Staffing. Since , the Elmira Heights and Horseheads school districts have reduced the level

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Staffing. Since , the Elmira Heights and Horseheads school districts have reduced the level"

Frank Mathews
5 years ago
Views:

1 Staffing Since , the Elmira Heights and Horseheads school districts have reduced the level of services and the number of employees due to budgetary constraints and taxation regulations for public employers. Tables and 2 illustrate personnel loss that has occurred in both Elmira Heights and Horseheads between and During this period, Elmira Heights reduced the total instructional staff by 2.00 full-time equivalent (FTE teaching positions, 2% of the teaching staff. In the same period, Elmira Height reduced support staff positions by.6 FTE. In all, Elmira Heights lost FTE positions across all functions of the school district, or 5% of its workforce. Horseheads reduced teaching faculty by 53.0 FTE, 5% of the instructional staff, while also reducing support staff by 7 FTE (25%. Table Five Year Personnel Loss Elmira Heights Central School District Position Total Teachers ALS Elementary ELA Guidance LMS Music Reading Science Social Studies Speech Path Total Teachers

2 Instructional Support Teacher Aide Playground Aide Total Non-Instructional Support Dir. Of Facilities Bus Driver Bus Mechanic.0.00 Cafeteria Aide Cleaner Clerk Typist/Sec Courier Custodian Total Administrators HR/Ass t. Principal Curriculum Coordinator Business Official (To CBO Total Positions Lost * * No cuts due to application of reserves and employee health insurance restructure

3 Table 2 Five-Year Personnel Loss Horseheads Central School District Position Total Teachers Alt. Ed.0.0 Art Business.0.0 Elementary English.0.0 FACS.0.0 LMS LOTE Math Music PE Reading.0.0 Science.0.0 Social Studies Special Education Technology Curriculum Coord..0.0 Inst. Support.0.0 Total Instructional Support Library Clerk.0.0 Teacher Aide.0.0 Teacher Assistant Total Non-Instructional Support Director of Facilities Building Maint. Mech..0.0 Bus Driver Bus Mechanic Cleaner Clerical Food Service RN/LPN Monitor Total

4 Administrators Data Administrator.0.0 Ass t. Superintendent.0.0 HS Ass t Principal.0.0 Business Official (To CBO.0.0 AD (reduction.0.0 Principal.0.0 Director of Facilities Total Positions Lost Table 3 presents a comparison of the 204 staffing levels in Elmira Heights and Horseheads. Table Staffing Comparison Elmira Heights Horseheads Position Elmira Heights Horseheads District Administration Superintendent Adm. Ass t./district Clerk 2 Director of Elementary Education Director of Secondary Education Assistant Director of Elementary/ Secondary Education Director of Student Services Data Manager/Central Enrollment Community Information Specialist PPS Secretaries 3 CSE Chair.5 2 Director of Human Resources Position Elmira Heights Horseheads Director Athletics, Health, PE Stipend.8 Network Cord./IT Supervisor ( ( IT Techs ( 7 ( Clerical HR.8 4

5 Business Administration Business Administrator (CBO (CBO District Treasurer.5 (CBO Deputy Treasurer/Accountant.8 (CBO Payroll/Benefits Clerk.4 (CBO.5 (CBO Purchasing Agent/Clerk.7 (CBO Accounts Payable Clerk.4 (CBO.05 (CBO Principal Clerk Internal Auditor TST TST Benefits Specialist Clerical Support/Tax Collector Building Administration Elementary Principal 5 Elementary Ass t. Principal 0 Middle School Principal MS Assistant Principal 0 High School Principal HS Assistant Principal 0 2 Dean of Students (no admin. cert. 2 Instructional Coach/Reading First Guidance Counselors 2 7 Secretaries (Building & Guidance

6 Instructional Staff - Teachers Pre-K 5 Elementary (K-6 Pre-K 5 Special Education 4 7 (K-6 K 5 Art.8 4 (K-6 K 5 Music 7 (K-6 K 5 PE 2 6 (K-6 Math Intervention Specialist 2 K-2 Reading Specialist English 3 6 ( Math ( Science 3 6 ( Social Studies ( LOTE 5 ( Special Education 3 7 ( Art.2 2 ( Music 3 ( FACS 2 ( PE 2 ( Technology 3 ( Health.5 2 ( English Math Math AIS Science Social Studies LOTE Special Education Art Music FACS Business PE Technology 9 2 Health.5 3 6

7 Position Elmira Heights Horseheads ESL 2 Reading Specialists 4 6 Library Media Specialist 2 6 Teaching Assistants Special Education 2 34 Title I Reading 4 Classroom 9 9 Instructional Support Nurses/Health Services 3 9 Psychologists Occupational Therapists.8 ( 2 Physical Therapists.27 ( 2 Teacher Aides Special Education 2 Teacher Aides-UPK Social Work Assistants 4 9 Director of Facilities Buildings and Grounds Shared Head Custodians Department Secretary Custodial Workers Cleaners 2 23 Building Maintenance Mechanic 6 Facilities Service 5 7

8 Position Elmira Heights Horseheads Transportation Transportation Supervisor Dispatcher 2 Bus Drivers (full-time 8 66 Bus Drivers (part-time School Bus Mechanic 6 Courier Bus Attendant 6 Equipment Service Manager Safety Examiner Food Service Food Service Manager/Director Shared ( School Lunch Workers 5 37 Teacher Aides 3 School Monitors 6 Athletics Head Coaches Ass t Coaches 2 2 Life Guard 8

9 Table 4 compares the staffing in the Elmira Heights CSD and Horseheads CSD with a consolidated staffing projection The table is divided into discreet functional staffing areas to demonstrate current staffing levels, current combined levels, projected consolidated staffing levels, the net change in staffing, and finally, cost adjustment projections for a consolidated district. The cost adjustment projections reflect not only salary for the various positions listed, but also mandated benefit expenses such as the district s contribution to the NYS retirement systems and FICA and its share of negotiated health plan premiums. The District Administration section of Table 3 includes all central office functions, with the exception of business operations. The table notes the expected reductions in administrative personnel that would be achieved by consolidating the districts. Savings are projected in the District Business Operations section of Table 3, due primarily to the elimination of duplicated positions in a merged district. The Building Staffs section includes school building administration, guidance services and clerical support. While this scenario indicates a reduction of high school and middle school principals, it includes the addition of assistant principals to serve the larger middle and high school populations. Despite the addition of grade 5 to each elementary school, this scenario does not anticipate the need for additional administrative support at the elementary schools. The Instructional Staff-Teachers section of Table 8 requires specific explanation. To anticipate the number of teachers needed in a consolidated district, enrollment and class size projections were considered. The Community Advisory Committee expressed support for maintaining current average class sizes in a consolidated district. The projection provides for average class size in grades K-2 to be 20 students, Grades 3-5 to be 22 and Grades 6-2 average class size to be 24. Thus, the number of teachers needed (as reflected in the FTE 9

10 Needed column was established by dividing the anticipated enrollment at the designated grade levels by average class sizes to determine the number of sections required. By this scenario a consolidated district may require 2.35 FTE fewer teachers to provide for all of the academic opportunities currently offered in the two districts. The projection anticipates 3 fewer Teaching Assistants due to an anticipated reduction in Special Education teaching staff. Instructional Support/Services staffing includes the addition of a school psychologist to account for current staffing inadequacy. Buildings and Grounds includes reductions in clerical, mechanic and custodial worker services. Additional reductions may be possible should the consolidated district determine to decommission excess building space once a transition to a consolidated district is accomplished. Within Transportation Operations, a reduction of one Transportation Supervisor is somewhat offset by the addition of 0 drivers to accommodate anticipated door-to-door transportation of Elmira Heights students according to the Horseheads BOE policy. An additional bus mechanic is anticipated to service the 8 additional buses needed to meet the policy. Additional transportation staffing adjustments might also occur, depending on the results of a more complete analysis of transportation services should consolidation be approved. Food Service Operations would see the reduction of a.0 FTE ( leadership position, given the combined district operation. Additional reductions in staffing might also occur, depending on decisions yet to be made regarding the number and location of cafeterias. Finally, the Athletics-Coaching section reflects a reduction in the number of head coaches and an increase in the number of assistant coaches, resulting from the athletic restructuring scenario previously discussed. Ultimately, the level of student interest and participation on each team will determine final coaching level requirements. 0

11 Position Elmira Heights Table 4 Consolidated District Staffing Horsehead s Total Consol. Need Net Change Cost Adjustme nt. District Administration Superintendent ,75 Administrative Assistant/ District Clerk Director of Elementary Education Director of Secondary Education Ass t. Director: Elementary/Secondar y Ed. Data Manager/Central Enrollment , ( Director of Student 0 Services CSE Chair PPS Secretaries Human Resources 0 Director Human Resources Clerical ,442 Director of Athletics, Stipend -8, PE and Health Network 2( - Coordinator/IT ( ( Supervisor -04,00 IT Technicians Community Information Specialist District Administration Totals ( ( 8 ( 8 ( ,4

12 2. District Business Operations Elmira Heights Horseheads Total Consol. Need Net Change Cost Adjustment Business Office (CBO (CBO 2 (CBO - -05,925 (CBO Administrator (CBO Treasurer ,973 (CBO (CBO CBO Deputy District.8(CBO.8 0.8(CBO Treasurer/Accountant (CBO Payroll/Benefits.4.5 (CBO ,458.5(CBO Clerk (CBO (CBO CBO Purchasing Agent/Clerk.7 (CBO.7 (CBO.4 (CBO.4 (CBO 0 Accounts Clerk (CBO (CBO +CBO (CBO Principal Clerk ,265 Internal Auditor TST TST 0 Benefits Specialist Clerical/Tax (CBO 0 Collector District Business Office Totals.5 3 (CBO (CBO (CBO (CBO CBO -220, Net Cost 3. Building Staffs Elmira Horseheads Total Consol. Change Adjustment Heights Need Elementary Principal ,094 Elementary Ass t. 0 0 Principal Middle School ,036 Principal Middle School ,020 Assistant Principal High School ,596 Principal High School ,04 Assistant Principal Dean of Students (no ,726 admin. cert. Instructional ,557 Coach/Reading First Guidance Counselors Secretaries (Building ,469 2

13 and Guidance Building Staffs Totals ,472 3

14 4. Instructional Staff-Teachers Enrollme nt Averag e Class Size Section s Needed FTE Needed Combine d FTE Net Chang e Cost Adjustme nt Pre-K Kindergarten Grade Grades K 5 Elementary Grades 6-8 Core (English, Math, Science, S.S. Grades 9-2 Core (English, Math, Science, S.S , ,264 K-2 Reading Specialists NA NA NA K-2 Math Specialists NA NA NA PreK - Grade 2 Sp. N/A N/A N/A ,358 Education K - 2 Art ,937 K - 2 Music (General, Instrumental, 7200 N/A N/A Choral K - 2 Physical Education ,928 Grades 6 2 (FACS ,96 Grades 7-2 LOTE Grades 7-2 Technology Grades 7 2 Health , , ,72 4

15 Grades 9 2 Business Speech/Langua ge N/A N/A N/A 7 (.5 7 (.5 ESL N/A N/A N/A Library-Media N/A N/A N/A Specialists 0-54,02 Instructional Staff- Teachers-Total ( ( ,30 5

16 5. Teaching Assistants Special Education Title I Reading; Libraries Elmira Heights Horsehead s Total Consol. Need Net Chang e Cost Adjustmen t , Classroom Teaching ,974 Assistants- Totals Instructional Support/Service s Elmira Heights Horsehead s Total Consol. Need Net Chang e Cost Adjustmen t Nurses/Health Services Psychologists Occupational Therapists Physical Therapist Teacher Aides- Special Education Social Work Assistants Instructional Support/Service s Totals 7. Buildings and Grounds Director of Facilities Department Secretary Building Maintenance 3.8 (.27 ( ,078 7 ( (.5 2 (+.8 2 (.27 9 (.5 2 (.8 2 ( Elmira Heights Horsehead s Total B0CES Consol. Need (Shared + +7, ,832 Net Chang e Cost Adjustmen t ,833 6

17 Mechanic Custodial 0-70,272 Workers Cleaners ,634 Head Cleaner Head Plumber Plumber Head Carpenter Working Foreman Courier Buildings and Grounds Totals ,239 7

18 8. Transportation Elmira Heights Horseheads Total Consol. Need Net Change Cost Adjustment Transportation Supervisor ,703 Dispatcher Bus Drivers (full +284, * +0 time School Bus +50, Mechanics Equipment Service Manager 0 Safety Examiner 0 School Bus Attendant Transportation Operations Total , Food Service Food Service Cook Manager/ Director School Lunch Workers Senior Food Elmira Heights Horseheads Shared ( Total Consol. Need Net Change ** Cost Adjustment ,302 Service Helper Cooks ,58 School Aides School Monitors Food Service Totals , Athletics Coaching Stipends Elmira Heights Horseheads Total Consol. Need Net Change Cost Adjustment Head Coaches ,265 Assistant Coaches ,9 Life Guard Athletic Stipends Total ,46 8

19 Table 5 summarizes the data contained in Table 3. As noted, this staffing scenario suggests, at minimum, a merged district could anticipate the reduction of approximately 3 positions, compared to current staffing levels, at a savings of over one and a half million dollars. In reflecting on these cost savings it is important to keep in mind the information that began this chapter; that is, before a consolidation was even contemplated, the districts reduced annual staffing by 50 positions in an effort to address the loss of State revenue and increased expenses. It is also important to recognize that this scenario would serve to significantly enhance the academic and extra-curricular with minimal decreases in teaching staff. Finally, as noted, additional non-teaching staffing reductions may be achieved following more detailed analyses of specific administrative and support services, should a decision to consolidate be made. Consolidated District Summary. District Administration 2. District Business Office 3. Building Staffs Elmira Heights CBO Table 5 Consolidated District Summary Horseheads CBO 4. Teachers Teaching Assistants 6. Instructional Support Total CBO Consolidated Need CBO Net Change CBO Cost Adjustment -420, , , , , , Buildings and Grounds , ,097 9

20 Transportation 9. Food Service 0. Athletics- Coaching Stipends Consolidated District Totals , , CBO CBO CBO CBO CBO - -,544,665 20

21 2

Milton Public Schools Fiscal Year 2018 Budget Presentation

Milton Public Schools Fiscal Year 2018 Budget Presentation 1 Background 2 How does Milton s per-pupil spending compare to other communities? Boston $18,372 Dedham $17,780 Randolph $16,051 Quincy $16,023