Annex-A to the Minutes of 74-EA&QEC/EAB Meeting held on November 18-19, at PEC HQ Islamabad. Agenda Item No. 03 (a) Consideration of PEC Visit Reports [Accreditation/Re-accreditation, Confirmatory, Review, Re-visit] S# Name of University/ Profile Decision of 74-EA&QEC/EAB 01. Balochistan University of Information Technology, and Management Sciences, Quetta (Takatoo Campus) B.Sc. Textile i.e., Intake of Batch 2011 only. Visit Type Re-Accreditation The accreditation of 2012 batch is subject Date of Visit July 14-15,, to compliance on establishment/ strengthening of labs and library (addition of books relevant to the program) as indicated by the visitation team. The compliance should be intimated to PEC with evidence(s) in order to proceed for the SRO of intake batch 2012 and consideration of request for onwards batches. 02. Balochistan University of Information Technology, and Management Sciences, Quetta (Takatoo Campus) B.Sc. Electronics Date of Visit July 13-14, Intake must be restricted to 50 students per year w.e.f 2014 onwards 03. Balochistan University of Information Technology, and Management Sciences, Quetta (Takatoo Campus) B.Sc. Computer Visit Type Re-Accreditation Date of Visit July 14-15, Intake must be restricted to 50 students per year w.e.f 2014 onwards. 1
04. Balochistan University of Information Technology, and Management Sciences, Quetta (Takatoo Campus) B.Sc. Civil Visit Type Re-Accreditation Intake must be restricted to 100 students Date of Visit July 13-14, per year (two sections of 50 students each) w.e.f 2014 onwards. 05. International Islamic College (Riphah International University), Islamabad B.Sc. Bio-Medical Visit Type Re-Accreditation Date of Visit July 31 & August 1, 06. International Islamic College (Riphah International University, Islamabad B.Sc. Electrical (Communication & Electronics) Accredited Re-Accreditation Visit Type Date of Visit JULY 30-31, 07. The Superior College, Lahore B.Sc. Electrical Date of Visit July 29-30, The intake must be restricted to 50 students per year. 2 08. The University of Faisalabad B.E. Electrical (Electronics, Computer System) Date of Visit August 3-4,
09. The University of Faisalabad B.E. Chemical Date of Visit August 5-6, 10. The University of Faisalabad B.E. Textile The minimum number of faculty members required for the purpose of accreditation of a program comprising of one section are Date of Visit August 4-5, eight (8) which has not been fulfilled by the university including at-least one PhD in relevant area of engineering. Therefore, accreditation is recommended for one year for intake batch 2010 (passed-out) subject to employment of the required faculty members. 11. University of and Technology, Lahore (Main Campus) B.Sc. Mechatronics & Control Date of Visit July 27-28, The intake must be restricted to 50 students per year. 12. Abasyn University, Peshawar B.E. Electrical Visit Type Re-Accreditation Date of Visit August 12-13, 13. CECOS University of IT and Emerging Sciences, Peshawar B. Sc. Civil Visit Type Re-Accreditation Date of Visit 24-25 August, 14. Mirpur University of Science and Technology(MUST), Mirpur A&JK B.Sc. Computer Systems 3
4 Date of Visit September 1-2, Further, the intake batch 2012 is also recommended to be accredited subject to the compliance regarding the following observations duly verified by PEC:- a. To ensure that atleast one PhD faculty joins the department as promised. b. To ensure that the current grading system is revised as promised. c. To ensure that the number of titles of books in library related to computer engineering are increased. 15. Balochistan University of Information Technology, and Management Sciences, Quetta B.Sc. Chemical Visit Type Re-Accreditation Date of Visit September 14-15, The intake must be restricted to 50 students per year. 16. Balochistan University of Information Technology, and Management Sciences, Quetta B.Sc. Petroleum & Gas Date of Visit September 15-16, 17. Balochistan University of Information Technology, and Management Sciences, Quetta B.Sc. Mining Date of Visit September 16-17, 18. Balochistan University of Information Technology, and Management Sciences, Quetta B.Sc. Telecommunication
The intake must be restricted to 50 students per year. Date of Visit September 17-18, 19. Foundation University Islamabad (Rawalpindi Campus) B.Sc. Telecommunication Date of Visit September 11-12, 20. University of and Technology, Lahore (Main Campus) B.Sc. Geological Date of Visit September 18-19, 21. University College of and Technology, (BZU) Multan B.Sc. Building & Architectural Date of Visit August 5-6, i.e., Intake of Batches 2010 and 2011. i.e., Intake of Batches 2009 and 2010. The intake batch of 2011 (evening) should be merged with intake batch 2011 (morning). Thus it should be named as one batch 2011 only. The University must hire at east one relevant qualified PhD faculty member. Or add atleast two more faculty members having MS qualified with fifteen years experience. 22. Institute of and Technology, Gomal University, D. I. Khan B.Sc. Electrical Re-accreditation is recommended for (Telecommunication) Intake of Batch 2011 subject to submission of notification of the enclosure of Faculty of in the statutes. Visit Type Accreditation Date of Visit September 18 & 19, 5
6 23. Iqra National University, Peshawar B.Sc. Civil Visit Type Re-Accreditation Date of Visit October 2-3, The intake must be restricted to 80 students per year (from and onwards) as per the latest revision in scope. 24. University of Science and Technology, Bannu 1. Electrical For Both s: (Telecommunicatio n) 2. Software Visit Type Verification Date of Visit September 17, 25. Government College University, Faisalabad B.Sc. Electrical (Telecommunication) Date of Visit August 17-18, 26. Wah College, Wah Cantt. B.Sc. Chemical Date of Visit August 4-5, 27. Wah College, Wah Cantt. B.Sc. Mechatronics Visit Type Re-Accreditation Date of Visit August 5-6, i.e., Intake of Batch 2011 only. The university should address the weak areas/observations as mentioned in the visit report. Further to observe CQI, university/institute has to submit separate progress report alongwith evidence to PEC, while applying for subsequent reaccreditation. The university should address the weak areas/observations as mentioned in the visit report. Further to observe CQI, university/institute has to submit separate progress report alongwith evidence to
PEC, while applying for subsequent reaccreditation. 28. Dawood University of and Technology, Karachi B.E. Electronics Accredited Visit Type - Date of Visit October 2-3, 29. COMSATS Islamabad (Lahore Campus) B.S. Chemical Visit Type - Date of Visit July 30-31, 30. Wah College, Wah Cantt. B.S. Electrical Date of Visit August 3-4, The intake must be restricted to 80 students per year, otherwise no reaccreditation request shall be entertained. Re-accreditation is granted for Intake of Batch 2011 (Spring & Fall) only, subject to commitment to comply single intake policy of PEC. The intake must be restricted to 100 students per year. Intake of Spring must be stopped. i.e., Intake of Batch 2011 only. The university should address the weak areas/observations as mentioned in the visit report. Further to observe CQI, university/institute has to submit separate progress report alongwith evidence to PEC, while applying for subsequent reaccreditation. 31. Institute of Quality and Technology Management, University of the Punjab B.Sc. Industrial & Management Re-accreditation is granted for three years i.e., Intake of Batches 2011, 2012 and 2013. Date of Visit November 2-3, The intake must be restricted to 50 students per year. 7
32. Sharif College of & Technology, affiliated with University of and Technology, Lahore a. B.Sc. Electrical For Both s: Under Process Based on verification of evidence provided Visit Type Accreditation by Sharif College of & Technology, Lahore, the accreditation is Date of Visit May 29-30, granted for one year i.e., Intake of Batch b. B.Sc. Chemical 2011 only. Under Process The Intake must be restricted to 50 students per year. Visit Type Accreditation Date of Visit May 28-29, The university should address the weak areas/observations as mentioned in the visit report. Further to observe CQI, university/institute has to submit separate progress report alongwith evidence to PEC, while applying for subsequent reaccreditation. 33. CECOS University of IT and Emerging Sciences, Peshawar B.Sc. Electrical i.e., Intake of Batch 2011 only. Visit Type Re-Accreditation Date of Visit OCTOBER 12-13, 34. Iqra University, Islamabad Campus (Iqra University, Karachi) B.E. Electronics From Intake of Batch i.e., Intake of Batch 2011 only. Visit Type 2008 upto 2010. Re-accreditation Date of Visit November 10-11, The university should address the weak areas/observations as mentioned in the visit report. Further to observe CQI, university/institute has to submit separate progress report alongwith evidence to PEC, while applying for subsequent reaccreditation. 35. Abasyn University, Peshawar B.E. Electrical Permission is granted to increase the intake upto 80 students per year (40 Visit Type Change Of Scope students per section). (Increase in Intake) Date of Visit August 12-13, The university must ensure that specialization specific faculty is available for the specializations being offered to the students. 8
36. COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, ISLAMABAD (Main Campus) B.Sc. Electrical (Power) Under Process Permission is granted to continue the program from Intake of Batch 2013 and onwards. Date of Visit February 28, 2013 (Zero visit) 37. Wah College, Wah Cantt. B.Sc. Electrical Visit Type Change of Scope (Increase in Intake) Date of Visit August 04, Increase in intake is granted for 30 students (total intake must be restricted to 80 students per year with two sections) from Fall year. Department should provide training to the faculty to move to outcome based education system. 38. City University of Science and Information Technology, Peshawar B.Sc. Electrical (Telecommunication Change of Scope is approved for addition of Electronics stream w.e.f. Fall- within the allowed intake of 80 students of and Power) B.Sc. Electrical (Telecommunication & Power). Visit Type Chang of Scope (Addition of Electronics stream) Date of Visit September 5, Note: Intake of 40 students per year is allowed for Power stream w.e.f. Fall-2013 and onwards. 39. Swedish College of and Technology, Rahim Yar Khan B.Sc. Mechanical Visit Type Change of Scope (Increase Intake) Date of Visit August 28, Due to contrary observations in the report by the team, increase in intake is deferred. However, the house recommended revisit be conducted at the charge of the fee from the Institute/College. 40. Muhammad Ali Jinnah University, Islamabad Campus B.S. Mechanical Accreditation is granted for one year i.e., Intake of Batch 2011. First accreditation Visit Type Accreditation Date of Visit August 7-8, --- 9
10 Annex-A1 to the Minutes of 74-EA&QEC/EAB Meeting held on November 18-19, at PEC HQ Islamabad. Agenda Item No. 03 (A) Consideration of PEC Visit Reports [Accreditation/Re-accreditation] (OBE / PEC Accreditation Manual-2014) S# Name of University/ Profile Decision of 73-EA&QEC/EAB 01. Military College of, Risalpur (NUST Islamabad) B.E. Civil 1. Re-accreditation is granted for two years i.e., Intake of Batches 2011 and Visit Type 2012 (under Level-2 OBE Accreditation System). a. Accreditation b. Change of Scope (Increase in Intake) Date of Visit April 8-10, 2. The intake must be restricted to 160 students per year. 02. Center for Advanced Studies in, Islamabad (UET Taxila) B.Sc. Electrical (Computer or Telecommunication) Visit Type Re-Accreditation Date of Visit August 26-28, Re-accreditation is granted for three years i.e., Intake of Batches 2011, 2012 and 2013 (under Level-2, OBE Accreditation System). 03. Institute of Space Technology, Islamabad BS Materials Science and Accredited Accreditation is granted for two years i.e., Intake of Batches 2012 and 2013 (under Level-2, OBE Accreditation System). Date of Visit 14-15 September, 04. College of Electrical and Mechanical, Rawalpindi Campus (NUST Islamabad) B.E. Computer Re-accreditation is granted for three years i.e., Intake of Batches 2012, 2013 and 2014 (under Level-2, OBE Accreditation Date of Visit August 10-12, 2014 System). ---
Annex-B to the Minutes of 74-EA&QEC/EAB Meeting held on November 18-19, at PEC HQ Islamabad. 11 Agenda Item No. 03 (b) Consideration of PEC Visit Reports [Zero, Interim, Change of Scopes (Nomenclature/Increase in Intake), Confirmatory] S# Name of University/ Profile Decision of 73-EA&QEC/EAB 01. Quaid-e-Awam University of, Science & Technology, Nawabshah a. B.E (Telecommunication ) - For both s The case was referred to the subcommittee constituted under Item No.08 of Visit Type Zero the agenda of meeting. Date of Visit September 2, b. B.E Chemical - Visit Type Zero Date of Visit 20-08- 02. Abasyn University Peshawar ( Islamabad Campus) Bachelor of in Electrical Under Process The observations during Zero Visit have been addressed satisfactorily; therefore, the program may proceed ahead. The observations of the report must be addressed and compliance/progress Date of Visit July 31, report be submitted before Accreditation Visit request. The Moderation Committee has shown serious concern that interim visit was delayed by one year by the university. The house strictly advised to send a warning letter to the university for future compliance. 03. University of Management and Technology, Lahore B.S. Industrial The observations during Zero Visit have been addressed satisfactorily; therefore, Under process the program may proceed ahead. The observations of the report must be Date of Visit 27 July, addressed and compliance/progress report be submitted before Accreditation Visit request. The Moderation Committee has shown serious concern that interim visit was delayed by one year by the university. The
04. University of Sargodha, Sargodha B.Sc. Mechanical Under Process Date of Visit 10-08- 05. Bahria University Islamabad ( Karachi Campus) Bachelor of in Computer Under Process Date of Visit September 14, 12 house strictly advised to send a warning letter to the university for future compliance. The observations during Zero Visit have been addressed satisfactorily; therefore, the program may proceed ahead. The observations of the report must be addressed and compliance/progress report be submitted before Accreditation Visit request. The observations (deficiencies & weak areas) from the zero visit have been addressed partially, therefore, the program may proceed further with the conditions to rectify before next intake/enrollment (Confirmatory visit shall be conducted to verify the compliance/progress report of HEIs before next enrollment/intake). In case of non-compliance the program shall be discontinued. 06. COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Abbottabad Campus B.S. Civil The observations during Zero Visit have Under Process been addressed satisfactorily; therefore, the program may proceed ahead. Date of Visit August 4, The observations of the report must be addressed and compliance/progress report must be submitted before Accreditation Visit request. Otherwise, a strict action will be taken accordingly. 07. Iqra National University, Peshawar B.Sc. Electrical The university made no preparation for the increase in intake and hence increase is not granted. Visit Type CoS (Increase in Intake) Date of Visit July 28, The university may apply after enhancing all the facilities so that it can provide quality education to all students.
08. National University of Computer and Emerging Sciences, Peshawar Campus B.S. Electrical Accredited Permission is granted to increase in Intake from 80 to 120 students per year w.e.f. Fall and onwards. Visit Type Change of Scope (Increase in Intake) Date of Visit 29-07- 09. University of and Technology, Lahore (KSK Campus) B.Sc. Electrical Accredited Permission is granted to increase in Intake from 40 to 80 students per year w.e.f. Fall and onwards. Visit Type Change of Scope (Increase in Intake) It is also recommended to arrange Date of Visit July 28, separate faculty for B.Sc. technology program. 10. Hamdard Institute of and Technology, Karachi B.E Telecommunication Visit Type Change in Nomenclature/Schem e of Study (Relocating B.E Telecommunication as B.E (Electrical) Date of Visit August 18, 13 Change in nomenclature/scheme of study of the program is not recommended at this stage. The Institute is advised to address all the observations as mentioned in the visit report and intimate PEC for confirmation/verification before the interim visit of B.E (Electrical) if planning to start "Power" stream. 11. The University of Lahore, Lahore (Main Campus) B.Sc. Civil Accredited Permission is granted to increase in Intake from 120 to 160 students per year (40 per section) w.e.f. Fall and onwards. Visit Type Change of Scope (Increase in Intake) Date of Visit September 17, 12. The University of Lahore, Lahore (Main Campus) B.Sc. Mechanical Accredited Permission is granted to increase of one additional section of 40 students from Fall- and onwards. After this, total three Visit Type Change of Scope sections of 40 section each with (Increase in Intake) cumulative strength of 120. Date of Visit September 18, 13. COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Islamabad (Main Campus) B. Sc. Electronics Under Process The Observations during zero visit have been addressed satisfactorily; therefore, the program may proceed ahead. Date of Visit September 10, The observations of the report must be addressed and compliance/progress
report be submitted before accreditation request. 14. University College of and Technology, University of Sargodha B.Sc. Electrical The observations (deficiencies & weak areas) from the zero visit have been Under Process addressed partially, therefore, the program may proceed further with the Date of Visit August 3, following conditions to rectify before next intake/enrollment. Confirmatory visit shall be conducted to verify the compliance/progress report of HEI before next enrollment/intake):- 14 a) Laboratories need to be organized and their lists of experiments should include all major practical experiments. b) Lab manuals should be prepared properly and reasonable records need to be maintained regarding students lab performance and its assessment. c) Equipment in most of the major labs needs to be improved and arrangements should be made to utilize unused equipment for lab experiments. In this regard, lab engineers need to be trained properly. d) The problem of faculty shortage and retention need to be dealt on concrete basis. 15. COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Wah Campus B.Sc. Civil The observations during Zero Visit have been addressed satisfactorily; therefore, Under Process the program may proceed ahead. Date of Visit August 10, The observations of the report must be addressed and compliance/progress report be submitted before Accreditation Visit request. 16. University of Agriculture Faisalabad B.Sc. Food Under Process Visit Type Confirmatory (of Interim) Note: The house shown serious concern that interim visit was delayed by the university. The 1 st Accreditation Visit may be arranged after two months in order to confirm the progress/initiative regarding purchase of equipment in labs and starting construction of new dedicated engineering
Date of Visit October 28, block subject to issuance of the development budget for the program and start of development work. 15 As the batch 2011 has passed-out, therefore the presence of students pertaining to this batch may be ensured in the final accreditation visit in order to interact with them. It was observed that the whole younger faculty including those having PhD in Food are not comfortable with the working of retired teachers/reappointments whose basic degree is Agricultural, and therefore the faculty is not developed in the related discipline. The number of teachers without basic degree of Food must be limited. The retired professors have been re-hired on Rs.75,000/- as subject experts may fulfill the purpose/requirement for the time being; however, it is recommended that, after the appointment of relevant faculty of Food engineering, this concept of hiring the retired lot may be discouraged. 17. NFC Institute of & Fertilizer Research Jaranwala Road, Faisalabad B.Sc. Civil Visit Type Change of Scope (Increase in Intake) Date of Visit October 19, Increase in intake is granted for 40 students to 80 students per year with two sections) from Fall- and onward. Observations of the visitation team must be addressed. 18. Punjab Institute of Contemporary Sciences, affiliated with the University of Punjab, Lahore B.Sc. Electrical - Green signal is granted with intake of 40 students per year w.e.f Fall subject to verification of joining of faculty, Lab Visit Type Zero Visit Engineers, and availability of required Date of Visit Oct. 29, Labs etc. by Engr Prof Dr Jamil Ahmad, member EAQEC/EAB. ---
Annex-A2 to the Minutes of 74-EA&QEC/EAB Meeting (endorsement/approval based on major compliance/progress) held on November 18-19, at PEC HQ, Islamabad. 16 S# Name of University 1. Swedish College of and Technology, Rahim Yar Khan (The Islamia University of Bahawalpur) 2. COMSATS Institute of Information Technology, Sahiwal Campus B.Sc. Mechanical B.Sc. Mechanical Decision Intake of Batch 2010 only. Intake of Batch 2010 only. Endorsement/Approval of 74-EA&QEC Based on the major compliance as per the 70th EA&QEC decision, accreditation is granted for one year i.e., Intake of Batch 2010 only. Based on the comittment by the Rector, CIIT and progress on various observations, accreditation is granted for one year i.e. Intake of Batch 2010 only. 3. NED University of and Technology, Karachi B.E. Mechanical Intake of Batch 2010-11 only. Based on the major compliance as per the 71- EA&QEC decision, reaccreditation is granted for one year i.e., Intake of Batch 2010-11 only. 4. University College of and Technology, Multan (BZU Multan) B.Sc. Mechanical Intake of Batch 2010 only. Based on the major compliance as per the 71- EA&QEC decision, reaccreditation is granted for one year i.e., Intake of Batch 2010 only. 5. University College of Agriculture, Multan (BZU Multan) B.Sc. Agricultural Intake of Batches 2008 and 2009. Based on the satisfactory compliance by the university as recommended in 71 st EA&QEC meeting, reaccreditation is granted for two years Intake of Batches 2008 & 2009. 6. National Textile University, Faisalabad B.Sc. Polymer Intake of Batches 2010 & 2011. Based on the major compliance as per the 71- EA&QEC decision, reaccreditation is granted for two years i.e., Intake of Batches 2010 & 2011 only.
17 7. Fatima Jinnah Women University, Rawalpindi B.Sc. Software Intake of Batch 2009 only. Based on the major compliance as per the 71- EA&QEC decision, reaccreditation is granted for one year i.e., Intake of Batch 2009 only. ---