Year 7. How Science Works. Badger Key Stage 3 Science Level-Assessed Tasks. Andrew Grevatt. Badger Publishing

Similar documents
P a g e 1. Grade 5. Grant funded by:

LITERACY ACROSS THE CURRICULUM POLICY

The Political Engagement Activity Student Guide

Providing Feedback to Learners. A useful aide memoire for mentors

Formative Assessment in Mathematics. Part 3: The Learner s Role

MADERA SCIENCE FAIR 2013 Grades 4 th 6 th Project due date: Tuesday, April 9, 8:15 am Parent Night: Tuesday, April 16, 6:00 8:00 pm

This document has been produced by:

Evidence-based Practice: A Workshop for Training Adult Basic Education, TANF and One Stop Practitioners and Program Administrators

Physics 270: Experimental Physics

Science Fair Project Handbook

School Experience Reflective Portfolio

Case study Norway case 1

Unpacking a Standard: Making Dinner with Student Differences in Mind

Improving Conceptual Understanding of Physics with Technology

STRETCHING AND CHALLENGING LEARNERS

INSTRUCTIONAL FOCUS DOCUMENT Grade 5/Science

PART C: ENERGIZERS & TEAM-BUILDING ACTIVITIES TO SUPPORT YOUTH-ADULT PARTNERSHIPS

TA Script of Student Test Directions

Julia Smith. Effective Classroom Approaches to.

Creative Media Department Assessment Policy

This Performance Standards include four major components. They are

Numeracy Medium term plan: Summer Term Level 2C/2B Year 2 Level 2A/3C

St Michael s Catholic Primary School

AGS THE GREAT REVIEW GAME FOR PRE-ALGEBRA (CD) CORRELATED TO CALIFORNIA CONTENT STANDARDS

White Paper. The Art of Learning

Unit: Human Impact Differentiated (Tiered) Task How Does Human Activity Impact Soil Erosion?

What is this species called? Generation Bar Graph

Classroom Teacher Primary Setting Job Description

Office Hours: Mon & Fri 10:00-12:00. Course Description

Classroom Assessment Techniques (CATs; Angelo & Cross, 1993)

Mathematics process categories

Assessment Pack HABC Level 3 Award in Education and Training (QCF)

Curriculum Design Project with Virtual Manipulatives. Gwenanne Salkind. George Mason University EDCI 856. Dr. Patricia Moyer-Packenham

Why Pay Attention to Race?

EDUCATION AND TRAINING (QCF) Qualification Specification

Cal s Dinner Card Deals

FEEDBACK & MARKING POLICY. Little Digmoor Primary School

English Language Arts Summative Assessment

Function Tables With The Magic Function Machine

Feedback, Marking and Presentation Policy

Science Fair Rules and Requirements

RESPONSE TO LITERATURE

This map-tastic middle-grade story from Andrew Clements gives the phrase uncharted territory a whole new meaning!

Grade 3: Module 2B: Unit 3: Lesson 10 Reviewing Conventions and Editing Peers Work

level 5 (6 SCQF credit points)

Extending Place Value with Whole Numbers to 1,000,000

Presentation Advice for your Professional Review

Politics and Society Curriculum Specification

Professional Experience - Mentor Information

Assessment and Evaluation

Math 96: Intermediate Algebra in Context

Backstage preparation Igniting passion Awareness of learning Directing & planning Reflection on learning

Grade 4: Module 2A: Unit 1: Lesson 3 Inferring: Who was John Allen?

Liking and Loving Now and When I m Older

UDL AND LANGUAGE ARTS LESSON OVERVIEW

Paper Reference. Edexcel GCSE Mathematics (Linear) 1380 Paper 1 (Non-Calculator) Foundation Tier. Monday 6 June 2011 Afternoon Time: 1 hour 30 minutes

Business. Pearson BTEC Level 1 Introductory in. Specification

MENTORING. Tips, Techniques, and Best Practices

To provide students with a formative and summative assessment about their learning behaviours. To reinforce key learning behaviours and skills that

National Literacy and Numeracy Framework for years 3/4

University of Waterloo School of Accountancy. AFM 102: Introductory Management Accounting. Fall Term 2004: Section 4

How to make an A in Physics 101/102. Submitted by students who earned an A in PHYS 101 and PHYS 102.

NCSC Alternate Assessments and Instructional Materials Based on Common Core State Standards

MASTER S THESIS GUIDE MASTER S PROGRAMME IN COMMUNICATION SCIENCE

Characteristics of Functions

Kindergarten - Unit One - Connecting Themes

Thameside Primary School Rationale for Assessment against the National Curriculum

Coimisiún na Scrúduithe Stáit State Examinations Commission LEAVING CERTIFICATE 2008 MARKING SCHEME GEOGRAPHY HIGHER LEVEL

A Study of the Effectiveness of Using PER-Based Reforms in a Summer Setting

Exemplar 6 th Grade Math Unit: Prime Factorization, Greatest Common Factor, and Least Common Multiple

ECE-492 SENIOR ADVANCED DESIGN PROJECT

CHEM 101 General Descriptive Chemistry I

Teacher of Psychology and Health and Social Care

Thinking Maps for Organizing Thinking

Assessing speaking skills:. a workshop for teacher development. Ben Knight

OVERVIEW OF CURRICULUM-BASED MEASUREMENT AS A GENERAL OUTCOME MEASURE

The Common European Framework of Reference for Languages p. 58 to p. 82

ICTCM 28th International Conference on Technology in Collegiate Mathematics

Environmental Science: Earth s Resources (National 3) level 3 (6 SCQF credit points)

Similar Triangles. Developed by: M. Fahy, J. O Keeffe, J. Cooper

H EALTHCARE S CIENCE

Qualification handbook

EQuIP Review Feedback

"Be who you are and say what you feel, because those who mind don't matter and

The lab is designed to remind you how to work with scientific data (including dealing with uncertainty) and to review experimental design.

The Task. A Guide for Tutors in the Rutgers Writing Centers Written and edited by Michael Goeller and Karen Kalteissen

State University of New York at Buffalo INTRODUCTION TO STATISTICS PSC 408 Fall 2015 M,W,F 1-1:50 NSC 210

Teaching a Laboratory Section

Adaptations and Survival: The Story of the Peppered Moth

GCSE English Language 2012 An investigation into the outcomes for candidates in Wales

Mathematics Success Level E

Strategic Practice: Career Practitioner Case Study

Lesson M4. page 1 of 2

Probability and Statistics Curriculum Pacing Guide

Chapter 4 - Fractions

Dublin City Schools Mathematics Graded Course of Study GRADE 4

Lecturing Module

Researcher Development Assessment A: Knowledge and intellectual abilities

Scientific Method Investigation of Plant Seed Germination

Grade 4. Common Core Adoption Process. (Unpacked Standards)

Transcription:

Badger Key Stage 3 Science Level-Assessed Tasks Year 7 How Science Works Andrew Grevatt You may copy this book freely for use in your school. The pages in this book are copyright, but copies may be made without fees or prior permission provided that these copies are used only by the institution which purchased the book. For copying in any other circumstances, prior written consent must be obtained from the publisher. Badger Publishing

CONTENTS Task Topic Area Focus 7A Cells Observing cells under a microscope Oa 7B Reproduction Cloning humans debate A 7C Food chains & webs Investigating the conditions woodlice prefer P 7D Behaviour Investigating my cat s behaviour CE 7E Solids, liquids & gases Investigating evidence for the particle model OaC 7F Simple chemical reactions Investigating how metals react with acids OaC 7G Variation Obesity: Genetic or Environment? A 7H Acids & alkalis Investigating which indigestion tablet is the most effective P 7I Forces & their effects Investigating stretching forces CE 7J Forces & their effects Investigating the effect of slope angle on the speed of a toy car P 7K Energy sources Investigating which fuel is best P 7L Electrical circuits Investigating current in a series circuit OC 7M Geological Changes T. Rex: Predator or Scavenger? A 7N The solar system & beyond Investigating patterns in the Solar System ObC 7O Environment Investigating variation in our class Ob Exemplar Material Commentaries of assessed students work. Assessment Area Planning to collect evidence Obtaining evidence (observing and recording) Obtaining evidence (presenting evidence) Considering evidence Evaluating evidence Developing and Argument P Oa Ob C E A Acknowledgements This new edition is dedicated to my ever supportive parents, John and Kathy. Many people have helped me develop these tasks over the past year, both directly by using the tasks and indirectly through professional discussion. Without them, I would not have had the confidence to develop this material. I would like to particularly acknowledge the support of Matthew Newberry, Professor John Gilbert and the Cams Hill Science Consortium team (www.thinkingframe.com). The fantastic team at Badger Publishing for their hard work, commitment and belief in my work.

INTRODUCTION Welcome to the new updated version of the Badger Key Stage 3 Science Level Assessed Tasks. These tasks have been adapted to the new KS3 Science National Curriculum and improved in response to feedback and advances in the use of tasks such as these. Since the first book was published back in 2004, I have been delighted with the hugely positive response from some many teaching colleagues from around the country. Through providing training sessions to departments that have taken this approach to assessment for learning and having seen the tasks used in such a variety of ways I have been inspired to adapt and improve the tasks for the new Key Stage 3. Something I have noticed is that colleagues do not always have the opportunity to read this introduction. Almost all questions that are asked about these tasks can be answered by reading the introduction. Even if it is not the first time you are using these tasks, please task a few minutes to read through the next few pages. If you are the person responsible for initiating these tasks into your department, I would highly recommend giving your colleagues the opportunity to read a copy of this introduction during a department meeting and discuss their thoughts before using the tasks. I hope you and your pupils enjoy using these assessment tasks. I always welcome feedback on how you are using the tasks. Andrew Grevatt What s new? I have made some improvements to the tasks to make them even more effective for assessment for learning in science lessons. Level boundaries. The level boundaries have increased from two level ranges (3-5 and 5-7) to three level boundaries: Level 3-5, Level 5-7 and Level 7-EP (Exceptional Performance). The new National Curriculum does not have level descriptors for Level 3, so I have made an educated guess to the expectations at this level. The reason that I kept Level 3 in the ladder is because we are still going to have learners who are on the Level 3 and 4 border-line, so I thought it necessary to keep the descriptors in. I did consider calling these descriptors below level 4 and if you want to use that terminology, please feel free to change it. Science Concepts and How Science Works. I have divided the curriculum into Science Concepts and How Science Works to improve knowledge and understanding of key science concepts and to improve knowledge and understanding of HSW in the contexts of these concepts respectively.

Literacy and Numeracy Guidance. There are now additional literacy or numeracy ladders on each task. These have been added to support both teachers and learners in improving writing and numeracy in science. You will notice that there is different guidance on the tasks at each level boundary. This is based on the assumption that learners working at higher levels of science will be working at higher levels of literacy and numeracy. Obviously if you decide not to use these, they can easily removed before printing. Additional guidance on literacy and numeracy in science can be found online in the National Strategy materials. More Choice I have increased the number of tasks from twelve to fifteen in each of the books. Most of the original tasks remain, but a few colleagues reported that they found particular tasks more difficult to use and so these have been refined or replaced. There are also additional tasks to help assess the new concepts such as ethology (behaviour) and atmosphere. I have also added tasks based on developing an argument. Condensed Key Stage 3 Some schools and colleges are choosing the two year KS3 approach to science teaching. I have taken this into account when writing the new edition. Although the books are published in the format of Year 7, Year 8 and Year 9 topics, teachers can use any of the tasks at any point throughout KS3. Although I doubt many Year 7 learners will use the Level 7-EP tasks, the tasks themselves can be used at any stage in the Key Stage. KEY FEATURES OF THE HOW SCIENCE WORKS TASKS Ready to use tasks with popular science investigations from the QCA. Tasks matched to QCA topics, focusing on one or two areas of Sc1. A level ladder in learner-friendly vocabulary to guide progress, assessment and decide on improvement targets for the new How Science Works criteria. Uses assessment for learning principles to promote progression through science levels. Assesses knowledge and understanding of How Science Works skills. Excellent diagnostic tool for highlighting individual and class misconceptions. Encourages teacher and learner engagement with progression through How Science Works criteria, through the National Curriculum Levels. Levels based on National Curriculum Levels additional guidance on levels in science. Fully differentiated for Levels 3-EP. Actively promotes the development of literacy skills through scaffolding.

Introduction Imagine overhearing this conversation while Year 8 students are lining up outside your laboratory expecting to do an investigation: Faye: I am going to try to get a Level 5 in this investigation. Michelle: So am I. I got Level 4a last time, but I need to make sure I am going to make it more accurate today. Faye: How are you going to do that? Michelle: I am going to do repeats. Stephen: That doesn t make it accurate, that makes it more reliable. Michelle: That s what I meant, make it more reliable. Faye: Is that all you have to do to get a Level 5? Michelle: Yeah, look, I ll show you on my level ladder. That was one of those proud teacher moments. Everything I had been aiming to achieve with Assessment for Learning and Scientific Enquiry in science teaching was summed up by this short conversation. Everything had just slotted into place. The learners involved knew their current levels, had an improvement target and were discussing what they had to do in order to achieve that. Suddenly I felt my work was done! This class were starting to become independent learners, in charge of their learning and actually being able to decide on their own next steps for improving. The focus of science teaching at Key Stage 3 and 4 is being reemphasised due to the new demands of the National Tests and new GCSEs. The increased focus on How Science Works is leaving many science teachers feeling a little uneasy as we have to explicitly teach and level the more difficult area of Scientific Enquiry. This has always been the area I had felt less confident in communicating with my classes and developing and using level ladders has improved that greatly. Not only that, but the level ladders provide a framework through which I can communicate the skills required for scientific investigations with my students. Having used these in my department and with colleagues throughout my local education authority, it is clear that these tasks are giving other teachers and learners a similar experience. These tasks have been written to enhance the teaching and learning through our everyday science investigations. They can be used in exactly the same way as the Badger KS3 Science Concept Level-Assessed Tasks. However, I highly recommend that you read the following notes to ensure you and your students get the most out of them.

HOW TO USE THESE TASKS Each task is a simple open-ended task that assesses skill, knowledge and understanding of scientific investigation from a QCA topic. The tasks can be photocopied with the task sheet and the level ladder back-to-back or reduced so the task and level-ladder are side by side. The level ladder can be used by teachers and learners to guide their response to the task. Each task is now available in three level ranges: Levels 3-5, Levels 5-7 and levels 7-EP. I chose this split because most learners are either working towards Level 5 or working beyond Level 5. Level 5 requires learners to start using abstract concepts like energy, forces, particles and cells. Once they can use these concepts, they are able to access Levels 6 and beyond more easily. Most of the tasks are the similar for all level ranges, but the demand of the task, key words and level ladders are suited to the ability of the learners. As with all new approaches, learners may need to do a few of these tasks before they get the full benefit from them. The tasks are very open and, to start with, some learners can feel overwhelmed by the freedom. They may need a lot of support and encouragement for the first few; as their confidence grows, the learners gain more independence at attempting the tasks. Scientific Investigation Skill Focus I have divided the How Science Works criteria from the National Curriculum into six sections for easy assessment. These are P Oa Ob C E A Planning to collect evidence Obtaining evidence (observing and recording) Obtaining evidence (presenting evidence) Considering evidence Evaluating evidence Developing an Argument Developing Scientific Enquiry skills and Literacy Support It is becoming increasing clear that learners have trouble accessing Level 5 and above because they have limited literacy skills. These tasks have literacy support in the form of writing frames, cloze examples and sentence starters where appropriate. These supports are available for the tasks at Level 3-5, but removed from Level 6, 7, 8 & EP. Scientific enquiry skills have to be explicitly taught for learners to be able to develop these skills. There are many resources available for teachers to use to develop these skills. These resources can be used alongside the level ladder supported tasks to enhance the learning experience and develop learners scientific enquiry skills.

Big Ideas in Science The Framework is divided into six Big Ideas in Science Energy, Forces, Particles, Cells, Interdependence and Scientific Enquiry. The first five can be seen as the abstract concepts, meaning that when learners can use these Big Ideas they can start to access criteria for Level 5 and beyond. My level descriptors use this language to encourage learners to use these ideas, e.g. use the Big Idea of Energy to explain the chemical reaction. This acts as a prompt, rather than giving them the answers! General approaches As the tasks have evolved and been trialed, several approaches have been tried. These are outlined below. Whatever approach you decide to use, make sure that the tasks allow formative assessment. It is important that these are not used as replacement summative tests. They are designed to encourage learners to demonstrate what they understand and to have the opportunity to improve. This is the foundation of formative assessment strategies: Where am I now? What am I aiming for? How do I get there? The tasks are designed to give learners the opportunity to show their full potential in science. To ensure this, I allow the class to use their notes from exercise books, text books and other secondary sources to help them with the task. I also encourage the learners to talk with their peers about the task and discuss their ideas. This rarely leads them to copy each other, but does encourage the development of their ideas and challenges their misconceptions. Standard approach: When carrying out an investigation, it is recommended that only part investigations are carried out so that the teaching and learning of particular skills is focused. Even when doing a complete investigation, it is worth focusing on just one or two areas for assessment. Starter activity (5-10 minutes) to introduce the task. Make sure each learner knows which level they should be aiming for. Main activity (30-40 minutes) learners attempt task. Teacher circulates, encouraging use of the level ladder and challenging misconceptions. Plenary activity (10 minutes) self or peer assessment, where level ladders are used to decide on level and improvement targets. Homework activity make the improvement, teacher collects and assesses them, giving one improvement target. Alternative approaches: Set the task for homework after carrying out or demonstrating the investigation. This could be attempted as a draft. Then assess the homework with one or two improvement targets and then give some lesson time to support learners in making improvements.

Encouragement of use of level ladder Some learners find it difficult to use the level ladder to guide their work. Strategies I have seen used include: encouraging the learner to tick or highlight the statements on the level ladder when they think they have satisfied it; laminating level ladders which can be ticked off using whiteboard markers, then wiped clean. ASSESSMENT OF THE TASKS There are three approaches to assessing these tasks: teacher assessment, self assessment and peer assessment: Teacher assessment If you have not used these tasks before, I would recommend starting with the teacher assessment approach for assessing the learners responses to the tasks. These are not like the standard national tests, where you have very clear guidance of what answers to accept and not accept. This approach is much more flexible and requires the use of professional judgment when assigning a level. These tasks are not summative tests, so the level that is assigned to a learner s work is only a snapshot. Learners often vary in their level from skill to skill. A good analogy to use with them is that of computer games. Computer games are often based on levels of success. Some people score higher levels on some computer games than others. The same will be experienced when doing the level-assessed tasks. However, most learners show a general improvement trend when using these tasks. The level ladders are written in learner-friendly language, are related to National Curriculum Levels and have been matched with national science tests where possible. These should be used when assigning a level to a learner s work. Additional guidance is given for teachers in the teacher notes - this should be used alongside the level ladder. I take a very general approach to levelness, outlined in the table below. If I am ever in doubt, I refer back to this and consider the ability of the learner. Then, using professional judgment, I can assign a suitable level along with a suitable improvement target.

Planning P planning to collect evidence To get Learners should: level 3 Simply state what you are trying to find out. Suggest a simple way to investigate the question. Suggest one way to make it a fair test. State a prediction. 4 Decide on and write down a scientific question to investigate. Select and list suitable equipment for the investigation. Describe how you will investigate the question (write step-by-step instructions). Identify which variable (factor) you will change. Identify which variable (factor) you will measure. Identify which variables you will control (keep the same). State a simple prediction with a reason. State how will make sure you are safe while doing the experiment. 5 Decide on a suitable scientific question to investigate. Select suitable equipment for the investigation, stating reasons. Describe how you will investigate the question (write step-by-step instructions). Identify and explain which variable (factor) you will change and which variables (factors) you will keep the same. State the range of measurements you will make. State a prediction with a reason. Describe how you will make sure the investigation is safe for you and others. 6 As for Level 5, but using scientific knowledge and understanding and Plan to collect repeat measurements. Describe how you will make the measurements precise. Make a prediction based on scientific knowledge and understanding. Describe the risks involved and the actions you will take to control them. If appropriate, do a Preliminary study. Select at least one source of information about X that helps to plan your investigation. Do a trial investigation first to help you make decisions on your final plan. Write down what you did and what you found out. 7 Decide on a suitable scientific question to investigate. Select s range of suitable equipment for the investigation, stating reasons based on its precision. Describe in detail how you will investigate the question systematically and collect data that is reliable. Identify the variables involved; explain how you will attempt to control them. Make a prediction based on a scientific reason. Describe how you will make sure the investigation is safe for you and others. Plan to collect data that is reliable. Carry out a risk assessment for the investigation, referring to the appropriate information. Plan a Preliminary study. Select at least two sources of information about X that help to plan your investigation. Do a trial investigation first to help you make decisions on your final plan. Write down what you did and what you found out. Explain the decisions you made from this for your actual investigation. 8 As for level 7, but independently use secondary sources to inform your preliminary investigation & planning. Discuss in detail your decisions for choosing particular high precision equipment, comparing alternative options. EP Without assistance, use your scientific knowledge and understanding to plan an appropriate investigation. Include the following: Synthesise information from a variety of resources to inform your plan and prediction. Consider a range of approaches to the investigation, making a decision based on scientific knowledge and understanding. Plan to use high precision equipment to measure a range of appropriate variables. Confidently carry out a risk assessment and make amendments to your plan to control risks.

Obtaining Oa Collecting and recording evidence To get level Learners should: 3 Be safe when instructed. Follow simple instructions With some help, take three observations or measurements. 4 Follow instructions carefully. When told, take action to keep yourself safe during the experiment. Change one variable only, controlling another variable. Make at least three observations/measurements. 5 With some help, recognise hazards and take action to reduce risk to yourself and others. Change one variable only, controlling a range of other variables. Make a series observations/measurements systematically. 6 On your own, take action to reduce familiar risks to yourself and others. Change one variable only, controlling a range of other variables. Make a series of precise observations or measurements systematically. 7 With some help, change one variable only, taking action to control a range of variables that are difficult to control. On your own, make a series of precise and reliable observations/measurements systematically using different types of equipment. 8 On your own, you carry out the experiment taking action to: Control all risks to yourself and others. Control variables that are difficult to control. Make systematic, precise and reliable observations and measurements. Use a range of equipment confidently. EP As for Level 8, but independently and confidently take action to control risks and make decisions about obtaining precise, accurate and reliable data.

Obtaining Ob Presenting Evidence Graphs To get level Learners should: 3 With help put some results in a simple table. With help plot a simple bar chart. 4 Record data in a simple table Draw simple bar charts, with some help with scales. With help, plot simple graphs 5 Design a simple results table. Record your evidence clearly in the table. 6 Design a results table to display your data. Record your evidence clearly in your table. Decide on suitable simple scales for your graph. Plot the points on the graph. Attempt to draw a line or curve of best fit. 7 Design a results table to display relevant data, including averages where appropriate. Record your evidence in your table. With help, carry out simple calculations. Decide on a suitable way to present your evidence. Decide on suitable scales for your graph. Plot at least five points on the graph. Draw an accurate line or curve of best fit. 8 Design a results table to display relevant and sufficient data, including additional calculations. Calculate speed/pressure/averages, using appropriate units. Record your evidence in your table clearly. Decide on a suitable way to present your evidence. Decide on suitable complex scales for your graph. Plot sufficient points on the graph. Draw an accurate line or curve of best fit. EP As for level 8 but also independently and confidently: Decide on the precision required for the measurements. Identify and explain points of particular significants.

Considering Evidence C To get level Learners should: 3 With help (teacher, teaching assistant or writing frames): State the pattern from your evidence. State your conclusion. 4 With help (teacher, teaching assistant or writing frames): State the pattern from your evidence. State your conclusion. Explain your conclusion using simple scientific ideas. 5 With some prompts: Describe the pattern from your evidence. State your conclusion, using a Big Idea in Science. Explain your conclusion using scientific words and units. 6 Mostly working independently, with some help with Level 6 specific skills: Describe any pattern from your evidence accurately. Make a conclusion consistent with your evidence. Explain your conclusion using scientific concepts, keywords and symbols where appropriate. 7 Fairly independently, with some help through discussion with the teacher: Describe the relationship between the variables quantitatively. Explain the relationship scientifically, where appropriate. Identify any anomalies in your results. Use a range scientific ideas and mathematical units appropriately. 8 Independently: Begin to explain and allow for anomalies Carry out multi-step calculations and use compound measures. Communicate findings and arguments using a range of views Considering Evidence Describe the relationship between the variables quantitatively. Explain the relationship scientifically, where appropriate, offering alternative views. Explain any anomalies in your results. Use scientific ideas and mathematical units appropriately and confidently. EP Independently and confidently: Describe the relationship between the variables quantitatively. Explain the relationship scientifically, where appropriate, offering alternative views, using scientific ideas and mathematical units appropriately. Discuss how certain you can be of the evidence you have produced.

Considering Evidence E To get level Learners should: 3 Suggest an improvement to the investigation. 4 Suggest improvements with reasons. 5 Suggest how the investigation could be improved with scientific reasons. Suggest practical improvements. 6 Evaluate the evidence: suggest one strength and one weakness with the evidence Explain how the method could be improved. 7 Begin to consider if the data is sufficient for the conclusions Evaluate the evidence: suggest some strengths and weaknesses with the evidence. Explain in detail how the method could be improved. Decide if the data is sufficient to support the conclusion. 8 Evaluate the evidence: suggest a range of strengths and weaknesses with the evidence. Explain in detail how the method could be improved based on your evaluation. Discuss if the data is sufficient to support the conclusion. EP Evaluate the evidence: suggest a range of strengths and weaknesses with the evidence. Discuss how certain you are about the evidence. Explain in detail how the method could be improved based on your evaluation. Discuss if the data is sufficient to support the conclusion, explaining what additional evidence could be collected.

Developing an Argument A To get Learners should: level 3 Select information for your argument. Write down what your argument is about. Make one point supported by evidence. State your conclusion. Use some key words correctly. 4 Select scientific information for your argument. Describe what your argument is about. Make two points each supported by evidence. State one reason why we cannot be sure whether State your conclusion. Use a range of key words correctly. 5 Select scientific information for your argument. Explain simply what your argument is about. Make two points each supported by evidence. Explain simply why you chose each piece of evidence. Explain simply why scientists cannot be sure whether Explain your conclusion. Use a range of key words correctly. 6 Use the criteria to select scientific or other evidence for your argument. Explain what your argument is about. Make three points, each supported by evidence. Explain why you chose each piece of evidence, based on the criteria. Explain why scientists cannot be sure whether Explain your conclusion. Use key words, mathematical and scientific conventions correctly. 7 Use criteria to select scientific or other evidence for your argument. Draw on your own scientific knowledge and understanding to select evidence for your argument. Explain what your argument is about. Make several relevant points, each supported by evidence. Explain in detail why you chose each piece of evidence, based on the criteria. Explain in detail why scientists cannot be sure whether Explain, using scientific detail, your conclusion. Suggest what further evidence would be needed to support your argument. Use a range of key words, mathematical and scientific conventions correctly. 8 Devise criteria to select scientific or other evidence for your argument. Explain clearly what the argument is about. Make several relevant points, each supported by evidence, drawing on your own scientific knowledge and understanding to select evidence for your argument. Explain in detail why you chose each piece of evidence, based on the criteria. Explain in detail why scientists cannot be sure whether Explain your conclusion based on the evidence you have selected, using scientific detail. Discuss what further evidence is needed to support your argument. Use a range of relevant key words, mathematical and scientific conventions confidently. EP Devise criteria to select scientific or other evidence for your argument. Explain clearly what the argument is about. Make a range of relevant points, each supported by evidence, drawing on addition evidence you have researched for your argument. Explain in detail why you chose each piece of evidence, based on your criteria. Explain in detail why scientists cannot be sure whether. Explain your conclusion based on the evidence you have selected, using scientific detail. Discuss in detail what further evidence is needed to support your argument and what evidence would be required for you to change your mind. Use a range of relevant key words, mathematical & scientific conventions consistently & confidently.

Do not get too bogged down in which level to assign make a judgement using the criteria, then assign the level. I find that learners do pick me up on anything they think has been badly judged! The resulting discussion is very useful to both parties. Assigning sub-levels Many schools and colleges use sub-levels to help measure and monitor progression in scientific knowledge and understanding. These can be easily applied to these tasks. Most level ladders have about three or more statements per level. If the learner has satisfied one descriptor out of the three for Level 4, the Level 4c can be awarded; all three descriptors would mean that 4a can be awarded. Some issues do arise over whether to assign a Level 4a or 5c (for example). At these boundaries, if it is not clear from the learner s work then professional judgement comes into play. Decide what will help aid the learner s progression the most. Dealing with misconceptions The great advantage of open-ended tasks is that they allow learners to have freedom to express their ideas, knowledge and understanding about science. This of course includes all their misconceptions as well. This is a particularly useful aspect of these tasks, but also can be daunting when assessing the work if a learner has many misconceptions demonstrated in their work. I usually circle anything that is not scientifically correct, but base the improvement target on the next step in progression. What happens if the learner completely misses the point? Sometimes learners can produce a piece of work that does not seem possible to assess using the level ladder. The simple approach is that the improvement target is to do the task again using the level ladder to guide. If it is a reoccurring issue, sit the learner next to someone who can use the level ladder and encourage them to work together. In order to pre-empt this issue, it is often useful to show the class the type of response you are looking for. This can be done using an exemplar. Self-assessment and peer-assessment Encouraging learners to assess their own work or each others can be very valuable to the learning experience. As with anything new, learners will need more guidance and support to start with before their confidence develops to do this successfully. I would highly recommend that time is taken to help learners develop these skills with the support of these tasks. Self assessment can be done by guiding learners through the level ladder and encouraging them to tick off the descriptors they feel they have satisfied. Then they can use the improvement ladder to help decide on suitable improvement targets. Peer assessment can be useful because learners can learn from each other as well as engage with what is required for each level.

Generally learners are reasonably accurate at assigning levels, but in self-assessment there is an issue that they may not be aware of misconceptions that have been made. If you intend the learners to self-assess a piece of work in class, it is worth making sure that you challenge major misconceptions as you circulate. With both these types of assessment, it is the process of discussing and deciding on a level that is important, not necessarily whether the work is assessed to the correct sub-level. The latter can be dealt with by the teacher.

7A C E L L S ( T N) OBSERVING CELLS UNDER A MICROSCOPE NATIONAL CURRICULUM LINK Critical understanding of evidence obtain, record and analyse data from a wide range of primary and secondary sources, including ICT sources, and use their findings to provide evidence for scientific explanations Communication RESOURCES: Task sheets, microscopes, slides, cover slips, appropriate stains 1, source of plant and animal cells (e.g. onion epidermis) and swabs for cheek cells 2. use appropriate methods, including ICT, to communicate scientific information and contribute to presentations and discussions about scientific issues. Organisms, behaviour and health life processes are supported by the organisation of cells into tissues, organs and body systems RISK ASSESSMENT 1 A risk assessment may be required in relation to the types of stain that might be used. 2 Allow learners to use a cotton bud to take their own samples and dispose of the cotton bud safely. Check school/la risk assessments for cheek-cell sampling. SUGGESTED APPROACHES Help learners to prepare slides of pieces of plant material, e.g. leaf surface, petals, root, squash, potato and tomato scrapings, onion epidermis. Establish that plant material is made of cells. Ask learners to describe these cells. Provide opportunities for learners to make their own slides of cheek cells as well as to observe prepared slides of human cells. Ask learners to suggest ways in which these cells are similar to and different from plant cells. Demonstrate by drawing around a single cell in the photograph, or by drawing a cell that you can see and then showing this particular cell to a learner, to help to focus their perception and observations. Use the appropriate task sheet to help learners identify what they are expected to do to reach their target level. Encourage learners to use the level ladder during the task and give them an opportunity to peer or self assess during the plenary. During the task, engage learners with the level ladder to ensure that they are being suitably challenged by the task. Ideally, give the learners an opportunity to use the microscope twice, so they can improve on their first attempt using targets from the level ladder. This is a valuable strategy for engaging learners with their own learning and skill development. Y7 HSW LEVEL-ASSESSED TASKS: TEACHER NOTES

ICT OPPORTUNITY Use animations of the particle model and diffusion to help visualize particle behaviour. ADDITIONAL GUIDANCE FOR ASSIGNING A LEVEL Sub-levels may be assigned to indicate the extent of understanding within a particular level. Level Teacher guidance 3 Learners will need assistance with setting up the slide and focusing the microscope. They may identify the main parts of the microscope verbally. They may draw something that they can see from the microscope, but will not be selective about what they draw. 4 Learners will need some help with slide preparation and focusing the microscope. They will attempt to draw a diagram of the cell. They will be able to state the names and jobs of each part of the microscope. They may be able to identify prominent parts of a cell, with prompting. 5 Learners at Level 5 should be able to prepare the slide safely using instructions and make a reasonable attempt at using the microscope effectively. The diagram should be a line drawing, with some organelles labelled correctly at low magnification only. 6 At Level 6 should be able to prepare a slide safely following written instructions. They should be able to use the microscope competently at low magnifications. All parts of the cell should be represented in a clear, accurate diagram of the cell, accounting for artefacts such as bubbles. With some help, they may calculate the magnification of the cell by multiplying the magnification of the eye piece with the magnification of the objective lens. 7 The key aspect of a Level 7 learner in addition to the Level 6 characteristics is the ability to attempt a measurement of some cells. They should be able to use the microscope competently and safely at both low and high magnifications. They should make a reasonable attempt to estimate the size of the cells observed, i.e. a fraction of a millimetre. 8 As for Level 7 but learners should be able to observe two cell types as they are competent at preparing slides. Learners draw cell diagrams competently, without guidance. EP As for Level 8, but the learner should be independent at all calculations and estimates and well as being able to compare the two types of cells, recognising the issues concerned with observing cells with the microscope. Note, when used with Year 7 learners it is unlikely that they will achieve Level 8 or EP because they require a wide experience of KS3 Y7 HSW LEVEL-ASSESSED TASKS: TEACHER NOTES 7A OBSERVING CELLS UNDER A MICROSCOPE

7A C E L L S ( TS 3-5 ) OBSERVING CELLS UNDER A MICROSCOPE FOCUS: OBTAINING EVIDENCE (OA) INFORMATION All living things are made of cells. You are made up of many millions of cells. Cells are very small, so small you cannot see them with your naked eye. Instead we use a microscope to observe cells. You are going to see some cells using a light microscope. THINK ABOUT How do you prepare cells to see them through a microscope? How do you focus a microscope safely to see cells? How do you draw what you see under a microscope? TASK Your teacher will show you how to prepare a slide carefully and use a microscope to observe some cells. Focus your microscope at low magnification carefully and draw what you can see. Draw a diagram carefully using the tips below. Use the Level Ladder to help you reach your target level. Tips for microscope drawings: Use a sharp pencil on plain paper. Decide which part of the image you want to draw. Use continuous lines to draw your diagram, do not sketch. Label the parts of the image you can identify. Write a title for a diagram, stating the name of the cell. Write down the magnification at which you observed the cell. KEY WORDS cell, cover slip, eye piece, focus, lens, magnification, magnify, microscope, slide, stain, cell membrane, cell wall, cytoplasm, nucleus, vacuole Y7 HSW LEVEL-ASSESSED TASKS: TS (L3-5) BADGER PUBLISHING LTD

7A C E L L S ( L L 3-5) OBSERVING CELLS UNDER A MICROSCOPE What is your target level? Use the level ladder to help you reach it. To get level You might: 3 With help, prepare the slide. With help, use the microscope to get a focused image of a cell. Identify some parts of the microscope: eye piece, stage, mirror, focus knob. Draw what you can see through the microscope. With help, identify a cell. 4 Follow instructions carefully and with help, prepare a slide. When told, take action to keep yourself safe during the experiment. With help, use the microscope to get a focused image of a cell at low magnification. Name major parts of the microscope and state their job. Draw a simple diagram of the cells you can see under the microscope. Identify and label a single cell. 5 Prepare a slide, maybe with a little help. With some help, recognise hazards and take action to reduce risk to yourself and others. Use the microscope to get a focused image of a cell at low magnification. Name most parts of the microscope and describe how they work. Draw an accurate diagram of the cells you can see under the microscope. Identify and label some parts of the cell correctly. Which level have you achieved? Choose one improvement target and try it. Y7 HSW LEVEL-ASSESSED TASKS: LL (L3-5) BADGER PUBLISHING LTD

7A C E L L S ( TS 5-7 ) OBSERVING CELLS UNDER A MICROSCOPE FOCUS: OBTAINING EVIDENCE (OA) INFORMATION All living things are made of cells. You are made up of many millions of cells. Cells are very small, so small you cannot see them with your naked eye. Instead we use a microscope to observe cells. You are going to see some cells using a light microscope. THINK ABOUT How do you prepare cells to see them through a microscope? How do you focus a microscope safely to see cells? How do you draw what you see under a microscope? How can you measure what you see under a microscope? TASK Your teacher will show you how to prepare a slide carefully and use a microscope to observe some cells. Focus your microscope at low and high magnification carefully and draw what you can see. Draw a diagram carefully using the tips below. Use the Level Ladder to help you reach your target level. actual magnification = magnification of eye piece x magnification of objective lens Tips for microscope drawings: Use a sharp pencil on plain paper. Decide which part of the image you want to draw. Use continuous lines to draw your diagram, do not sketch. Label the parts of the image you can identify. Write a title for a diagram, stating the name of the cell. Write down the magnification at which you observed the cell. KEY WORDS cell, cover slip, focus, lens, magnification, magnify, microscope, slide, stain cell membrane, cell wall, cytoplasm, eye piece, objective, nucleus, vacuole Y7 HSW LEVEL-ASSESSED TASKS: TS (L5-7) BADGER PUBLISHING LTD

7A C E L L S ( L L 5-7) OBSERVING CELLS UNDER A MICROSCOPE What is your target level? Use the level ladder to help you reach it. To get level You might: 5 Prepare a slide, maybe with a little help. With some help, recognise hazards and take action to reduce risk to yourself and others. Use the microscope to get a focused image of a cell at low magnification. Name most parts of the microscope and describe how they work. Draw an accurate diagram of the cells you can see under the microscope. Identify and label some parts of the cell correctly. 6 Take action to reduce familiar risks to yourself and others to prepare a slide. Use the microscope to get a focused image of a cell at low and high magnifications. Name parts of the microscope and explain how they work. Draw an accurate diagram of the cells you can see under the microscope. Identify and label all parts of the cell correctly. Calculate the magnification of the cell you observed, showing your working. 7 On your own, take action to reduce a range of risks to yourself and others to prepare a slide properly. Use the microscope to get a focused image of a cell at three magnifications. Draw an accurate diagram of the cells you can see under the microscope. Explain, in detail, how the microscope works. Identify and label all parts of the cell correctly, explaining any problems of seeing cells with a microscope. Calculate one magnification of the cell you observed, showing your working. Make a reasonable estimate of the size of the cells you have observed, explaining how you did this. Which level have you achieved? Choose one improvement target and try it. Y7 HSW LEVEL-ASSESSED TASKS: LL (L5-7) BADGER PUBLISHING LTD

7A C E L L S ( TS 7 - EP ) OBSERVING CELLS UNDER A MICROSCOPE FOCUS: OBTAINING EVIDENCE (OA) INFORMATION All living things are made of cells. You are made up of many millions of cells. Cells are very small, so small you cannot see them with your naked eye. Instead we use a microscope to observe cells. You are going to see some cells using a light microscope. THINK ABOUT How do you prepare cells to see them through a microscope? How do you focus a microscope safely to see cells? How can you measure what you see under a microscope? How do you draw what you see under a microscope? TASK Your teacher will show you how to prepare a slide carefully and use a microscope to observe some cells. Focus your microscope at low and high magnification carefully and draw what you can see. Draw a diagram carefully using the tips below. Use the Level Ladder to help you reach your target level. actual magnification = magnification of eye piece x magnification of objective lens Tips for microscope drawings: Use a sharp pencil on plain paper. Decide which part of the image you want to draw. Use continuous lines to draw your diagram, do not sketch. Label the parts of the image you can identify. Write a title for a diagram, stating the name of the cell. Write down the magnification at which you observed the cell. KEY WORDS Decide on key words that are suitable for this task. Y7 HSW LEVEL-ASSESSED TASKS: TS (L7-EP) BADGER PUBLISHING LTD

7A C E L L S ( L L 7- E P) OBSERVING CELLS UNDER A MICROSCOPE What is your target level? Use the level ladder to help you reach it. To get level You might: 7 On your own, take action to reduce a range of risks to yourself and others to prepare a slide properly. Use the microscope to get a focused image of a cell at three magnifications. Draw an accurate diagram of the cells you can see under the microscope. Explain, in detail, how the microscope works. Identify and label all parts of the cell correctly, explaining any problems of seeing cells with a microscope. Calculate one magnification of the cell you observed, showing your working. Make a reasonable estimate of the size of the cells you have observed, explaining how you did this. 8 As for Level 7 but also: On your own, take action to reduce a range of risks to yourself and others to prepare slides competently and safely of two types of cell. Make a reasonable estimate of the size of the cells you have observed, explaining how you did this at two magnifications. EP As for Level 8 but also: On your own, take action to reduce a range of risks to yourself and others to prepare slides competently and safely for a range of cell types. Compare and contrast the parts of the cells correctly, explaining differences and explaining problems of seeing cells with a microscope. Calculate the magnification of the cells you observed, showing your working. Make a reasonable estimate of the size of the cells you have observed, explaining how you did this. Which level have you achieved? Choose one improvement target and try it. Y7 HSW LEVEL-ASSESSED TASKS: LL (L7-EP) BADGER PUBLISHING LTD