Earnshaw State College Queensland State School Reporting 2015 School Annual Report Postal address PO Box 242 Banyo 4014 Phone (07) 3621 7333 Fax (07) 3621 7300 Email Webpages Contact person principal@earnshawsc.eq.edu.au Additional reporting information pertaining to Queensland state schools is located on the My School website and the Queensland Government data website. Dave Bosworth Principal s foreword Introduction The Annual School Report provides parents and the community with an overview of the achievements and highlights of Earnshaw State College for the 2015 academic year. This report includes summary information on our student achievements in the National Assessment Program, student retention rates, curriculum offerings and information relating to the professional work of our staff. Earnshaw is a P-12 college providing a caring and nurturing education for all our students. Our college programs and practices embed our values of diligence, integrity, courage and empathy into all areas of learning and college life. Our students and staff commit to our college motto, prepare today for tomorrow as they develop deep understanding and knowledge of the importance of lifelong learning and working with open hearts and open minds. At Earnshaw State College we believe If you can read you can do anything Our values shape the Earnshaw culture of 'Together We Achieve', allowing our community to build a productive partnership between all stakeholders where learning with open hearts and minds is valued:. Diligence. Integrity. Courage. Empathy Diligence Working hard and doing your absolute best Taking special care, by doing things step-by-step Diligence helps you to get things done with excellence and enthusiasm Diligence leads to success Integrity Living by your highest values. Being honest and sincere Integrity helps you to listen to your conscience, to do the right thing, and to tell the truth You act with integrity when your words and actions match Integrity gives you self-respect and a peaceful heart Courage Courage is bravery in the face of fear. You do the right thing even when it is hard or scary. When you are courageous, you don't give up. You try new things. You admit mistakes. Courage is the strength in your heart. Empathy A respectful understanding of another person s feelings, dreams, hopes or problems Sharing the feelings of another person and understanding a situation from their point of view Empathy helps you imagine how you would think or feel if you walked in another person s shoes School progress towards its goals in 2015 Providing high quality learning and skilling focused on preparing Queenslanders with the knowledge, skills and confidence to participate effectively in the community and the economy is our goal at Earnshaw State College.
Our goals for 2015 (Green on tract, Yellow, started) included: Refine whole school curriculum, assessment and reporting plan Research and embed the use of ICT's in Literacy and Numeracy Provide PD and training to Teacher Aides Undertake Action Research on the teaching of reading and writing Research and review teaching strategies for numeracy Train teachers to provide quality feedback to students Curriculum planning processes focus on student data and "the how" of teaching Review and implement the College "Thinking Framework" Research appropriate ICT tools to aid in the teaching of Literacy Adopt / adapt / develop a research driven, evidence based pedagogical approach in the school which promotes school - wide high expectations and consistency of practice. Develop and manage collaborative teaching practices Develop / refine approaches to build professional capacity through feedback Observation of teachers and teaching strategies Provide professional development around 21st Century Learning Encourage the college to take pedagogical risks and explore possibilities Resourcing with 21st Century tools Plan for the retention, attainment and transition of students Plan to transition 7 to High School Future outlook Priorities for growth and improvement in the College for 2016 focus on: Priority: Literacy and Numeracy Strategy: Refine whole school curriculum, assessment and reporting plan Actions Adopt / adapt / develop a research driven, evidence based pedagogical approach in the school which promotes school - wide high expectations and consistency of practice Actions Review current program and extend to the end of 9 Actions Continue to embed the college pedagogical framework. Clarify what students are expected to learn and be able to do, high expectations of every student s learning and explicit teaching Actions Revise the college coaching and feedback model Strategy: Research and embed the use of ICT's in Literacy and Numeracy Actions Adopt / adapt / develop a research driven, evidence based pedagogical approach in the school which promotes school - wide high expectations and consistency of practice Actions Encourage the college to take pedagogical risks and explore possibilities Actions Resourcing with 21st Century tools Strategy: Provide PD and training to Teacher Aides Actions Provide professional development around 21st Century Learning Strategy: Undertake Action Research on the teaching of reading and writing Actions Observation of teachers and teaching strategies Strategy: Train teachers to provide quality feedback to students Actions Develop / refine approaches to build professional capacity through feedback Actions Observation of teachers and teaching strategies Strategy: Curriculum planning processes focus on student data and "the how" of teaching Actions Facilitate professional conversations on a regular basis around pedagogical practice Actions Master Teaching working across the College to support and professionally grow our teaching staff Core Priority: Pathways and Community Connections Strategy: Plan for the retention, attainment and transition of students Actions Community connections with industry agreement - Beacon, ACU Strategy: Develop productive partnerships with students, staff, parents and the community Actions Effective transition programs from year 10 to 11 Actions Learning opportunities with ACU for Senior Students and Staff. Strategy: Develop marketing strategies and opportunities Actions Understanding the College brand Actions Communication practices to increase % of paid school fees Core Priority: Student Support Strategy: Review the transition 7 to high school Actions Review 2015 year with recommendations for 2016 Strategy: School based data tracking system for students at risk. Actions Whole College coordination of Student Services Actions Whole College student referral program to provide services for students at risk
Actions All students at risk identified and an individual response documented and tracked Strategy: Professional Development for the student service team Actions Develop with a futures focus and on a needs basis. Strategy: Professional Development Actions Facilitate professional conversations on a regular basis around pedagogical practice and its impact on classroom differentiation.
Our school at a glance School Profile Coeducational or single sex: Coeducational Independent Public School: Yes levels offered in 2015: Prep - 12 Student enrolments for this school: Enrolment Continuity Total Girls Boys Indigenous (Feb Nov) 2013 655 313 342 33 93% 2014 669 311 358 40 93% 2015 713 333 380 37 93% Student counts are based on the Census (August) enrolment collection. *From 2015, data for all state high schools include 7 students. Prior to 2015, only state high schools offering 7 had these students included in their counts. In 2015, there were no students enrolled in a Pre-Prep program.* *Pre-Prep is a kindergarten program for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, living across 35 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, in the year before school (http://deta.qld.gov.au/earlychildhood/families/pre-prep-indigenous.html). Characteristics of the student body: Our families are predominantly local residents who are committed to the quality and personalised education their children receive at Earnshaw State College. The Banyo/Nudgee area is undergoing renewal and growth in housing and community and the Airport Precinct is continuing development with many new families moving into the area. Our students come from a range of socio-economic and cultural backgrounds and the diversity of our student population is increasing each year. Student retention is high across all sectors of the college with most students completing their primary and secondary schooling at Earnshaw Average class sizes Average Class Size Phase 2013 2014 2015 Prep 3 25 24 24 4 7 Primary 22 28 24 7 Secondary 10 22 22 21 11 12 16 15 16 *From 2015, data for all state high schools include 7 students. Prior to 2015, only state high schools offering 7 had these students included in their counts.
School Disciplinary Absences Count of Incidents Disciplinary Absences 2013 2014* 2015** Short Suspensions - 1 to 5 days 89 71 39 Long Suspensions - 6 to 20 days 18 13 11 Exclusions 1 2 3 Cancellations of Enrolment 0 1 2 * Caution should be used when comparing post 2013 SDA data as amendments to EGPA disciplinary provisions and changes in methodology created time series breaks in 2014 and 2015. **From 2015, Exclusion represents principal decisions to exclude rather than recommendations for exclusion. From 2015 where a principal decided not to exclude, a small number of recommendations for exclusions have been counted as a long suspension. Exclusions, Cancellations and Long & Charge Suspensions may be upheld or set aside through an appeals process. Curriculum delivery Our approach to curriculum delivery Our Prep to 12 curriculum is innovative, futures oriented and focussed on engaging and inspiring our students to achieve their best. Our curriculum is structured around programs at key educational junctions. 3, 6 and 9 offer extension and foundation classes to students with a particular focus on building student strength in English and Mathematics. Gender based classes are established in 4 and 5 allowing the curriculum to be delivered in a meaningful way for boys and girls and also allowing for the building of strong social programs. Our gender program has been extend up to 10 in the core subjects. Earnshaw students study Enterprise Education in years 7 and 8. Enterprise Education allows students to learn through real life opportunities including the planning and operations of our community markets. Business and Enterprise Education is a focus for the college with students able to continue their business studies through to 12. We are active members of the Brisbane North Chamber of Commerce and our Business Program is achieving outstanding results nationally and internationally. Students in the senior school are successfully completing their first university subjects in years 11 and 12 as a result of our close relationship with our local university, ACU. Many of our senior students also undertake Certificate III courses through TAFE including BNIT and SBIT while still completing their senior education. Our Individual Pursuits Program provides the opportunity for our students to study a broad range of subjects and courses through multiple learning and training providers and be supported by the college while undertaking them. We provide many opportunities for support to our students including Maths on Toast, assessment support sessions and homework clubs to ensure student success. Extra curricula activities Junior School (years P-6) Middle School (years 7-9) Senior School (year 10-12) Junior Choir ICAS Mathematics, English, Spelling Literacy and Numeracy Week Activities Readers are Leaders Home Reading program Homework Club Science Incursion Raw Art Incursion Guest speakers Kilometre Club Life Education Van Home access to Reading Eggs and Reading Eggspress Revved Up and MPower (s 4 and 5) Sparkle ( 5 girls) Lead motivational speakers Australian Business Week (junior competition) Middle School Mathematics and Problem Solving competition \ Rock and Water Program (boys) Maths on Toast support program Early Intervention Program (year 8) Middle School Enterprise Challenge Interschool sport RYDA program to promote road safety for our students motivational speakers Annual ski trip 12 formal 11 semi-formal Australian Business Week Global Enterprise Challenge (International Winners 2010, 2011 and 2012) Work Experience Program Maths on Toast support program Interschool sport
Fun Friends (P-2) ACU Medieval Fayre Interschool Sport (s 5-6) How Information and Communication Technologies are used to assist learning Information and Communication Technologies are embedded in our curriculum. The use of ICTs in our classrooms has become more of a focus with the implementation of the Australian curriculum. ICTs are allowing students more control over their learning and for differentiation of student learning, especially through virtual classrooms and other e learning tools. The increasing use of ICTs is expanding the learning of students outside the four walls of the classroom to connect to the outside world. 9 students were the first students in 2012 to participate in our laptop program. All year 9 students were issued with a laptop to enhance their learning and will keep their laptop for the duration of their schooling at Earnshaw College. In 2015 every student will have a school based personal device by the end of term 1. Prep to 4 will be a laptop and 5 to 12 a laptop. The College will move to a BYOD model in 2016. The College is also working on virtual classrooms (ELO Earnshaw Learning Online) Social Climate It is the shared belief of our college staff and community that school should be a place for all students to learn in a safe and caring environment - free to learn and enjoy their childhood and youth. Our Pastoral Care program within the college is significantly enhanced by the opportunities provided in a P-12 context. Our students are supported through a number of pastoral care programs within the college including our chaplaincy program, youth worker, school nurse, guidance officers and our You Can Do It Program. We support our students through a firm but caring approach to instilling the values of Diligence, Integrity, Courage and Empathy in all aspects of college life. In 2012 our students engaged in the following programs to further develop their social emotional skills and behaviours: Respect and Resilience Day; Y Lead, Revved Up and Shine, MPower, Early Intervention Program, Girl Groups. Our student leadership program recognises the developmental stages of young leaders and focuses on the educational aspects of student leadership as our student leaders prepare for representative roles in the College. We acknowledge and celebrate student successes through assemblies, awards night, graduation (prep and year 12), closing the gap awards nights, newsletter and local newspapers. Parent, student and staff satisfaction with the school Performance measure Percentage of parent/caregivers who agree # that: 2013 2014 2015 their child is getting a good education at school (S2016) 90% 92% 94% this is a good school (S2035) 80% 94% 94% their child likes being at this school (S2001) 80% 92% 92% their child feels safe at this school (S2002) 100% 94% 98% their child's learning needs are being met at this school (S2003) 80% 85% 88% their child is making good progress at this school (S2004) 89% 90% 94% teachers at this school expect their child to do his or her best (S2005) teachers at this school provide their child with useful feedback about his or her school work (S2006) 100% 95% 98% 100% 90% 88% teachers at this school motivate their child to learn (S2007) 90% 92% 90% teachers at this school treat students fairly (S2008) 90% 90% 90% they can talk to their child's teachers about their concerns (S2009) 100% 95% 98%
Performance measure Percentage of parent/caregivers who agree # that: 2013 2014 2015 this school works with them to support their child's learning (S2010) 90% 90% 94% this school takes parents' opinions seriously (S2011) 89% 86% 88% student behaviour is well managed at this school (S2012) 90% 81% 86% this school looks for ways to improve (S2013) 100% 92% 91% this school is well maintained (S2014) 90% 87% 98% Performance measure Percentage of students who agree # that: 2013 2014 2015 they are getting a good education at school (S2048) 94% 93% 96% they like being at their school (S2036) 90% 94% 94% they feel safe at their school (S2037) 87% 90% 94% their teachers motivate them to learn (S2038) 94% 93% 95% their teachers expect them to do their best (S2039) 98% 97% 98% their teachers provide them with useful feedback about their school work (S2040) 91% 91% 92% teachers treat students fairly at their school (S2041) 83% 88% 85% they can talk to their teachers about their concerns (S2042) 81% 84% 90% their school takes students' opinions seriously (S2043) 81% 82% 90% student behaviour is well managed at their school (S2044) 75% 78% 78% their school looks for ways to improve (S2045) 93% 91% 96% their school is well maintained (S2046) 86% 89% 87% their school gives them opportunities to do interesting things (S2047) 92% 91% 90% Performance measure Percentage of school staff who agree # that: 2013 2014 2015 they enjoy working at their school (S2069) 98% 100% 100% they feel that their school is a safe place in which to work (S2070) they receive useful feedback about their work at their school (S2071) they feel confident embedding Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander perspectives across the learning areas (S2114) students are encouraged to do their best at their school (S2072) 98% 100% 100% 81% 93% 97% 83% 89% 86% 96% 100% 100% students are treated fairly at their school (S2073) 98% 100% 100% student behaviour is well managed at their school (S2074) 89% 95% 92% staff are well supported at their school (S2075) 89% 93% 89% their school takes staff opinions seriously (S2076) 85% 89% 94% their school looks for ways to improve (S2077) 98% 100% 97% their school is well maintained (S2078) 81% 83% 92% their school gives them opportunities to do interesting things (S2079) 91% 96% 92%
# Agree represents the percentage of respondents who Somewhat Agree, Agree or Strongly Agree with the statement. DW = Data withheld to ensure confidentiality. Parent and Community Engagement Each semester we negotiate academic targets with all students from 1 12 and develop strategies that are shared with parents in a written report. Parents discuss the strategies and confirm these targets with their children. Teachers and parents follow up each student s progress toward their targets at reporting interviews. Parent/Teacher interviews are offered twice a year following the issuing of reports. These meetings between parents and their son/daughter s teachers prove very effective in establishing a meaningful relationship. Parents are also involved in the key transition points in the College notably year 10 11 through the SET Plan process and subject selection evenings. Earnshaw State College is committed to increasing and improving the quality of communications between the college and parents. This communication takes many forms, both informal and formal. College newsletters are produced fortnightly and class newsletters in the junior school are issued at least twice per term. Parent information evenings are held at the beginning of the year for junior school, up to year 7 and later in the year for secondary to communicate critical information regarding their child s education at Earnshaw. Parents are invited to college events and to celebrate student success. These events include our assemblies, awards nights and sporting days. A significant number of parents support student learning through volunteer work in classrooms, school excursions and special event days. The Earnshaw State College community is a close knit and inclusive community. Our college is the local school and is well supported by our parents, local organisations and businesses. Parents and citizens of our community are welcomed to attend and join our P&C association Reducing the school s environmental footprint Data is sourced from school's annual utilities return and is reliant on the accuracy of these returns. The college environmental initiatives include: Instalment of solar panels Use of water tanks Light bulbs changes throughout college to environmentally friendly models s Environmental footprint indicators Electricity kwh Water kl 2012-2013 299,406 2,097 2013-2014 217,623 4,661 2014-2015 265,468 3,257 *The consumption data is compiled from sources including ERM, Ergon reports and utilities data entered into OneSchool by each school. The data provides an indication of the consumption trend in each of the utility categories which impact on the school s environmental footprint. Our staff profile Staff composition, including Indigenous staff 2015 Workforce Composition Teaching Staff* Non-teaching Staff Indigenous Staff Headcounts 61 36 <5 Full-time equivalents 57 25 <5
Qualification of all teachers Highest level of attainment Number of Teaching Staff * Certificate 0 Diploma 0 Advanced Diploma 0 70 60 50 40 30 59 Bachelor Degree 59 20 Graduate Diploma etc.** 0 Masters 2 10 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 Doctorate 0 Total 61 *Teaching staff includes School Leaders **Graduate Diploma etc. includes Graduate Diploma, Bachelor Honours Degree, and Graduate Certificate. Expenditure on and teacher participation in professional development The total funds expended on teacher professional development in 2015 were $29,943.36 The major professional development initiatives are as follows: QSA workshops Thinking Skills Framework VET Tactical Reading Subject Specific Professional Development IT Leadership Conferences/Development Programs One school training First Aides/CPR Pedagogical Framework Students with disabilities ACARA Coaching Research teams in Learning Behaviours and Higher Order Thinking STEAM Mindset Growth Individual Development The proportion of the teaching staff involved in professional development activities during 2015 was 100%. Average staff attendance 2013 2014 2015 Staff attendance for permanent and temporary staff and school leaders. 96% 96% 96% Proportion of staff retained from the previous school year From the end of the previous school year, 95% of staff was retained by the school for the entire 2015 school year. School income broken down by funding source School income broken down by funding source is available via the My School website at http://www.myschool.edu.au/. To access our income details, click on the My School link above. You will then be taken to the My School website with the following Find a school text box.
Where it says School name, type in the name of the school you wish to view, select the school from the drop-down list and select <GO>. Read and follow the instructions on the next screen; you will be asked to confirm that you are not a robot then by clicking continue, you acknowledge that you have read, accepted and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy before being given access to the school s profile webpage. School financial information is available by selecting School finances in the menu box in the top left corner of the school s profile webpage. If you are unable to access the internet, please contact the school for a paper copy of income by funding source. Performance of our students Key student outcomes Student attendance 2013 2014 2015 The overall attendance rate for the students at this school (shown as a percentage). 91% 91% 91% The attendance rate for Indigenous students at this school (shown as a percentage). 91% 84% 84% The student attendance rate is generated by dividing the total of full-days and part-days that students attended, and comparing this to the total of all possible days for students to attend, expressed as a percentage. The overall attendance rate in 2015 for all Queensland P-10/P-12 schools was 90%. Student attendance rate for each year level (shown as a percentage) Prep 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 2013 93% 92% 93% 94% 93% 96% 92% 91% 93% 85% 89% 88% 87% 2014 93% 91% 92% 90% 93% 93% 94% 91% 87% 90% 87% 91% 89% 2015 92% 92% 92% 93% 95% 93% 93% 92% 90% 88% 88% 82% 89% *From 2013, the methodology used for calculating attendance rates effectively counts attendance for every student for every day of attendance in Semester 1. The student attendance rate is generated by dividing the total of full-days and part-days that students attended, and comparing this to the total of all possible days for students to attend, expressed as a percentage. DW = Data withheld to ensure confidentiality.
Student attendance distribution The proportions of students by attendance range. Attendance Rate: 0% to <85% 85% to <90% 90% to <95% 95% to 100% 2013 17 13 24 46 2014 18 12 22 48 2015 21 10 23 46 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Proportion of Students Description of how non-attendance is managed by the school Non-attendance is managed in state schools in line with the DET procedures, Managing Student Absences and Enforcing Enrolment and Attendance at State Schools and Roll Marking in State Schools, which outline processes for managing and recording student attendance and absenteeism. Non-attendance is managed in state schools in line with the DET policies, SMS-PR-029: Managing Student Absences and SMS-PR-036: Roll Marking in State Schools, which outline processes for managing and recording student attendance and absenteeism. Form teachers mark rolls in form meeting or assembly each morning and absences are transferred to OneSchool by the relevant subschool administration staff. Late students report to either of the sub-school offices for the admin staff to issue them with a late slip showing when they arrived. Staff are able to check, through OneSchool for unauthorised absences which are followed up by the class teacher. The follow up of truancy of students is made more efficient for the administration and year coordinators via the electronic processes introduced. Form teachers are responsible for collection of notes explaining absences. Parents can call an absence line, email, phone or write in with the explanation for absences. Attendance Officer phones home when a student has 3 unexplained absences. This process is monitored through OneSchool by the Heads of School. Attendance checks for 2015 were conducted at the end of each reporting period and letters were sent home to all parents asking for explanation of unexplained absences. Letters are also sent home for any student with 3+ consecutive unexplained absences. National Assessment Program Literacy and Numeracy (NAPLAN) results our reading, writing, spelling, grammar and punctuation, and numeracy results for the s 3, 5, 7, and 9. Our reading, writing, spelling, grammar and punctuation, and numeracy results for the s 3, 5, 7 and 9 are available via the My School website at http://www.myschool.edu.au/. To access our NAPLAN results, click on the My School link above. You will then be taken to the My School website with the following Find a school text box.
Where it says School name, type in the name of the school you wish to view, select the school from the drop-down list and select <GO>. Read and follow the instructions on the next screen; you will be asked to confirm that you are not a robot then by clicking continue, you acknowledge that you have read, accepted and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy before being given access to the school s profile webpage. School NAPLAN information is available by selecting NAPLAN in the menu box in the top left corner of the school s profile webpage. If you are unable to access the internet, please contact the school for a paper copy of our school s NAPLAN results. Apparent retention rates 10 to 12 2013 2014 2015 12 student enrolment as a percentage of the 10 student cohort. 85% 98% 75% 12 Indigenous student enrolment as a percentage of the 10 Indigenous student cohort. 0% 75% 100% Outcomes for our 12 cohorts 2013 2014 2015 Number of students receiving a Senior Statement 37 41 49 Number of students awarded a Queensland Certificate of Individual Achievement. 0 3 1 Number of students receiving an Overall Position (OP) 13 18 23 Percentage of Indigenous students receiving an Overall Position (OP) 50% 75% Number of students who are completing/continuing a School-based Apprenticeship or Traineeship (SAT). Number of students awarded one or more Vocational Educational Training (VET) qualifications (incl. SAT). Number of students awarded an Australian Qualification Framework Certificate II or above. Number of students awarded a Queensland Certificate of Education (QCE) at the end of 12. Percentage of Indigenous students awarded a Queensland Certificate of Education (QCE) at the end of 12. 1 1 4 37 37 47 25 27 22 34 36 46 100% 100% Number of students awarded an International Baccalaureate Diploma (IBD). 0 0 0
Outcomes for our 12 cohorts 2013 2014 2015 Percentage of OP/IBD eligible students with OP 1-15 or an IBD. 100% 56% 35% Percentage of 12 students who are completing or completed a SAT or were awarded one or more of the following: QCE, IBD, VET qualification. Percentage of Queensland Tertiary Admissions Centre (QTAC) applicants receiving an offer. As at 16 February 2016. The above values exclude VISA students. 100% 93% 100% 73% 90% 96% Overall Position Bands (OP) Number of students in each Band for OP 1 to 25 s OP 1-5 OP 6-10 OP 11-15 OP 16-20 OP 21-25 2013 3 5 5 0 0 2014 1 4 5 7 1 2015 0 5 3 14 1 As at 16 February 2016. The above values exclude VISA students. Vocational Educational Training qualification (VET) Number of students completing qualifications under Australian Qualification Framework (AQF) s Certificate I Certificate II Certificate III or above 2013 37 25 0 2014 31 26 4 2015 46 19 5 As at 16 February 2016. The above values exclude VISA students. The College offers several Certificate I s to students as part of our curriculum. Students in year 10 undertake Certificate I Work Education as part of their pastoral care program. This course provides an insight into the world of work and helps prepare students in the lead up to work experience and SET Plans. Students studying business in year 10 complete Certificate I in Business as part of the subject curriculum. Certificate I in Information, Digital Media and Technologies is offered to students as part of their senior curriculum and pastoral care program. Post-school destination information At the time of publishing this School Annual Report, the results of the 2016 post-school destinations survey, Next Step Student Destination Report (2015 12 cohort) for the school were not available. Information about these post-school destinations of our students will be uploaded to the school s website in September. Early school leavers information The destinations of young people who left the school in s 10, 11 and prior to completing 12. Any students exiting the College have been referred to outside agencies to support their transition into either 25 hours per week of work, Enrolment in a Certificate III at TAFE, an Apprenticeship/Traineeship or some other form of work/study.