CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE NEW DELHI MINUTES OF 122 ND MEETING OF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE HELD ON AT NEW DELHI

CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE NEW DELHI MINUTES OF 122 ND MEETING OF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE HELD ON 09.9.2004 AT NEW DELHI PRESENT 1. Vaidya Shriram Sharma, President Chairman 2. Vaidya SKS Chhangani, Vice-President (Ayurved) Member 3. Prof. Abdul Mobin Khan,Vice-President(Unani) Member 4. Dr. V Arunachalam, Vice-President (Siddha) Member 5. Dr. Madan Sarup Gupta, Chairman, Education Committee (Unani) Member 6. Vaidya Devendra Kumar Triguna Member 7. Dr. Sivanandam Member 8. Dr. Pramod Kumar Jain Member 9. Vaidya Raghunandan Sharma Member 10. Dr. MA Kumar Member 11. Hakim Ved Prakash Sharma Member Dr. PR Sharma Secretary Special Invitee 12. Vaidya S.K. Mishra, Chairman, Education Committee (Ayurved) Agenda Item No.1 Confirmation of 121 st meeting of Executive Committee held on 29.6.2004 at New Delhi. It was noted that the minutes of 121 st meeting of Executive Committee held on 29.6.2004 were circulated to all the members of the Council for ratification in the meeting of Central Council of Indian Medicine held on 30.6.2004. The same were ratified by the Council, therefore, the Executive Committee confirmed the minutes of 121 st meeting of the Committee. 1122ec

Agenda Item No.2 Ratification of the minutes of Sub Committee held on 18.8.2004. It was noted that the meeting of Sub-Committee (constituted by the CCIM in its meeting held on 30.6.2004 to consider the representations/compliance report received from the colleges) was held on 18.8.2004. The minutes of the Sub-Committee are as under:- i) Consideration of visitation report of Dharma Ayurved College, Perumbudur, Tamilnadu It was noted that the Sub-Committee considered the verification report of the visitors held on 9.8.2004. The Sub-Committee was of the opinion that though there has been improvement in respect of appointment of new teachers, hospital beds and establishment of Laboratories etc. but it is not as per Minimum Standards and Requirements of CCIM. Considering the recommendations of visitors and also existence of only few colleges in Tamilnadu State, it was decided that admission of forty students for the year 2004-05 be permitted with strict warning that if shortcomings are not fulfilled by the college within six months it will not be possible for the Council to permit admission for next year. The college be asked to report quarterly improvement made by the college in various aspects of Minimum Standards and Requirements. The Executive Committee ratified the decision of Sub Committee. ii) Consideration of visitation report of Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Coimbatore It was noted that the Sub-Committee considered the verification report of the visitors held on 10.8.2004. The Sub-Committee was of the opinion that though there has been improvement in respect of appointment of new teachers, hospital, beds and establishment of Laboratories etc. but it is not as per Minimum Standards and Requirements of CCIM. Considering the recommendations of visitors and also existence of only a few colleges in Tamilnadu State it was decided that admission of forty students for the year 2004-05 be permitted as per previous year with strict warning that if shortcomings are not fulfilled by the college within 6 months it will not be possible for the Council to permit admission for next year. The college be asked to report quarterly improvement made by the college in various aspects of Minimum Standards and Requirements. The Executive Committee ratified the decision of Sub Committee. 2122ec

iii) Consideration of visitation report of Shri Kalabhairaveshwara Swami Ayurved Medical College, Bangalore It was noted that the Sub-Committee considered the verification report submitted by the visitors held on 17.8.2004. Verification was conducted based on Government of India letter No.R.13011/09/2003-EP dated 29.7.2004. The verification report shows that there are only 50 beded functional hospital attached to the college. It was also pointed out that though a large number of persons have been named as teachers of the college, but there are only 21 teachers in the college. The Sub-Committee decided that a photocopy of the visitation report should be sent to Government of India with the request of that recommendations for addition of 10 more admission capacity in this college may not be considered now in view of the verification report. The Executive Committee ratified the decision of Sub Committee. It was also decided that 2-3 programmers be appointed on contract basis for computerization of information of the institutions of ISM. Agenda Item No.3 Ratification of the minutes of Sub Committee held on 29.7.2004. It was noted that Vasant Dada Patil Ayurved College, Sangli was visited by the visitors of the Council on 20.5.2004. The visitation report was considered by Education Committee (Ayurveda) and Executive Committee in their meetings held on 28 th & 29.6.2004 respectively. The Executive Committee did not agree to grant permission to admit students for the session 2004-05 and till the shortcomings fulfilled by the college. The shortcomings were intimated to the college for fulfillments. The compliance submitted by the college was considered by President, Vice-President(Ay.) and Chairman, Education Committee(Ay.) decided as under:- It is evident from the Maharashtra Govt. letter dated 6 th July,2004 that 8 more teaching posts have been sanctioned to this college. There is also improvement in other aspects. Therefore, we may permit admission of 40 students for graduate course during 2004-2005. The Executive Committee ratified the decision of Sub Committee. 3122ec

Agenda Item No.4. Approval of Annual Report and Audited Accounts of the Central Council of Indian Medicine for the year 2003-04. It was noted that draft Annual Report of the Central Council of Indian Medicine for the year 2003-04 to be laid down on the Table of both Houses of Parliament as usual has been prepared. The Audit of the Accounts of the Council for the year 2003-04 was conducted by the Auditors of DGACR from 01.7.2004 to 14.7.2004. The Audit report is still awaited. The same will be placed before the Committee as and when received. The earlier report for the year 2002-03 was placed before the Parliament on 07.7.2004 The Executive Committee went through the draft Annual Report and suggested amendment on page No.10 to exhibit the member of Executive Committee as office bearer as was suggested earlier and approved the same. Agenda Item No.5 Quarterly Progress Report of Central Council of Indian Medicine Court Cases and Counter Affidavits dealt with during the months of April, May and June,2004. It was noted that the 120 th meeting of Executive Committee at its meeting held on 23.3.2004 while approving the decision taken by the President for appointment of Shri Sunil Kumar Sharma, Advocate as Retainer of the office of the Central Council of Indian Medicine has decided that Progress Report of Court cases should be placed before the Executive Committee in its meeting from time to time. Shri Sunil Kumar Sharma, Advocate Retainer of the Council vide his letter dated 6.7.2004 submitted the quarterly report of court cases/ Counter Affidavits dealt by him during April,2004 to June,2004. The Executive Committee discussed the matter and decided that Members desired following more informations:- 1. Brief note of Writ (content of writ) 2. Views of the Council filed in the Counter affidavit It was also decided that opinion may be asked from EC members by circulation as per provision of clause 8 para second of the Central Council of Indian Medicine (General) Regulations, 1976. 4122ec

Agenda Item No.6 Ratification of recommendations of meeting of Departmental Promotion Committee to be held on 9.9.2004 at New Delhi. It was noted that the meeting of Departmental Promotion Committee to consider the cases of the employees of the Council under Assured Career Progression Scheme could not held due to lack of time. Agenda Item No.7 Consideration of Inspection Report received from Director General of Audit, Central Revenues on the accounts of Central Council of Indian Medicine New Delhi for the year 2003-04 It was noted that the Director, A&G II Office of the Director General of Audit, Central Revenues, New Delhi vide their letter No.AMGI/IR/CC.of Indian Med./04-05/399 dated Nil forwarded local Inspection Audit Report on the accounts of Central Council of Indian Medicine for the year 2003-04. In this connection, it was further noted that Audit of the Accounts of the CCIM for the year 2003-04 was conducted by the Auditor of DGACR from 01.7.2004 to 14.7.2004. Executive Committee decided to constitute a Sub Committee consisting of following members to prepare proper reply to furnish the DGACR within stipulated period:- 1. Dr. Abdul Mobin Khan 2. Dr. Madan Sarup Gupta 3. Vaidya Raghunandan Sharma 4. Dr. MA Kumar It was also decided that both side boarding pass with original ticket must be submitted by the members otherwise no payment should be made. Addl. Agenda Item No. 1. Allocation of Grant allocated by the Ministry to Central Council under Plan for the year 2004-05. It was noted that Budget Estimate amounting to Rs. 81.00 lakh for the year 2004-05 was submitted to the Ministry for sanction for 12 schemes. Ministry of Health & Family 5122ec

Welfare, Deptt. of Ayush allocated only Rs. 12.00 lakh against Rs. 81.00 lakh proposed by the Council for the year 2004-05. The Executive Committee discussed the matter and decided to refer the matter to Sub Committee constituted under Agenda Item No.7. Addl. Agenda Item No.2. Ratification of Action taken by Vice President (Ay.) It was noted that a Delegation of practitioners of ISM of Haryana State whose qualifications are included in the Second Schedule to the IMCC Act, 1970 met the Vice President (Ay.) & Vice-President (Siddha) and explained the problems facing in Haryana state regarding practice in Gynecology and Obstetrics. The Vice-President (Ay.) and Vice President (Siddha) observed that the theory and practical training of the following is included in the syllabus of graduate course of ISM prescribed by CCIM and they are competent for treating such patients. Prescribed treatment of excessive bleeding per vaginum with presence of non-viable product of conception, haemorhage in early pregnancy. Dilatation and curette procedure for various Gynecological condition like Dysmenorhhea, Dysfunctional uterine bleeding infertility, uterine polyps, Hydatiform mole (Vascular Mole) Cervical deformities etc. It may also be stated that Notification No. 8-5/96-AY. (MM) dated 30.10.96 issued by this Council is self explanatory in this regard. Vice-President (Ay.) directed that a letter on above, addressed to the Secretary, Govt. of Haryana be issued. Accordingly, a letter No. 8-5/2004-MM dated 9.4.04 was issued to Finance Commissioner-cum-Health-Secretary, Haryana, Chandigarh abtracts reads as under:- That the theory and practical training of the following is included in the syllabus of graduate course of ISM prescribed by CCIM and they are competent for treating such patients. Prescribed treatment of excessive bleeding per vaginum with presence of no-viable product of conception, harmorhage in early pregnancy. Dilation and curette procedure for various Gynaecological condition like Dysmenorhhea, Dysfunctional ulterine bleeding, infertility, uterine polyps, Hydatiform mole(vascular mole) Cervical deformities etc. 6122ec

It may also be stated that Notification No.8-5/96-Ay. (MM) dated 30.10.1996 issued by the Council is self-explanatory in this regard. submitted for ratification please. The Executive Committee ratified the same. Addl. Agenda Item NO.3. Restoration of Intake capacity of previous year s of Dada Sarup Singh Naik Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Dhule. It was noted that Dada Saheb Surupsingh Naik Ayurved Mahavidyalay, Dhule asking to restore the intake capacity i.e. sixty students of year 1997-98 which was reduced in 1998-99 upto 50 and thereafter 2000-2001-40 students. In view of amendment of IMCC Act, 1970 the clarification regarding restoration of intake capacity was asked from the Govt. of India. The Govt. of India vide letter No. 11011/01/2003-EP(Part) dated 17.6.04 asked to furnish the details of all such proposal whose admission in Under-graduate/Post-graduate course has been decreased/ceased by CCIM instead of seeking general exemption/approval for restoration to this department at the earliest. A copy of the visitation report in pursuance of seats were decreased and the last visitation report with the comparative statement of the facilities with reference to minimum standards may also be sent along with the recommendation. Accordingly matter was submitted to Government of India. Now Government of India is asked for recommendation of the Central Council in this regard. The Executive Committee discussed the matter and decided that relevant Visitation Report be circulated to all members of Executive Committee and by circulation decision be called for as per provision of Clause 8 of Central Council of Indian Medicine (General) Regulations, 1976. Addl. Agenda Item No.4. Restoration of Post and scale of pay of Asstt. Registrar (Ayurved) It was noted that Vaidya P.R. Sharma, Secretary CCIM has submitted a representation reads as under requesting stop/not to make the recovery since the matter is sub-judice. With reference to memorandum No.1-26/2001-Estt. Dated 6.4.2004 on the subject mentioned above, I am to submit that I was appointed as Asstt. Registrar (Ayurved) in the initial pay scale of Rs.8000-275-13500 and not in upgraded pay scale as in the case of other persons. Therefore, the office memorandum issued for me is not maintainable. 7122ec

Moreover, Shri VK Mishra, Asstt. Registrar (Regn.) and Hakim GS Reena, Technical Officer (Unani) have filed writ petition No.6451 of 2004 and 6674 of 2004 respectively which were heard by the Delhi High Court on 28.4.2004 and 30.4.2004 respectively and the Court has stayed the operation of office memorandum No.1-26/2001-Estt. dated 6.4.2004 of the Council whereby no recoveries can be made till the cases are pending or till the stay is not vacated by the Court. In view of the above, it was noted that since the Central Councils OM No.1-26/2001-Estt. dated 6.4.2004 has itself been stayed by the High Court, no consequent action for recovery etc. may be taken against any person to whom the above OM dated 6.4.2004 has been issued, since the matter is now sub-judice. The Executive Committee discussed the matter and decided that as the matter of fact there are three persons, two went to the Court and they have got stayed and applicability of judgement for third person be asked from the Government of India. Addl. Agenda Item No.6. Approval of Regulation in pursuance of Section 13 (c) of Indian Medicine Central Council (Amendment) Act, 2003. It was noted that as per decision of the Central Council in its meeting held on 30.6.2004 under agenda Item No.6 the meeting of following members was convened on 30.7.2004 to finalise the draft Regulation to submit the Govt. of India for approval:- 1. Vaidya Shriram Sharma 2. Vaidya SKS Chhangani 3. Prof. Abdul Mobin Khan 4. Dr. V Arunachalam 5. Vaidya SK Mishra 6. Dr. Jay Prakash Narayan 7. Dr. Ved Prakash Tyagi 8. Dr. V Stanley Jones 9. Dr. MA Kumar The Executive Committee discussed the matter and decided that Vice- Presidents and Chairmen of respective systems Education Committees will look into matter before sending to Government of India. 8122ec

Addl. Agenda Item No.7. Ayurved & Unani Tibbia College, New Delhi It was noted that a letter received from Principal, A& U Tibbia College, Karol bagh, New Delhi regarding re-starting the Post-graduate course in Moalijat (MD) Unani. In this context following facts were placed below for information and necessary orders:- 1. Central Council of Indian Medicine permitted first admission of three students in MD,Moalejat for 2002---2003 vide this office letter No.11-34/2002-Unani (2) dated 16.7.2003. 2. CCIM did not permit admission in MD (Moalejat) for 2003-2004 considering the lack of available facilities of teaching and practical training as well as teaching staff for the said course of studies of the college. The Registrar, Delhi University, Principal, A&U Tibbia college and other competent authorities were informed accordingly vide this Council letter No.11-34/2003-Unani (2) dated 18-19/08.2003. But despite that the college admitted three students in MD (Moalejat) for the session 2003-2004 many days after 18.8.2003. The Council referred the case for legal opinion which is reproduced below:- Ayurvedic and Unani Tibbia College, Karol bagh, New Delhi was not permitted by CCIM to admit students in Moelijat in Post Graduate course during session 2003-2004 as was decided by the Executive Committee of CCIM which was also communicated to the Registrar (Uninversity of Delhi) vide letter date 18/19.08.2003. It has been informed to CCIM that the said college admitted 3 students in MD (Unani) Moelijat inspite of the above directives of the Central Council of Indian Medicine after being permitted by the University. In view of the above, I am of the considered opinion that the act of University in allowing admission in the said college is absolutely unjustified and contrary to the provisions of IMCC Act. The Registrar of the University may be asked as tol how admissions were allowed in Ayurvedic & Unani Tibbia college when specific instructions were given not to allow admissions in the said course and a copy of the said letter may marked to Vice Chancellor of the University. The Secretary, Deptt. of ISM & H, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of Delhi may be asked as to how they allowed admission in the said course in Ayurvedic & Unani Tibbia College and copy may be marked to the Director of Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Government of Delhi. In this context Section 13 (B) (2) of IMCC (AMENDMENT) Act,1970 which is self explanatory is given below:- 9122ec

Where any medical college opens a new or higher course of study or training including a post-graduate course of study or training without the previous permission of the Central Government in accordance with the provisions of section 13 A, medical qualification granted to any student of such medical college on the basis of such study or training shall not be deemed to be a recognized medical qualification for the purposes of this Act. 4. Shortcomings were conveyed to the competent authorities in respect of visitation of the college made on 13-14,August,2003. But no compliance report has been received. 5.Visitors visited the college on 14.05.2004 on the basis of their report considering available facilities of teaching and practical training in the college the Central Council did not agree to grant permission for conducting P.G course in Moalijat for session 22004-2005. The Registrar, Delhi University, and other competent authorities were informed shortcomings vide this office letter No.11-34/2004/Unani(2) dated 18.08.2004. 6. Principal A& U Tibbia college informed vide his letter No.F.5 (64)/81-Co/891 dated 29.7.2004 that Dr.F.R.Misbahi,Reader Moalijat has been retired on 30.6.2004. The picture of teaching staff for UG and well P.G.classes of Moalejat wan not clearly specified. So the Council sent this letter No.11-11/2004-Unani (2) dated 16.08.2004 text is given below:- 1. Regarding teaching staff of Unani section of your college in the proforma qualified ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1 2 3 4 5 6. S.No. Name of Date of Medical Date of Nature of Teacher Birth qualification appointment appointment with name of college /univ. (Regular/Honrary /Ad hoc/contact basis) ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 6 7 8 9 10 11 Designation Date of Department Subject of Total teaching Remarks (Univ. of Delhi approval by teaching for experience in approved Lecturer/ the university which approved detail in chrono- Reader/Professor by the university logical order 10122ec

2. Regarding Department of Moalijat (A) Infrastructure including equipment in detail in department of Moalijat for (a) Under graduate course (b) Post-graduate course (B) Beds allotted for department of Moalijat in the Hospital (C) Diagnostic facilities with details of equipment Further it was noted that no information has been received so far. Report of Dr. Madan Sarup Gupta, Chairman, Education Committee (Unani) in the matter of re-start of M.D. Moalijat for 2004-2005 is reproduced below:- On 03.08.2004 Prof. Abdul Mobin Khan, Vice President, (Unani) phoned me from Mumbai that he is unable to come and I asked to go CCIM on 4.8.2004 since he had given an appointment to the Principal, A& U Tibbia college for 4.8.2004 to see him and me. Accordingly, I came to CCIM office. Hakim G.S.Reena, Asstt. Registrar (Unani) told me that some students of the said college want to see me. I permitted one students. He came and on his request I allowed 2 students more. The following students came:- 1. Irshad Shaik (Final Year Student) 2. Mohd.Farooq (Interne) 3. Rohit Choudhary (law Student) President,Delhi University, Soon after, Dr. B.N.Sinha, Principal, of the said college also arrived. Students said they are on strike, I told them CCIM is not aware of it, you are here without any prior information or appointment. But since you have come you can have your say. Students gave me a photocopy of a letter dated 4.8.2004 addressed to the Principal of the said college, copy to Registrar, CCIM and others from General Secretary Tibbia Medicos Association, A&U Tibbia (Medical) college, Delhi. The Principal & Students wanted CCIM to rscind its decision not permit admission of students to Post-Graduate course in Moalejat for 2004-2005 session and permit admission in Post-graduate course in Moalejat for academic year 2004-05 I told them that:- 11122ec

1.CCIM did not permit admission in Post-graduate course in Moalijat for academic year 2003-2004. but despite that the college admitted the students. 2. Shortcomings were conveyed to Delhi University, the college and other authorities vide letter No.11-34/2004-Unani dated 28.8.2003. 3. According to visitation report of the college dated 14.05.2004 Leaving aside other shortcomings, the college does not have minimum teaching staff as prescribed by CCIM even for Under graduate course. For Post-Graduate course in Moalijat also, it is lacking Principal said he had given a letter dated 23.7.2004 to the Secretary, CCIM it may considered. I went through the said letter (Letter F.5 (64)/81-CO)/Part file ) 80 dated 23.7.2004 office receipt No.3278 daed 26.7.2004 and enquired from the Principal if Dr.F.R.Misbahi who retired on 30.6.2004 was approved as Reader by Delhi University and If Dr.Ahmad yasin, Reader who has been shifted from department of Hifzan e-sehat to department of Moalejat in Delhi University is approved Reader in Moalijat. He replied there is no University approved Reader in the college including myself. College has lecturers in the grade of Reader. I said requirement of Central council of Indian Medicine is University approved teachers (Professor/Reader/Lecturer. New College has informed as under:- 1. We are pursuing to engage one retired teacher (in Reader capacity) in the department of Moalijat for PG Classes, as already approved by the screening committee constituted by Govt. of NCT of Delhi. 2. We have already sent a proposal to the competent authority for publishing of the adbvertisement in the newspapers for the appointment to the post of Reader in the Department of Moalijat along with post of Readers in the Department of Kayachikitsa & Kriya Sharir in the pay scale of Rs.1200-16500. 3. The proposal for creation of 22 posts of different categories (6 Professors, 3 Readers and 1 Lecturer in Ayurved and 6 Professors, 3 Readers and 3 Lecturer in Unani) has already been approved by the department of Administrative Reform Planning and & Finance. At present this proposal is under consideration of Hon ble Lt. Governor. 4. We are going to start a newly constructed 60 beded Maternity Centre within 15 days to enhance the bed capacity of the Hospital from 150 to 210. Separate 105 beds for Ayurveda Medicine and 105 beds for Unani Medicine. 12122ec

5. We has sent a proposal to the Forest Department Government of NCT of Delhi for development/maintenance of Plantation of Medicinal Plants in the Herbal Garden/Herbarium of the A&U Tibbia College. 6. We have already placed the order for purchase/supply of Journals to the Publishers/ Distributors to strengthen the library for UG & PG students. We have also engaged Urdu-knowing person in the library to assist the Asstt. Librarian. 7. For appointment of Group A posts, UPSC is the competent authority and to fill up the 34 posts of lectures (Ayurved/Unani) are lying pending with. The Executive Committee discussed the matter and did not agree to grant permission for conducting PG Course in Moalijat. Addl. Agenda Item No.8. vk;qoszn egkfo ky; x;k ls izkir vuqikyu izfrosnu LkwpukFkZ izlrqr gs fd vk;qoszn egkfo ky; x;k }kjk vuqikyu izfrosnu izsf"kr djrs gq, l= 2004&05 gsrq vuqefr iznku djus ds fy, vuqjks/k fd;k x;k gs A egkfo ky; us lwfpr fd;k gs fd%& egkfo ky; vius pkj,dm+ wfe esa yxhkx 20 yk[k (rkrdkfyd ewy;) ftldk orzeku ewy; djksm+ksa esa gs] ls fufezr vius futh Hkou esa voflfkr gs A vkt ds ;qx esa =Lr ekuo leqnk; ds lsokfkz,oa vk;qosznh; fpfdrlk i)fr ds izpkj&izlkjkfkz bl egkfo ky; dh LFkkiuk 2 ebz 1972 dks gqbz A 1974 esa egkfo ky; ds Nk=ksa dk fo ofo kyh; ijh{kk esa izfke izfof"v gksus dh vuqefr dkes oj flag njhkaxk fo ofo ky;] njhkaxk }kjk iznku dh xbz A rnksijkur 1977 13122ec

esa vlfkk;h lec)rk,oa 1981 esa fo ofo ky; us bl egkfo ky; dks LFkkbZ lec)rk iznku dh A bl egkfo ky; esa Hkkjr o"kz ds yxhkx lhkh izkurksa ds Nk=ksa }kjk vk;qoszn dh f k{kk xzg.k dj vius {ks= esa =Lr jksfx;ksa dh lsok dh tk jgh gs rfkk dbz rks ljdkjh lsok esa dk;zjr gs A ;gkwa ds Nk= fo ofo kyh; ijh{kk esa ges kk mpp LFkku dks izkir fd;s gsa A bl egkfo ky; dk izca/ku futh lalfkk ;k O;fDr fo ks"k ds gkfk esa ugha gs cfyd jkt; ljdkj }kjk xfbr kklh fudk; ds v/khu gs ftldk insu v/;{k ex/k ize.my ds vk;qdr,oa lfpo mifodkl vk;qdr] x;k gksrs gsa,oa dbz ljdkjh inkf/kdkjh lnl; ds :i esaa gsa A bl egkfo ky; essa dqy 72 dezpkjh dk;zjr gsa ftudk osru Hkqxrku fcgkj ljdkj ds ifjfu;eksa ds rgr csad ds ek/;e ls dezpkfj;ksa ds csad ds [kkrs ds fo:) fd;k tkrk gs A dezpkfj;ksa ds Hkfo";fuf/k ns; gs A blds fy, dezpkfj;ksa ds uke vyx&vyx csad [kkrk fo eku gs A bl egkfo ky; dk vk;&o;; dk ek/;e flqz Mz~kQ~V@pSd ds }kjk fd;k tkrk gs ftldk vads{k.k jkt; ljdkj ds forr vads{k.k fohkkx }kjk fd;k tkrk gs A ;g dkyst Hkkjrh; fpfdrlk dsunzh; ifj"kn~] ubz fnyyh ds ekin.mksa ds vuqlkj dk;kzsa dks lapkfyr djrh gs rfkk Hk-fp-ds-i-] ubz fnyyh ds vkns k ds vuq:i ukekadu dh vuqefr izkir jgus ds ckotwn bl egkfo ky; esa ukekadu ugha gks ldk gs A dkj.k ifj"kn~ }kjk tkjh i= esa fy[ks x;s jkt; ljdkj dh vuqefr,oa fo ofo ky; ls lec)rk dh krz ds vkyksd esa fcgkj ljdkj }kjk vuqefr izkir u gksuk gs A 14122ec

tc fd bl lecu/k esa jkt; ljdkj dks vusdksa i= vk;qdr] mifodkl vk;qdr,oa iz/kkukpk;z }kjk fuxzr fd;k x;k ij jkt; ljdkj }kjk vkt rd vkns k ij funs k ls lecfu/kr dksbz i= vizkir gs A fnukad 1-9-2003 dks Hkkjrh; fpfdrlk dsunzh; ifj"kn~] ubz fnyyh ds ifjn kzdksa }kjk bafxr dfe;ksa dks egkfo ky; iz kklu }kjk nwj dj fy;k x;k gs A izk/;kid o izokpd dh dfe;kaw tks fohkkxkuqlkj n kkz;h xbz Fkh] mls egkfo ky; izodrkvksa dks izksuufr nsdj mu fohkkxksa ds fjdr izk/;kid@izokpd ds inksa dks Hkjdj iwjk fd;k tk pqdk gs A egkfo ky;,oa vlirky dk i`fkd&i`fkd djrs gq, Hkk-fp-dsi-ds ekin.mksa ds vuqlkj vyx&vyx 14 fohkkxksa dh O;oLFkk gks pqdh gs A iqlrdky;,oa okpuky; esa iqlrdksa dh la[;k 2029 ls c<+kdj 3516 dj nh xbz gs A ftlesa vk;qoszn ds vfrfjdr lald`r] vk/kqfud fpfdrlk kkl=] lkfgr;,oa osn dh iqlrdsa miyc/k gsa A iqlrdky; esa 60 Nk=ksa ds csbdj v/;;u djus dh O;oLFkk gs A Nk=ksa ds fy, Nk=kokl dh lqfo/kk fdjk;s ij rrdky esa miyc/k gs] ftl ij egkfo ky; iz kklu opu nsrk gs fd,d ckj ukekadu dh vuqefr feyus ij egkfo ky; dk viuk fuft Nk=kokl N% ekg ds vunj iwjk djk fy;k tk;sxk A vkrqjky; ls lecfu/kr dfe;ksa dks nwj dj fy;k x;k gs A cfgjax fohkkx esa izfrfnu jksfx;ksa dh la[;k 150 ls mij 15122ec

gks pqdh gs ftlesa vurjax fohkkx esa izfo"v jksfx;ksa dh la[;k vkslr yxhkx 70 izfr kr gks pqdk gs A kopnsnu d{k dk {ks=qy Hkk-fp-ds-i-] ubz fnyyh ds ekin.mksa ds vuqlkj iwjk djrs gq, orzeku esa,d ko dh O;oFkk dh xbz gs A iz;ksx kkyk esa ey&ew=&jdr dh tkawp dh leqfpr O;oLFkk gs fyldk O;ogkfjdh Kku Nk=&Nk=kvksa dks nh tkrh gs A egkfo ky; ds ouks"kf/k m ku dks iw.kzr% O;ofLFkr dj nh xbz gs ftlesa fofhkuu iztkfr;ksa ds yxhkx 525 ouks"kf/k ds ifjp; gsrq uke ifv~vdk yxk;h xbz gs A lkfk gh vk;qoszn esfmdy dkyst] x;k vius izxfr ds ifk ij vxzlj gs A vr% vuqjks/k gs fd vk;qoszn esfmdy dkyst] x;k dks l= 2004-05 esa Nk=ksa dsk izos k gsrq ifjn kzu dk vkns k nsrs gq, ukekadu dh vuqefr nsus dh d`ik dh tk; A egkfo ky; iz kklu Hkkjrh; fpfdrlk dsunzh; ifj"kn~] ubz fnyyh dks ;g fo okl fnykrk gss fd vk;qoszn esfmdy dkyst]x;k fcgkj jkt;,oa Hkkjr o"kz ds lkfk&lkfk vurjkz"v~zh; Lrj ij vk;qoszn f k{kk i)fr ds izpkj&izlkj,oa i`foh ij =Lr jksfx;ksa ds lsokfkz gesa kk vxzlj jgsxka The Executive Committee discussed the matter and decided that visitation of the college be conducted at earliest. Addl. Agenda Item No.9. Dr. JJ Magdum Ayurvedic Medical College, Jaysingpur It was noted that Dr. JJ Magdum Ayurvedic Medical College at Jayasingpur, Distt. Kolhapur has requested to accord continuation of permission for the year 2004-05. In this regard following facts were placed below:- 16122ec

1. After receipt of NOC from Maharashtra University of Health Sciences, Nasik and Government of Maharashtra, the college was visited on 11.5.2001 by the visitors of CCIM to assess the available facilities for teaching and practical training for conducting Ayurvedacharya Course. 2. After assessing the available facilities of teaching and practical training, Central Council permitted the college to make admission forty (40) students for the session 2001-2002 subject to the affiliation of the University and permission of the State Government. 3. Later on, University did not grant affiliation to this college reason best known to the University. 4. College filed a writ petition No.3679/2004 in the Judicature of Hon ble High Court of Mumbai. Hon ble High Court has directed to the University to grant the affiliation to the college. Abstract of the Judgement is as under:- The respondent University is directed to consider the application made by the Petitioner for the first time affiliation expeditiously after getting permission from the CCIM and the State Government and after removing the deficiencies. It is need less to say that the University shall not reject the application made by the Petitioner on the ground of perspective plan. 5. Mahrashtra University of Health Sciences, Nasik has granted affiliation to the college subject to permission of the Central Council of Indian Medicine and State Government (copy enclosed). As per instruction of the President, CCIM the proposal has been forwarded to Government of India for taking necessary action at their end. The Executive Committee discussed the matter and decided that college should be asked to approach to the Government of India. Addl. Agenda Item No.10. Request of University of Kerala to regularize the PG exam. Conducted by College. 17122ec

It was noted that a letter of University of Kerala dated 15.6.2004 and subsequent reminder dated 31.7.2004 asking to give appropriate directions to University and assuring that Preliminary Examination will be conducted by Universities only in future. In this regard following facts were placed below:- (1) It was noted that it was came to the notice of the Central Council that Preliminary examination (after completion one year) of Post Graduate Course of Ayurved are being conducted by college not by the University. The letter were issued by the Council regarding to preliminary examination should be conducted by University only not by college. The University of Kerala was informed that the examination were conducted by the college under following confusion:- Regulation prescribe by CCIM say that the preliminary exams at the end of one academic year after admission will be conducted by Institution. In this regard IMCC Act, states as under:- (f) medical institution means any institution within or without India which grants degrees, diplomas or licences in Indian medicine; However, it was informed by the University that the examination was conducted one time. But after receipt of the letter of Council no examination will be conducted by college. In view of the letter of Council University has not declared the result of students examined by the college. If agreed it may be informed to the University as under:- Since the University is the degree awarding authority, it has to conduct examinations and should not leave it to the college concerned. Therefore, in the above case, the preliminary examination should be conducted by the University only. However, if the University is satisfied with the examination conducted by the institution, it may declare 18122ec

the results but the Regulations/instructions of the Central Council should be followed in letter and spirit and this practice should not be followed in future. The Indian Medicine Central Council (Post-graduate education) (Amendment) Regulations, 1994 are mandatory and they should be followed in toto without any deviation. Further a Writ Petition No. 18082/2004 has been also filed by the Students and Hon ble Court has given one month time to file the view. Similar request has been received of University of Calicut. The Executive Committee discussed the matter and decided that Central Council has no objection if University satisfy with the examination conducted by the College. Further, it was decided that University should be asked to follow the regulations prescribed by CCIM in toto and examination should be conducted by University only in future. Addl. Agenda Item No.11. Permission to three Ayurved Colleges of Rajasthan It was noted that visitation report of three colleges i.e. MMM Government Ayurved College, Udaipur, Bhanwar Lal Dugar Ayurved Vishwabharti Sardar Shahar and Parasurampuriya Ayurved College, Sikar were considered by Central Council and decided not to grant permission to these colleges. Accordingly, the letters were issued alongwith shortcomings. Secretary to Government of Rajasthan, Medical Health and Ayurveda Department vide letter No.25(6) Ay./2000-Pt. Dated 7.8.2004 has given assurance that all the shortcomings informed by Central Council of Indian Medicine will be fulfilled very shortly by the concerned colleges. Government of Rajasthan has assured to convert the designation of Demonstrator to Lecturer. Executive Committee considered the letter No.2(1)/vk;q/99 dated 8 th September 2004 of Director of Ayurved, Government of Rajasthan reads as under:- jktdh; enu eksgu ekyoh; vk;qoszn egkfo ky; mn;iqj esa LFkkfir o foospd ds inksa dks foyksfir dj lekir dj 19122ec

fn;s x;s gs,oa bu inksa dks ysdpjkj (izk/;kid) ds in uke esa ifjofrzr dj fn;k x;k gs A bl dze esa lqfo/kk ds fy, tkjh dh xbz vkkk dh izfr layxu dj izf"kr gsa And Office Order No.i2(1)vk;q/99 dated 8.9.2004 reads as under:- jktdh; enu eksgu ekyoh; vk;qoszn egkfo ky;] mn;iqj esa foospd inuke dks rqjur izhkko ls foyksfir fd;k tkdj foospd in dks lekir fd;k tkrk gs,oa in uke ysdpjkj esa ifjofrzr fd;k tkrk gs A foospd in lekir gksus dh flfkfr esa mdr 13 inksa dk lek;kstu ysdpjkj ds inksa esa fd;s tkus ij egkfo ky; esa miyc/k dqy 32 (13+19) inksa dk in uke (izk/;kid) tkuk tk,xk A ;g Lohd`fr forr fohkkx (fu;e fmfotu) ds vkbz- Mh- la- 4649 fnukad 6-9-2004 ds vuqlj.k esa tkjh dh tkrh gs A Executive Committee discussed the matter and decided to grant permission to MMM Government Ayurved College, Udaipur, Parasurampuriya Ayurved College, Sikar, Bhanwar Lal Dugar Ayurved Vishwabharti Sardar Shahar with intake capacity of previous year. Executive Committee in this regard also decided that :- 1. Vacant post be filled up immediately. 2. The Post of Reader should be created and filled up. 3. DPC for teachers be convened. 4. Teaching post be filled up within six months in private colleges. 20122ec

Addl. Agenda Item No.12. Request to extend the permission granted of the year 2003-04 for the year 2004-05. It was noted that a visitation report of Bapuji Ayurved Medical College & Hospital, Shimoga was considered by 121 st Executive Committee at its meeting held on 29.6.2004 and did not agree to grant permission for the session 2004-05. Accordingly letter was issued to the college in response to the same Bapuji Ayurved Medical College & Hospital, Shimoga requested vide their letter No.1490/BAMS/04 dated 7.9.2004 which is as follows:- 1. The Bapuji Ayurved Medical College & Hospital, Shimoga was established during the year 1996-97. 2. The Central Council after assessing the available facilities of teaching and practical training was permitted to the college for taking admission 40 students since its inception. 3. The Society has and had full trust in the instruction of CCIM. 4. On the basis of some misunderstandings college was made admission of Sixty admission for the session 2001-02 without the permission of CCIM but admission of 60 students were made with the permission of State Government and affiliation of the Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences, Bangalore. 5. Later admission of 60 students made for the year 2001-02 were regularized by the CCIM, but college wrongly made admission 60 students for the session 2002-03 and 2003-04 in anticipation of permission of the CCIM. 6. However, I accept it college should not made admission beyond the intake capacity sanctioned by the CCIM. 7. Now I request to you that college shall never made admission beyond the intake capacity sanctioned by CCIM. The matter of unauthorized admission made during the above said sessions may be regularized and college may be allowed to take admission 2004-05. 8. In this regard the State Government and University were also agreed to regularized admission made by the college. 9. About 110 colleges have not been proposed for visitation for this year and permission has been extended as per previous year. But only this college has been left. 21122ec

In this regard it was also noted that a letter No.ISM 10 DEV (3)/2002-03 dated 7.9.2004 received from the Director of ISM & H, Government of Karnataka, Bangalore furnish the clarifications regarding admission for the academic year 2002-03 as follows:- 1) The Government of Karnataka in their Government Order No. Akuka/295/PIM/2001 dated 11.9.2001 increased seat capacity from 40 to 60 from 2001-02 academic year. Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences, Bangalore in their Syndicate Meeting proceedings held on 31.3.2001 increased seat capacity from the existing 40 seats to 60 seats. 2) This Directorate had allotted 09 students under Government quota to the concerned college during 2002-03. 3) As per the directions given by the State Government and Rajiv Gandhi University of Health Sciences the concerned college had admitted 60 students for 1 st year BAMS during 2002-03. 4) Hence permission may kindly be granted to allow the concerned college for taking 60 students during 2002-03 academic year and onwards. The Executive Committee discussed the matter and after great deliberation decided that permission of admission of 40 students granted for the year 2003-04 be extended for the year 2004-05. Addl. Agenda Item No.13. Shri SBS Ayurvedic Medical College, Mundargi It was noted that a visitation report of SBS Ayurvedic Medical College, Mundargi was considered by 121 st Executive Committee at its meeting held on 29.6.2004 and did not agree to grant permission for the session 2004-05. Accordingly letter was issued to the college in response to the same Shri SBS Ayurvedic Medical College, Mundargi submitted its compliance report as under:- Teaching Staff We have appointed another 4 PG qualified teacher. Now there are 24 teachers working in our institution ijn which there are 7 PG qualified, 4 teachers are completed their graduation before 1989 and 2 teachers are deputed to MD so, presently we have sufficient teaching staff and hardly trying to fulfill the rest of vacant posts by giving advertisement in daily newspaper. (List of teaching start is enclosed along with their certificate of newly appointed teachers. 22122ec

Area and Land Building We have already 11-09 acres of land in which 11000 Sq.ft. is constructed for college building now our college is shifted in a new building and we have 5600 Sq.ft. rented building and we have 5600 Sq.ft. rented building for hospital. Now we have 16600 Sq.ft. building for our college and hospital and 2 nd phase of building construction of work is in progresses as per plan. We have already provided the required space in each and every department in our own college building. And we have provided the required space for 100 beded full pledge hospital OPD Laboratory and Panchkarma facility is also provided in a rented building (in 5600 Sq.ft. covered area). Library After inspecting, we have placed an order for 1500 more books. Out of which, we have received 500 books remaining 1000 books will be received very soon (Copy of books receipt is enclosed herewith). Dissection Hall We have provided 1400 Sq.ft. area for the dissection hall in our own new building and now one cadaver is available for teaching and practical training to the students. Hospital At the time of inspection, we have 75 beds in our hospital. Now we have added 25 more beds so our hospital is 100 beded and sufficient space (5600 Sq.ft.) is provided and 7 more OPDs including Shalya Shalakya Panchkarma have been also set up and bed occupancy has been increased. Laboratory The laboratory has been set up by providing sufficient space. We have appointed a qualified Lab technician for our laboratory. Pharmacy The sufficient space has been provided for Pharmacy in our new building. Herbal Garden We have provided 5 acres of land for herbal garden and more plants have been planted during this year. Operation Theater space in our hospital. Minor operation theater has been set up by providing sufficient Panchkarma Panchkarma has been set up by providing sufficient space in our hospital. Other staff No. of other staff has been increased. The Executive Committee discussed the matter and decided to allow the college for continuing the study of students admitted earlier with the permission of Central Council. 23122ec

Addl. Agenda Item No.14. Resolution of the Vice-Presidents It was noted that following resolution was placed before the Executive Committee. As per CCIM Regulations and IMCC Act, 1970 every Vice-President shall look into the matter related with their system first and thereafter it will go to the President for ratification. Similarly any policy matter first be present to the respective Vice-Chairman, thereafter it should go to President for ratification by this way so many problems comes day to day will be sorted out. The Executive Committee decided that Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha Committees and their Chairmen shall act as per IMCC Act, 1970 and Regulation made thereunder. Addl. Agenda Item No.15. Taj Tibbia College & Rasheedia General Hospital, Nagpur It was noted that Taj Tibbia college & Rasheedia General Hospital, Nagpur vide letter No.TTC/RGH/2004-2005/55 dated 21.8.2004 stated that:- It is pointed that after the Council refused permission to admit the students, the health University had withdrawn its affiliation. However, if the Council grants a fresh permission the affiliation of the University could be restored. You are, therefore, requested to kindly accord your permission to admit students for the year 2004-05 onwards immediately otherwise the desirous students will take admission in other colleges. It was also noted that college was not permitted by CCIM for the session 2000-2001 Not permitted 2001-2002 Not permitted 2002-2003 Not permitted 2003-2004 Not permitted College admitted students as per details given below:- 2000-2001 44 2001-2002 25 and college also filed the several cases but no relief was granted by Hon ble Court. 24122ec

After going through all the contents Executive Committee agree to grant the permission of admission of forty (40) students. Addl. Agenda Item No.16. Saifia Hamidia Unani Tibbia College, Burhanpur. It was noted that a letter No.2004/Adm/186 dated 8.9.2004 was received from Saifia Hamidia Unani Tibbia College, Burhanpur regarding Restoration of intake of 50 seats for 2004-05 and onwards stated as under:- That there was an intake of 50 seats in Saifia Hamidia Unani Tibbia College, Burhanpur for admitting the students to BUMS course for the last so many years. That for the academic year 2004-05 as our intake of 50 has been reduced to 40, it will cause a perpetual loss of the fees of 10 students for entire course that is four and a halfyear to the institution. Sir, in view of the perpetual financial loss caused to the institution due to reduction in an intake of 50 to 40, I request your goodself to kindly look in our case sympathetically and restore our intake of 50 for 2004-05 and further and oblige. Executive Committee noted that intake capacity of this college wrongly mentioned in the minutes of Education Committee (Unani) and Executive Committee i.e. 40 instead of intake capacity for the session 2004-05 should be fifty (50). Addl. Agenda Item No.17. Allama Iqbal Unani Tibbia College & Ahmad Hospital, Muzaffarnagar It was noted that Allama Iqbal Unani Tibbia College & Ahmad Hospital, Muzaffarnagar letter No.AIUMC/39/04MZN dated 9.9.2004 sent the compliance of the Institution as follows:- Teaching staff At the time of visitation all concerning registers seen by the visitors in which the attendance of staff is complete upto the above mentioned months (list attached). (only 10 staff are there at the time of visitation). 25122ec

Departments There are 12 departments existing in the college (i) Moalijat (ii) Kulliyat, (iii) Ilmul Amraz, (iv) Jarahat, (v) Tashreeh-ul-Badan, (vi) Atfal Aza, (vii) Ilmul Advia (viii) Niswan Atfal wa Qabala, (ix) Tahaffuzi Samaji Tibb (x) Ain Uzn Anaf Halaq (xi) Oriental Language, (xii) Ilaj Bid Tadbeer Hostel construction. Hostel is exist in rental building in the city and main building under Laboratories are as per norms of CCIM. Pharmacy is under process of development as per norms of CCIM. Hospital IPD is in functioning unfortunately no patient was admitted in IPD on above said date. In OPD Unani Medicines are used and for emergency some modern medicines are also available in the hospital because our hospital and college is situated on national high way. Dissection Hall It was made in 1993 and now we are going to enlarge preservation tank is available now. Para Medical Staff is there in as per requirements staff nurse is available at this time. We shall request to grant permission. Executive Committee considered the compliance report and was not satisfied with Compliance so did not agree to grant permission. Addl. Agenda Item No.18. Suggestions of Dr. MA Kumar, Member, CCIM Dr. MA Kumar, Member, Executive Committee pointed out that Siddha Medical Council Act promulgated by Government of Tamilnadu is contrary to the provisions of IMCC Act, 1970. Inspite of many reminders no action has been taken. So it was suggested that Council must challenge the same in the Court. 26122ec

The Executive Committee decided that after taking legal opinion needful may be done. Prof. Abdul Mobin Khan desired to visit the Andhra Board for Ayurveda & Homoeopathy and Board of Indian Medicine, Andhra Pradesh alongwith the members of the Central Council as already proposed on 13 th & 14 th September 2004. The Executive Committee agreed for the same. Meeting concluded with a vote of thanks to the Chair. 27122ec