Keeping Up With The Cheese! Research as a Foundation for Professional Coaching First International Coach Federation Research Symposium Denver, Colorado, November 2003 Anthony M Grant PhD Coaching Psychologist and Director Coaching Psychology Unit School of Psychology University of Sydney Australia NSW 2006 anthonyg@psych.usyd.edu.au www.psych.usyd.edu.au/coach www.psych.usyd.edu.au/coach/icf.htm
Overview Scientist-practitioner Model (1949 2003) The Coaching Journey The Crossroads Professionalism Is Coaching a Fad? Overview of the Research Implications for Coach Education Where to next? (c) Anthony Grant 2003 2
The Coach s Journey The Coach as the Guide in the Woods Coaching and the art of trekking (c) Anthony Grant 2003 3
The Coach s Journey The Coach as the Guide in the Woods Coaching and the art of trekking Coach s Own Development as a Journey Tenuous first steps Changing and choosing new paths Self-doubt Self-development & professional development (c) Anthony Grant 2003 4
A Mental Time Journey Think of your first ever coaching session What was the knowledge level that you brought to that first session? Superficial? Unsophisticated? Naive? Over-confident? (c) Anthony Grant 2003 5
A Mental Time Journey Think of a recent (successful) coaching session Compare your current knowledge level to you first session? What is the difference between now and then? (c) Anthony Grant 2003 6
A Mental Time Journey Think of where your knowledge will be in five years time (c) Anthony Grant 2003 7
A Mental Time Journey Think of where your knowledge will be in five years time What got us here won t get us there!! We need much much more if we are to keep up with the cheese! (c) Anthony Grant 2003 8
The Coaching Industry's Journey 1: Coaching Industry as Naive Explorer Coaching as a mixed-group on a day-trip (c) Anthony Grant 2003 9
The Coaching Industry's Journey 1: Coaching Industry as Naive Explorer Coaching as a mixed-group on a day-trip 2: Coaching Industry as Emerging-Profession Formation of associations ICF & others (c) Anthony Grant 2003 10
The Coaching Industry's Journey 1: Coaching Industry as Naive Explorer Coaching as a mixed-group on a day-trip 2: Coaching Industry as Emerging-Profession Cross-disciplinary occupation Formation of associations ICF & others 3: Maturation of the Coaching Industry Increasing sophistication clients / students University-level coach-specific education Foundational coach-specific research Development of evidence-based coaching (c) Anthony Grant 2003 11
Why Research (& S-P) is Vital True professionalism rests on evidence Extend shared knowledge base Stop selling start sharing! Ethical practice demands it Demonstrate effectiveness Human change and ROI $ Basis for coach training Critical thinking skills (c) Anthony Grant 2003 12
Is Coaching a Fad? First mention of Workplace Coaching in academic press in 1937 (1) A long-standing fad! Genuine interest from business (2) Business looking for credibility and substance Coaching touted as a huge growth industry Driven by coach training schools & credentialing mills Many claim to be qualified coaches (EMAHD Coach Accreditation) many are not well trained (3) Do they have an understanding of coaching that goes beyond their own personal coaching system and explicitly links to established theory and practice?
Coach-Specific Research (c) Anthony Grant 2003 14
Four Key Phases of Coaching Research Articles Case Studies N = 128 Group Studies (pre/post) Group Studies (Controlled) Phase 3 Phase 4 Aimed at prof. coach Human change Evaluations of effectiveness Phase 1 Internal MAC Phase 2 PhD & Internal MAC 1937 1960 1980 1990 2003 (c) Anthony Grant 2003 15
Peer-reviewed Coaching Papers from PsychInfo & DAI (1937 Nov 2003) Total Citations: (N = 128) 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 1935-1939 2 1940-1944 8 0 1 1 1 1945-1949 1950-1954 1955-1959 1960-1964 1965-1969 2 2 1970-1974 1975-1979 2 7 1980-1984 1985-1989 12 12 1990-1994 29 1995-1999 2000 - Nov 2003 49
Types of Papers from PsychInfo & DAI (1937 Nov 2003) Total Citations: N = 128 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Articles Empirical Studies 8 2 0 1 1 1 1 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 5 2 6 6 8 4 15 14 26 23 1935-1939 1940-1944 1945-1949 1950-1954 1955-1959 1960-1964 1965-1969 1970-1974 1975-1979 1980-1984 1985-1989 1990-1994 1995-1999 2000 - Nov 2003
Coach-Specific PhDs from PsychInfo & DAI (1937 Nov 2003) PhD Citations (N = 33) 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 1935-1939 0 0 1940-1944 0 1945-1949 0 1950-1954 1955-1959 0 1960-1964 0 1965-1969 1 1970 1974 4 5 2 5 0 0 1975 1979 1980-1984 1985-1989 1990-1994 1995-1999 2000 - Nov 2003 16
My Own Research Journey (c) Anthony Grant 2003 19
My Own Research Journey 2001 - Comparing cognitive and behavioral approaches to coaching (5) Cognitive only group Increased well-being no impact on performance Behavioural only group Small impact on > well-being Short-term increase in performance Combined group Increased well-being Long-term increase in performance (c) Anthony Grant 2003 20
My Own Research Journey Life Coaching Study #1 (Grant 2003) (6) Solution-focused CBC approach (N = 20) Group-based coaching (Pre/post only) Pre/post increase in goal attainment (d = 2.85) Decrease in depression, anxiety, stress Decrease in Self-reflection Increase in Insight (c) Anthony Grant 2003 21
My Own Research Journey Life Coaching Study #2 (Green, Oades & Grant 2003) (7) Intervention / Control group study (N = 46) 10-week group life coaching SF/CBC Increases in goal attainment Increase in well-being Impact measured over 40 weeks (c) Anthony Grant 2003 22
My Own Research Journey Life Coaching Study #3 (Spence & Grant 2003) (8) Individual / Group / Control study (N = 64) 10-week life coaching SF/CBC All coaching > higher levels of purpose in life, personal growth, openness to experience & goals Increase in EI (Emotion perception facet) Individuals benefited more than group (c) Anthony Grant 2003 23
My Own Research Journey Problems with Organisational Research Life Coaching easier to run studies Clinical issues in coaching populations Screening for mental health impacts on outcome measures Measurement issues Use positive psyc measure and others Caught between several worlds (c) Anthony Grant 2003 24
So, What Does The Literature Tell Us About Coaching Effectiveness? Level 1: Reactions Level 2: Learning? Level 3: Behaviour?? Level 4: Results Level 5: ROI????? Kirkpatrick (1998); Phillips (2003) (9 & 10) (c) Anthony Grant 2003 25
Evidence-Based Coaching (c) Anthony Grant 2003 26
We Need Evidenced-Based Coaching If there is so little coaching-specific research how can we have evidenced-based (11) coaching?
Evidenced-Based Coaching? If there is so little coaching-specific research how can we have evidenced-based coaching? Use the broader body of coaching-related knowledge
The Body of Knowledge 1. Philosophy Critical Thinking Skills Critical thinking skills, Socratic Method, Philosophical insights 2. Behavioral Science How we think, feel and act in the way we do 3. Adult Education Principles How adults best learn 4. Economics & Business How business runs and economic systems function Personal Development Genre Popularized, un-verified notions of motivation and change
Issues for Professionalisation The Body of Knowledge Underpinning Coaching Coaching Profession Evidenced-based Coaching Fad! Behavioural Science Adult Education EMAHD Credentialing (EveryManAndHisDog) Philosophy Thinking Skills Economics & Business University-level Education Coach-specific Research Personal Development I read-it-somewhere -and-it-feels-right-to-me
Evidenced-Based Coaching Education and Professionalism Need to explicitly link theory to practice Need critical thinking skills No Gurus established body of testable & shared knowledge Linked shared knowledge base means greater credibility and a real future
Evidenced-Based Coach Education Explicitly drawn from all four areas Mental health issues Coaches need basic diagnostic skills 25% - 50% of Life Coaching clients have mental health issues (11) Basic training in psychometrics Some coaching assessment / development tools are very poor Little or no critical appraisal of tools Less focus on marketing More solid theory and evidenced-based education Less USA-influenced coaching OK for the USA but not for all More local cultural flavour
Avenues for Future Research Impact on EI and psych constructs Impact on personality traits Workplace performance / culture / wellbeing Executive / leadership skills Cognitive and behavioural change RIO and many others. (c) Anthony Grant 2003 33
Barriers to Future Research Few places to publish uniformed reviewers Poor training in research skills Coach schools don t teach application of research / evidenced-based approach Need a new model of coaching - Scientist-practioner model (c) Anthony Grant 2003 34
Where To Next? Four Key Players. (c) Anthony Grant 2003 35
The Four Key Players Coach Training Schools Gatekeeper s responsibility Shift from propriety systems Cite and reference teaching materials ICF Push for evidenced-based links Sponsor good quality research Foster critical thinking skills (c) Anthony Grant 2003 36
The Four Key Players Students & Practitioners Demand more sophistication Get cross-disciplinary training Hold no Gurus - Scientist-practitioner Model Researchers and Us Here Today Take up the challenge Remain coachable not the expert Conduct good quality research Collaborate. (c) Anthony Grant 2003 37
What s The Take Away..? Draw on a wide body of knowledge University-level education is vital Research and theory development is crucial Evidence-base will lead to professionalism We all have a role to play What s yours going to be? (c) Anthony Grant 2003 38
What s The Take Away..? Enjoy coaching conference and keep up with the cheese or be eaten by the mouse!! (c) Anthony Grant 2003 39
Keeping Up With The Cheese! Research as a Foundation for Professional Coaching First International Coach Federation Research Symposium Denver, Colorado, November 2003 Anthony M Grant PhD Coaching Psychologist and Director Coaching Psychology Unit School of Psychology University of Sydney Australia NSW 2006 anthonyg@psych.usyd.edu.au www.psych.usyd.edu.au/coach www.psych.usyd.edu.au/coach/icf.htm
References (1) Gorby, C. B. (1937). Everyone gets a share of the profits. Factory Management & Maintenance, 95, 82-83. (2) Wales, S. (2003). Why coaching? Journal of Change Management, 3(3), 275-282. (3) Brotman, L. E., Liberi, W. P., & Wasylyshyn, K. M. (1998). Executive coaching: The need for standards of competence. Consulting Psychology Journal: Practice and Research, 50(1), 40-46. (4) Bullock, A., Stallybrass, & Trombley, S. (Eds.). (1988). The Fontana dictionary of modern thought. London: Fontana Press. (5) Grant, A. M. (2001). Coaching for enhanced performance. Comparing cognitive and behavioural coaching approaches. Paper presented at the 3rd Spearman Conference, Sydney, Australia. (6) Grant, A. M. (2003). The impact of life coaching on goal attainment, metacognition and mental health. Social Behavior and Personality, 31(3), 253-264. (7) Green, L. S., Oades, L. G., & Grant, A. M. (2003). An evaluation of a life coaching group program: Preliminary findings from a wait-list control study. Poster presented at the International Positive Psychology Summit, Washington DC. (8) Spence, G. B., & Grant, A. M. (2003). Individual and Group Life-Coaching: Initial Findings from a Randomised, Controlled Trial. 1st Australian Evidence-Based Coaching Conference. (9) Kirkpatrick, D. (1998). Evaluating training programs (2 ed.). San Francisco CA: Berrett- Koehler. (10) Phillips, J. J. (2003). Return on Investment in Training and Performance Improvement Programs. New York: Butterworth-Heinemann. (11) Sackett, D. L., Haynes, R. B., Guyatt, G. H., & Tugwell, P. (1996). Evidenced based medicine: What it is and what is isn't. British Medical Journal, 13, 71-72.
Keeping Up With The Cheese! Research as a Foundation for Professional Coaching First International Coach Federation Research Symposium Denver, Colorado, November 2003 Anthony M Grant PhD Abstract The next five years (2003-2008) will be a critical and a fascinating time for professional coaches. The coaching industry has outgrown its existing theoretical and empirical research knowledge base. Those that employ coaches and potential students of coaching are becoming more sophisticated and better informed, demanding evidence for the effectiveness of different types of coaching, and seeking an articulation of the underpinning theoretical frameworks. Consequently, many professional coaches have moved away from reliance on the proprietary coaching systems taught in many commercial coach training schools, and are seeking to work within the scientist-practitioner model as both producers and consumers of coaching-related research. This is a fascinating time, because research into coaching offers far greater opportunities than just calculating effectiveness or return on investment. Evidence-based coaching interventions are an ideal means for investigating the personal and systemic mechanisms and processes involved in real-life human change in individuals and organisations. Furthermore, the increase in coaching-related research marks a new stage in the maturation of the coaching industry, and the adoption of the scientist-practitioner model will be a critical factor as coaching seeks to further establish itself as a respected, crossdisciplinary means of facilitating human and organisational change. This paper discusses these issues, presents an overview of the key themes and emergent patterns in the peerreviewed literature on coaching since 1937, and highlights the relevance of research to evidence-based coaching practice.