Researcher Development Assessment A: Knowledge and intellectual abilities

Transcription

1 Researcher Development Assessment A: Knowledge and intellectual abilities Domain A: Knowledge and intellectual abilities This domain relates to the knowledge and intellectual abilities needed to be able to carry out excellent research. Characteristic descriptor A1 Knowledge base Skill level (1-5) 1= no evidence 2 = low 3 = average 4 = strong 5 = outstanding 1 Subject knowledge I have a core knowledge and basic understanding of key concepts, issues and history of thought. I am aware of recent advances within my own research area and in related areas. I am working towards making an original contribution to knowledge. I am developing awareness of international and non-academic dimensions of knowledge creation. 2 Research Methods I understand relevant research methodologies and techniques and their appropriate theoretical application within my own research area. I can justify the principles and experimental techniques used in my own research. 3 Research Methods I can skilfully use a range of research methods linked to my study area and can document practical my own activity. I can demonstrate growth in competence in my own subject area and I am developing my awareness of alternative methods/techniques. 4 Information seeking I can acquire and develop information search and discovery skills and techniques. I can identify and access appropriate bibliographical resources, archives and other sources of relevant information including web based resources, primary sources and repositories. I can make best use of a range of current tools and techniques. I can assess the reliability, reputation and relevance of sources. I seek feedback from relevant groups to achieve other insights. 5 Information literacy and management I am capable of designing and executing systems for the acquisition and collation of information using information technology (e.g. word processing, spreadsheets, simulation systems, databases) appropriately. I am developing an awareness of information/data security and longevity issues. I know where to obtain expert advice i.e. information/data managers, archivists and librarians. 1

2 6 Languages I have excellent knowledge of the language(s) (including technical) which are appropriate for my research. 7 Academic literacy and numeracy I can prepare grammatically and syntactically correct text for written or oral presentation. I can write clearly and in a style appropriate to purpose and context for specialist and nonspecialist audiences. I am mathematically competent to undertake research in my own discipline/research area and understand and can apply any statistics that may be used in my discipline/research area. I can analyse data and use appropriate computer packages. I am IT literate and digitally competent, I can use virtual networks for research. A2 Cognitive abilities 1 Analysing I can critically analyse and evaluate my own findings and those of others. I can validate the datasets of others. 2 Synthesising I see connections between sections of my own information/data and previous studies. I will benefit from guidance in order to synthesise information/data and ideas. 3 Critical thinking I am able to understand arguments and theories (oral and textual) and articulate my own assumptions; I am developing independent and critical thinking. I have the ability to recognise and validate problems. I can recognise multiple ways of knowing. 4 Evaluating I am able to summarise documents and reports and can reflect on my progress. I can evaluate the impact and outcomes of my own research activities. I can assess the quality, integrity and authenticity of primary and secondary research information/data. I am able to receive and give constructive criticism. 5 Problem solving I can isolate basic themes of my own research and formulate basic research questions and hypotheses. A3 Creativity 1 Inquiring mind I demonstrate a willingness and an ability to learn and acquire knowledge. I am developing a style of questioning and questioning techniques. 2 Intellectual insight I can absorb and appropriate ideas and am intellectually sharp. I can create ideas and opportunities by investigating/seeking information. 3 Innovation I understand the role of innovation and creativity in research. I may engage in interdisciplinary research. 2

3 4 Argument construction I can constructively defend my research outcomes. I am able to provide evidence in support of ideas. I can structure oral and written arguments concisely and intelligibly 5 Intellectual risk I test the boundaries, I am willing to expose my ideas to a critical audience and to critically appraise other research. Researcher Development Assessment B: Personal effectiveness Domain B: Personal effectiveness This domain contains the personal qualities, career and selfmanagement skills required to take ownership for and engage in professional development. Characteristic descriptor B1 Personal Qualities Skill level (1-5) 1= no evidence 2 = low 3 = average 4 = strong 5 = outstanding 1 Enthusiasm I can maintain enthusiasm and motivation for my own research. 2 Perseverance I can demonstrate self-discipline, motivation and thoroughness. I persevere in the face of obstacles and set-backs but benefit from peer, supervisor or leader support. I deal effectively with the dull, routine, aspects of research. 3 Integrity I can demonstrate an appreciation of standards of good research practice in the institution and/or discipline/research area. I seek guidance as necessary. 4 Self-confidence I am aware of some personal abilities and am willing to demonstrate them. I recognise the boundaries of my own knowledge, skills and expertise and draw upon and use sources of support as appropriate. 5 Self-reflection I make time to reflect on practice and experience. I develop my strengths and improve on my weak areas. I seek personal feedback. I learn from my mistakes. 6 Responsibility I am capable of gradually taking complete responsibility for my own project and my own well-being and developing independence. 3

4 1 Preparation and prioritisation B2 Self-management I prepare and plan my project to fulfil objectives and with support. I am able to adapt if necessary. 2 Commitment to research I am determined to complete my first project. I can commit to my own project and establish my research credentials. 3 Time management I can manage my own time effectively to complete my research project; I can adhere to a clear plan. 4 Responsiveness to change I can adapt my approach when required to, seek guidance and carefully consider risk. 5 Work-life balance I am developing an awareness of work-life balance issues. I use support and advisory resources when necessary to avoid undue pressure and to enhance my personal well-being. I am alert to the needs of others. B3 Professional and career development 1 Career management I can take ownership of and manage my own career progression, I can set realistic and achievable career goals, and I can identify and develop ways to improve employability. I am able to present my own skills, personal attributes and experiences through effective CVs, applications and interviews. I am beginning to establish a career network. 2 Continuing professional development 3 Responsiveness to opportunities I can appreciate the need to show commitment to continuing professional development. I can recognise the transferability of own experience and can articulate this to potential employers or line managers. I am able to develop and maintain my own records of achievement and experience. I can demonstrate an insight into the transferable nature of research skills to other work environments and the range of career opportunities within and outside academia. I seek to gain a broader range of experience. 4 Networking I can develop and maintain co-operative networks and working relationships with supervisors, colleagues and peers, within the institution and the wider research community. 5 Reputation and esteem I can speak with authority on my own topic. I am beginning to be known as a good researcher. 4

5 Researcher Development Assessment C: Research governance and organisation Domain C: Research governance and organisation This domain relates to the knowledge of the standards, requirements and professional conduct that are needed for the effective management of research. Characteristic descriptor C1 Professional conduct Skill level (1-5) 1= no evidence 2 = low 3 = average 4 = strong 5 = outstanding 1 Health and safety I can understand relevant health and safety issues and demonstrate responsible working practices. I am able to take responsibility for my own work space and am aware of my impact on others and the wider environment. 2 Ethics and principles and sustainability I can show knowledge and understanding of ethical requirements and codes of conduct appropriate for my discipline/research area, research council and professional association/body. I can take responsibility for ethics in my own project. I am able to demonstrate an awareness of issues relating to the rights of other researchers, of research subjects, and of others who may be affected by my research. I am mindful of the environment and my own impact on it. I understand how to behave and work in a sustainable way. I understand the concept of corporate social responsibility and will seek guidance as necessary. 3 Legal requirements I have a basic understanding of legal requirements surrounding research (e.g. Data Protection Act, Freedom of Information Act, Disability Discrimination Act and equality legislation). 4 IPR and copyright I have a basic understanding of data ownership rules as they apply to my own research. 5 Respect and confidentiality Within my own research I respect the right of participants to confidentiality and anonymity. I respect colleagues. 6 Attribution and co-authorship I understand the concept of attribution and apply it consistently and fairly in order to appropriately recognise contributions and co-authorships. I am able to seek advice on local codes of conduct. 5

6 7 Appropriate practice I understand and adhere to the rules and regulations concerning academic malpractice in the institution in which I am based. I also adhere to the rules and regulations of the professional body and funder where appropriate. C2 Research Management 1. Research strategy I understand how my own research aligns with the research strategy of the institution and strategic focus of the discipline/research area. I can develop an understanding of the broader context of research. 2. Project planning an delivery I can apply effective project management skills through the setting of research goals, intermediate milestones and prioritisation of activities. I act on decisions agreed with my supervisor/line manager and can deliver results. 3. Risk management I can make basic risk assessment and, with support, I am able to manage risks in my own project. I am aware of the risks in virtual environments and when using interactive communication technologies. C3 Finance, funding and resources 1 Income and funding generation I understand the processes for funding and evaluation of research. I can write an individual research proposal. 2 Financial management I understand the basic principles of financial management. I have commercial awareness. 3 Infrastructure and resources I make the best use of available resources. I know my immediate academic system/work environment. 6

7 Researcher Development Assessment D: Engagement, influence and impact Domain D: Engagement, influence and impact This domain relates to the knowledge, understanding and skills needed to engage with, influence and impact on the academic, social, cultural, economic and broader context. Characteristic descriptor D1 Working with others Skill level (1-5) 1= no evidence 2 = low 3 = average 4 = strong 5 = outstanding 1 Collegiality I can show consideration to others. I am able to listen, give and receive feedback, and respond perceptively to others. 2 Team working I understand my own behaviour and its impact on others when working in and contributing to the success of formal and informal teams. I can appreciate the contributions of other team members including non-academic members. I can thank people for their contribution. 3 People management I am able to negotiate activities and deadlines with my supervisor/line manager. 4 Supervision I am able to engage in peer support and evaluation, and undergraduate support and assessment. 5 Mentoring I can effectively support the learning of others when involved in teaching, mentoring, demonstrating or other research activities. I recognise the importance of mentorship. 6 Influence and leadership I can engage in debate and invite challenge. I am developing an awareness of the need to gain support. I can recognise the implications of my own research for real life contexts. I am learning the value to academia of engaging in dialogue with users to achieve influence and impact. 7 Collaboration I have a developing awareness of the value of working collaboratively in order to benefit research and to maximise the potential for impact. I am working towards co-production of knowledge with supervisors/research leaders. I can recognise common/conflicting interests within my own and adjacent disciplines/research areas. 7

8 8 Equality and diversity I am sensitive to and respectful of individual differences. I am developing an awareness of diversity and difference within the working environment. I am able to understand the equality and diversity requirements of my institution. D2 Communication and dissemination 1 Communication methods I can construct coherent arguments and articulate ideas clearly to a range of audiences, formally and informally, through a variety of techniques, including written and oral formats. I can listen to debate and engage with the audience. I am able to actively engage in knowledge exchange with colleagues, sometimes across disciplines/research areas. 2 Communication media I am developing skills in a range of communication areas where useful and/or necessary, e.g. face-to-face interaction using interactive technologies, textual and visual media. I have a web presence as a researcher. I can use visual aids effectively in presentations. 3 Publication I am able to understand the processes of publication and academic exploitation of research results. I am working towards producing publishable material in print, electronic or other format. I am developing an awareness of the range and diversity of outlets for publications. D3 Engagement and impact 1 Teaching I am willing to contribute to teaching at undergraduate level. I can assist in the supervision of undergraduate projects. I am able to participate in research meetings (seminars, workshops, conferences, etc). I am developing an awareness of the ways research influences/enhances teaching. 2 Public engagement I can understand the value of engaging with the public. I willingly participate with the public and I am open to the influence of public interactions on my own work. I am able to respond to local opportunities and existing activities; I can present aspects of my research at public events. 3 Enterprise I can create ideas and spot opportunities internally and externally. I am developing ideas in an innovative manner within my own institution or externally. I understand the process of commercial exploitation of research results. I am willing to learn of the value to academia of establishing relationships in business/commercial context. 8

9 4 Policy I can understand relevant policy-making processes and can present my findings in a policy-friendly format. I am able to analyse policies and understand the wider contexts within which they are situated. 5 Society and culture I am developing an awareness of the impact of research on wider society and of the impact of society, the environment and culture on research. I can understand the concept of corporate social responsibility. 6 Global citizenship I can show a broad understanding of the context in which my own research takes place, at national and international levels. Note: PhD Students should complete the Researcher Development Assessment online after they have attended a Researcher Development Assessment Workshop provided as part of the Graduate School s Researcher Development Programme. Workshops can be booked by accessing the online booking system at: The above assessment is available on-line and followed by free text boxes in which you will be asked to analyse your results and identify a plan for your development (please see below). Having rated your skills in the above RDF areas, please consider your results and use the overall analysis box below to write a commentary on the outcome. You should outline: (i) the evidence for areas where you have identified that you already have a high skill level and (ii) list areas where you judge that you need to undertake more development opportunities to improve your skills. Overall Analysis Having considered your results, please use the development opportunities box below to outline a plan for developing skills in the areas you have identified. Opportunities for developing skills are available through participation in workshops offered as part of the Graduate School s Researcher Development Programme as well as participation in School-based training and other career development opportunities. You should use the box below to identify all types of development opportunity. If you identify areas of training that are not currently available via your School or the Graduate School, please contact: skills@kent.ac.uk. Development opportunities 9