Language is characterized by: Language is characterized by: Language. Why is language a major area of research?

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Language is characterized by: Language is characterized by: Language. Why is language a major area of research?"

Archibald Knight
6 years ago
Views:

1 Language Language is: a a rule based system of symbolic codes used for communication. Language is characterized by: Semantics Rules used to communicate meaning. Grammar (syntax) A limited set of rules describing how we can combine the symbols in certain orders. Arbitrariness No inherent relationship between symbol & referent. 1 2 Language is characterized by: Generative A limited number of symbols can be combined in (infinitely) novel ways. Applies to syntax and semantics Dynamic (Changes occur over time) New words are added to the lexicon (but not new sounds; Xhosa) Rules of grammar change Displacement Ability to refer to objects not physically present. Vervet monkey (Cheney( & Seyfarth, 1990). Why is language a major area of research? Language requires many other capacities Perception, categorization, memory, motor skill It can be explored from MANY different perspectives. It may be the one ability unique to humans. It may be the heart of thought

2 The Relationship of Language & Thought Sapir-Whorf (1956) Hypothesis Linguistic relativity (strong version) Distinctions encoded in one language are not found in any other language. Translation programs--sometimes fine distinctions are missed The Relationship of Language & Thought Sapir-Whorf (1956) Hypothesis Linguistic determinism (weak version) The structure and complexity of a language determines how we perceive and think about the world. Language may influence, but not determine, our perception of the world. ambiguous figures 5 6 Now that we have an idea of what language is and isn t, where does it come Did language evolve? (How do children learn language?) Did language evolve?. The emergence of a "language" in an evolving population of neural networks. Connection Science, 10, [Section on Evolution from textbook] 7 8 2

3 Given limited evidence (no fossils) it is difficult to prove language evolved, so simulations may provide useful evidence. What was done in the present simulation? 100 simple organisms (ANN) try to eat mushrooms Feedforward net w/14 input, 5 outputs, 5 hidden units Edible & poisonous mushrooms look similar. 2 one-word utterances are communicated among NN Location of mushroom can be determined before edibility, so the words avoid & approach would be useful 9 10 At the end of life (a certain number of time steps), the 20 individuals with the most energy (from eating mushrooms) produce 5 offspring each. Offspring have the same connection weights as parents (with 10% genetic mutations of weights). This is repeated for 1000 generations

4 3 populations were examined: 1) No language language inputs always =.5, everyone must learn about mushrooms on their own. 2) Language is externally provided 3) Language evolves A creature sees a mushroom and labels it for another randomly selected creature nearby Results After 1000 generations the creatures were very good at discriminating mushrooms. 28 mushrooms and 1 toadstool on average No-language group had 150 energy units whereas those with language had more than 250 units. No difference between outside- and evolvedlanguage, but outside-language group reached plateau faster. 15 Ability to categorize objects in the environment based on perceptual properties, repeated social interactions, and language may have co-evolved. A consistent/distinct signal for mushroom/toadstool increases reproductive chances. Analysis of the output units in the no-language group shows some support for this idea; increases in the quality of the signal coincide with an increase in fitness. The signal can act as a substitute for perceptual information when the object cannot be perceived This is the power of language an abstract symbol. 16 4

5 Production and perception must have evolved in parallel. One w/o the other is useless All languages have both abilities How can language evolve if its informative function may be advantageous to the receiver but not the producer? Why not lie to get all the food for yourself? Vervet monkeys don t lie, they signal lion when they see it, snake when they see it, etc. 17 The results are consistent with Burling (1993) Human language evolved from the cognitive (sensory-motor) capacities of pre-lingual ancestors rather than primate level communication. 18 Where did language come Ulbaek (1998). The origin of language and cognition. In Hurford, Studdert- Kennedy & Knight (eds). Approaches to the evolution of language. Where did language come Language evolved from animal cognition NOT animal communication

6 Where did language come Language grew out of cognitive systems already in existence and working. It formed a communicative bridge between animals that were already cognitive. Where did language come Consider the cognitive processes used for: Tool-using and making Cognitive maps Learning through imitation Social knowledge Deception Theory of mind Similar processes are used with language Where did language come Language was used by early species to communicate thoughts. Sharing thoughts can be disadvantageous. So why bother? Where did language come Greater cognitive intelligence outweighed that disadvantage. Social conditions such as reciprocal altruism (increased fitness by sharing and helping) lead to greater cognitive intelligence. Was the first language even spoken?

7 Is sign language a real language? YES! (LSA in 1970 s) Same developmental trajectory as spoken language Babble (9 m.o.) 50 word stage ( ( 2 y.o.) It has syntax, semantics, morphology, phonology. Uses same parts of the brain as spoken language Signed languages emerge spontaneously How do we learn/acquire language? Language acquisition involves several stages: Babbling 4-6 m. <all sounds> 9 m <in/out & less/more common> First words: 1 year old Overextension (milk, juice, glass, cup = bati ) Underextension (Only Spot is doggie ) How do we learn/acquire language? Displacement & Over-regularization are also exhibited about this time (18 m.) A rule is applied to a word that is an exception to the rule. In applying the rule X + s = plural a child might say "mouses" instead of "mice." How do we learn/acquire language? Holophrastic Speech One word means many things Telegraphic Speech: months old Children have a vocabulary explosion after about 50 words (expressive); 18 months

8 What can Physics tell us about language? Watts (2004). The new science of networks. Annual Review of Sociology, 30, Important ideas to understand from Watts (2004) This article highlights the importance of interdisciplinary cross- Each field reinvented the wheel A network is a useful tool to represent various systems Biological, Social, Technological, etc. systems Important ideas to understand from Watts (2004) Note that this type of network is more general or abstract than the artificial neural networks we discussed earlier. These networks do NOT learn, do NOT have activation levels, etc. Nodes = an entity Links = a relationship between entities In general these networks describe structures, not processes. However, structure does have implications for processing 31 Important ideas to understand from Watts (2004) Many real-world networks are interesting mixtures of ordered and random networks. Two types of networks that have received much recent attention are small-world and scale-free networks. Small-world Although the network is very large, there are random shortcuts that allow one to traverse the network very quickly. Scale-free There are a few highly-interconnected nodes that contribute to the robustness (to damage) of the network. Growth and preferential attachment are two mechanisms that lead to this type of structure. 32 8

Evolution of Symbolisation in Chimpanzees and Neural Nets

Evolution of Symbolisation in Chimpanzees and Neural Nets Angelo Cangelosi Centre for Neural and Adaptive Systems University of Plymouth (UK) a.cangelosi@plymouth.ac.uk Introduction Animal communication