PROCEEDINGS OF 265 th MEETING OF THE ERC-NCTE HELD ON 08 th 09 th JANUARY, 2019

Transcription

1 PROCEEDINGS OF 265 th MEETING OF THE ERC-NCTE HELD ON 08 th 09 th JANUARY, 2019 The 265 th Meeting of the Eastern Regional Committee (ERC), National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) was convened on 08 th 09 th January, 2019 at Conference Hall, ERC, NCTE, 15, Neelakantha Nagar, Nayapalli, Bhubaneswar. The Chairperson, Members and Convener as listed below were present at the time of the 265 th ERC Meeting. Prof. Brajanath Kundu - Chairperson Dr. Pratap Indra Dash - State Representative of Odisha Dr. Tayek Talom - State Representative of Arunachal Pradesh Prof. Deva Kumar Dutta - State Representative of Assam Ms. J.Ch. Momin - State Representative of Meghalaya Mr. Awadhesh Kumar Singh - State Representative of Bihar Prof. Vanlalhruaii - State Representative of Mizoram Ms. Naorem Santa Devi - State Representative of Manipur Mr. Pradeep Kumar Yadav - Regional Director (I/C), ERC & Convener As per the notice for meeting issued by this office, the 265 th meeting of ERC scheduled from 08 th 09 th January, The Chairperson, ERC is unable to attend the meeting on 08 th 09 th January, 2019 and given consent to continue the meeting in her absence. The members present in the meeting hereby unanimously decided that in absence of Chairperson ERC, Prof. Brajanath Kundu, Member, ERC shall function as Chairperson. At the outset, the Regional Director welcomed all the members of Committee and apprised them about the provisions of the NCTE Act, Rules, Regulations and Guidelines issued from time to time. With the permission of Chairperson, Mr. Pradeep Kumar Yadav (Convener) presented the Agenda before the Committee for its due consideration and appropriate decision. Sl. No. Item No. Content Confirmation of the Proceedings of 264 th ERC meeting held on 05 th 06 th ER December, 2018 at Bhubaneswar. Confirmed. ATTENTION! 1. The Committee unanimously decided that the institution may reply in response to the decision of the Committee uploaded on the ERC website without waiting for formal letters from the office of ERC. The replies so received will also be considered by the committee. 2. The Endowment Fund / Reserve Fund (5 Lakhs + 7 Lakhs) is 12 Lakhs per programme. (See ERC website: for detail). 3. The institution needs to submit list of 10 schools for internship and school based activities duly approved by District Education Officer. 4. Institutions must give the affidavit for consent / willingness for number of units either one or two if it was not submitted earlier. 5. As per provisions u/s 17(4) of the NCTE Act, 1993, if an institution offers any course or training in Teacher Education without obtaining recognition or permission under this Act, the qualification in teacher education obtained pursuant to such course or training or after undertaking a course or training in such institution, shall not be treated as a valid qualification for purposes of employment under the Central Government, any State Government or University, or in any school, college or other educational body aided by the Central Government or any State Government. 6. The Committee suggested to prepare Data Bank for the teachers. 7. The institution needs to install Fire Safety equipment and submit the Fire Safety Certificate if not submitted earlier. 1

2 ER [Court Case] Usha Hiranmaye Teachers Training Institute D.El.Ed. and B.Ed., Plot No.-148, 149, 1173, 163, 164, Street No.- Hukahara, Vill. - Hukahara, PO. - Joykrishnapur, Tehsil/Taluka- Jalangi, Town/City - Jalangi, Dist - Murshidabad, West Bengal (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (ERCAPP2987) As decided in 239 th ERC Meeting, recognition to D.El.Ed. Course was refused vide order dated The institution preferred an appeal to the NCTE HQs. against the refusal order of ERC and the Appellate Authority vide order No /E-11469/2017 Appeal/19 th Meeting-2017/61368 dated rejected the appeal and the order of the ERC is confirmed. The institution preferred W.P.(C) No.2367 (w) of 2018 in the Hon ble High Court of Calcutta. The Hon ble High Court disposed of the matter on with a direction inter alia: Petitioners are interested in obtaining recognition to conduct D.El.Ed. course in their institute. Inspection was held in January, 2017 which did not result in recognition being granted. While Mr. Mallick, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioners submits, inspection was held on a date when his clients were not present as earlier informed to the Council, Mr. Nandy, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the Council submits, inspection cannot be on chosen date of institute. Mr. Nandy, however, in fairness submits, if the institute complies with formalities then fresh inspection can be held for prospective grant of recognition. Mr. Mallick submits, his clients will comply with the formalities within ten days. Petitioners will comply with requisite formalities. On such compliance the Council will cause inspection and deal with the institute s claim for recognition. The Council should cause inspection so that recognition, if to be granted, can be granted for ensuing academic year. The Committee considered the order of the Hon ble High Court of Calcutta and decided as under: VT be constituted Usha Hiranmaye Teachers Training Institute D.El.Ed. and B.Ed., Plot No.-148, 149, 1173, 163, 164, Street No.- Hukahara, Vill. - Hukahara, PO. - Joykrishnapur, Tehsil/Taluka- Jalangi, Town/City - Jalangi, Dist - Murshidabad, West Bengal (B.Ed.) (Private) (The West Bengal University of Teachers Training, Education Planing and Administration) (ERCAPP2992) As decided in 239 th ERC Meeting, recognition to B.Ed. Course was refused vide order dated The institution preferred an appeal to the NCTE HQs. against the refusal order of ERC and the Appellate Authority vide order No /E-11468/2017 Appeal/19 th Meeting-2017/61371 dated rejected the appeal and the order of the ERC is confirmed. The institution preferred W.P.(C) No.2369 (w) of 2018 in the Hon ble High Court of Calcutta. The Hon ble High Court disposed of the matter on with a direction inter alia: Petitioners are interested in obtaining recognition to conduct B.Ed. course in their institute. Inspection was held in January, 2017 which did not result in recognition being granted. While Mr. Mallick, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioners submits, inspection was held on a date when his clients were not present as earlier informed to the Council, Mr. Nandy, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the Council submits, inspection cannot be on chosen date of institute. Mr. Nandy, however, in fairness submits, if the institute complies with formalities then fresh inspection can be held for prospective grant of recognition. Mr. Mallick submits, his clients will comply with the formalities within ten days. Petitioners will comply with requisite formalities. On such compliance the Council will cause inspection and deal with the institute s claim for recognition. The Council should cause inspection so that recognition, if to be granted, can be granted for ensuing academic year. The Committee considered the order of the Hon ble High Court of Calcutta and decided as under: VT be constituted. 2

3 ER [Misc Case] Baidyanath Shukla College of Education, Plot Nos. 197, 64, 197, 65 & 74, Main Road, Vill.- Jaganpura, PO.- Majhauli, Tehsil/Taluka- Lalganj, Town/City- Vaishali, Dist- Vaishali, Bihar (B.Ed.) (Private) (Babasaheb Bhimrao Ambedkar Bihar University) (ERCAPP3272) As decided in 264 th ERC Meeting, recognition granted to B.Ed. course with an intake of 100 (two basic units) from the academic session vide order No dated A representation vide letter Ref. No.BSCE/ERC-NCTE/2018/03 dated , together with copy of letter Ref. No.Sec./ERC/BSCE/16 dated submited earlier to ERC regarding consideration of trust viz. Vaishali Foundation instead of Human Resources Empowerment Committee received from Baidyanath Shukla, Secretary of the institution and connected documents such as trust deed, notarized permanent agreement on Rs.1000/- stamp paper, abstract of resolutions dated regarding desolation of Human Resources Empowerment Committee for correction in recognition order of the aforesaid course mentioning the trust i.e. Vaishali Foundation, Jaganpura, Majhauli, Vaishali, Bihar, which is running the institution. The trust viz. Vaishali Foundation is accepted and necessary changes be incorporated in the recognition order issued earlier Baidyanath Shukla College of Education, Plot Nos. 197, 64, 197, 65 & 74, Main Road, Vill.- Jaganpura, PO.- Majhauli, Tehsil/Taluka- Lalganj, Town/City- Vaishali, Dist- Vaishali, Bihar (4 year Intergrated B.A.B.Ed./B.Sc. B.Ed. Course) (Private) (Babasaheb Bhimrao Ambedkar Bihar University) (ERCAPP3295) As decided in 264 th ERC Meeting, recognition granted to 4 year Integrated B.A.B.Ed./B.Sc.B.Ed. course with an intake of 100 (two basic units) from the academic session vide order No dated A representation vide letter Ref. No.BSCE/ERC-NCTE/2018/04 dated , together with copy of letter Ref. No.Sec./ERC/BSCE/16 dated submited earlier to ERC regarding consideration of trust viz. Vaishali Foundation instead of Human Resources Empowerment Committee received from Baidyanath Shukla, Secretary of the institution and connected documents such as trust deed, notarized permanent agreement on Rs.1000/- stamp paper, abstract of resolutions dated regarding desolation of Human Resources Empowerment Committee for correction in recognition order of the aforesaid course mentioning the trust i.e. Vaishali Foundation, Jaganpura, Majhauli, Vaishali, Bihar, which is running the institution. The trust viz. Vaishali Foundation is accepted and necessary changes be incorporated in the recognition order issued earlier. ER [Court Case] Y B N College for Teacher Education, Street/Road - Bara Kawali, Taluka/Mandal - Namkum, Dist. - Ranchi, Jharkhand (B.Ed. and D.El.Ed.) (Ranchi University and Jharkhand Academic Council) (Private) (ERCAPP ) (ID No.10685) As decided in 263 rd ERC Meeting, Letter of Intent u/c 7(13) issued on to the institution. The institution preferred W.P.(C) No.2404 (w) of 2018 in the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand in connection with early conduct of inspection of their institution as because previously inspection was conducted by visiting team member found fake later. Copy of order of the Hon ble High Court dated disposing of the matter received on , with a direction inter alia: Accordingly, the respondent No.3-Eastern Regional Committee, National Council for Teacher Education, Bhubaneswar, is directed to take further steps with regard to grant of recognition of the petitioner-college for the applied courses expeditiously. It goes without saying that if further compliance is required from the petitioner in this regard, it shall do the same as may be asked by the respondent No.3. The Committee considered the order of the Hon ble High Court of Jharkhand along with compliance of Letter of Intent u/c 7(13) from the institution and decided as under: Formal recognition order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation, 2014 for B.Ed. programme with an intake 100 (two basic units) from the academic session be issued to the institution. (ii) Formal recognition order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation, 2014 for D.El.Ed. programme with an intake 100 (two basic units) from the academic session be issued to the institution. 3

4 Utkal university, Vill.- Bhubaneswar, Street/Road-Vani Vihar, Taluka/Mandal- Bhubaneswar, Town/City-Bhubaneswar, Dist.-Khurda, Orissa [B.Ed., M.Ed. and 4 year Integrated B.A.B.Ed./B.Sc. B.Ed. course] (Government) (Itself affiliating body) (ID No.7162) As decided in 257 th ERC Meeting, recognition granted to B.Ed., M.Ed. and 4 year Integrated B.A.B.Ed./B.Sc. B.Ed. courses respectively from the academic session vide orders dated with approved intake mentioned therein for each course. The institution filed W.P. (C) No of 2018 in the Hon ble High Court of Orissa. The Hon ble High Court disposed of the matter on with a direction inter alia: Considering the limited grievance of the petitioner, without expressing any opinion on the merits of the case, this Court disposes of the writ petition directing opposite party no.2 to take a decision on the representation filed by the petitioner vide Annexure-6 and pass appropriate order in accordance with law within a period of two months from the date of production of certified copy of this order. The Committee considered the order of the Hon ble High Court of Orissa and observed as under: It is needless to mention here that Hon ble Supreme Court of India in its order dated passed in W.P.(C) No.276 of 2012 titled as Maa Vaishno Devi Mahila Mahavidyalaya Vs. State of UP & Ors, the Hon ble Court had fixed up a schedule for recognition and affiliation of Teacher Training Institutions by fixing the cut off date as 3 rd March of each year and hence, the NCTE is bound to follow the time schedule provided by the Hon ble Court for the said purpose. Formal recognition granted to B.Ed., M.Ed. and 4 year Integrated B.A.B.Ed./B.Sc. B.Ed. courses respectively from the academic session by ERC remains unchanged. A reasoned order be issued to the institution in this regard. ER [Reply of LOI / SCN Reply after LOI/No reply in response to LOI] KD College of Education, Plot No.- 32, 26, 31, Street No.- NH 84, Vill.- Parasia, PO.- Dalsagar, Tehsil/Taluka-Buxar, Town/City-Buxar, Dist.- Buxar, Bihar (D.El.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Private) (Bihar School Examination Board) (ERCAPP4195) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply in response to SCN issued after LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Formal permission order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation, 2014 for D.El.Ed. programme with an intake 100 (two basic units) from the academic session be issued to the institution College of Teacher Education, Bhagalpur, Street/Road- Ghanta Ghar, Taluka/Mandal- Nagarnigam Bhagalpur, Dist.- Bhagalpur, Bihar (M.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Government) (Tilka Manjhi Bhagalpur University) (Application No.- ERCAPP ) (ID No.-7585) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply in response to SCN issued after LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Formal permission order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation, 2014 for M.Ed. programme with an intake 50 (one basic unit) from the academic session be issued to the institution. 4

5 TC College of Teachers Education, Street/Road - I.T.Road, Vill - I.T. Road, Kangpokpi, Taluka/Mandal - Kangpokpi, Town/City-I.T. Road, Kangpokpi, Dist - Senapati, Manipur (B.Ed.) (Private) (Application No.- ERCAPP ) (ID No.-9892) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply in response to SCN issued after LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: Submitted photocopy of FDRs Rs.5 lakh & Rs.7 lakh are not in joint mode. Original FDRs required to be submitted. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for recognition be not refused on the above point. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision Deo Nagina Teacher Training College, Plot No. 3, Vill.- Mohiuddinpur, PO.- Hansadih, Tehsil/Taluka- Masaurhi, Town/City- Masaurhi, Dist.- Patna, Bihar (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (Bihar School Examination Board) (ERCAPP3835) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply in response to SCN issued after LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: Original FDRs Rs.5 lakh & Rs.7 lakh towards endowment and reserve fund in joint operation mode as per NCTE Regulations, 2014 are not submitted. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for recognition be not refused on the above point. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision Province College, Vill. - Tetelia, Street/Road - NH 37, Taluka/Mandal - Sonapur, Town/City - Tetelia, Dist. - Kamrup, Assam (B.Ed.) (Private) (Gauhati University) (Application No.-ERCAPP ) (ID No.11061) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply of LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: Faculty list is not in the NCTE prescribed proforma. (ii) Faculties in Physical Education, Art & Music are appointed on part-time basis, which is not accepted as per NCTE norms. (iii) Educational qualification certificates of appointed faculties are not submitted. (iv) Faculties at sl. No.1, 2 & 3 of the list are having SLET qualification, which is not accepted as per Gazette Notification dated Also the faculties at sl. No.6, 7, 8, 11, 13, 14, 15 & 16 do not have NET/Ph.D. qualification. (v) Experience certificate of Principal is not submitted. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for recognition be not refused on the above points. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision. 5

6 Manikchak College of Education D.Ed., Plot No.-381, 382, 382/653, 382/654, 382/65, Vill.-Jalalpur, P.O.-Dallutola, Tehsil/Taluka-Manikchak, Town/City-Malda, Dist.- Malda, West Bengal (B.Ed.-Addl. Course) (The West Bengal University of Teachers Training, Education Planing and Administration) (ERCAPP4280) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply in response to SCN issued after LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Formal permission order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation, 2014 for B.Ed. programme with an intake 100 (two basic units) from the academic session be issued to the institution Satyanam Satyaguru B.Ed. College, Vill. - Ayachigram, Bairiya, Muzaffarpur, Street/ Road - Ayachigram, Main Road, Taluka/Mandal - Kanti, Town/City - Ayachigram, Bairiya, Muzaffarpur, Dist. - Muzaffarpur, Bihar (B.Ed. and D.El.Ed.) (BRA Bihar University and Bihar School Examination Board) (Private) (ERCAPP ) (ID No.-8140) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply of LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: As per approved faculty list for B.Ed. course, all faculties except two are not having NET/Ph.D. qualification as per Gazette Notification dated published by NCTE. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for recognition be not refused on the above point. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision Jalpaiguri Dooars PTTI, Plot No.-338, Vill.-Ghagra, Street/Road- Ghagra, Taluka/Mandal - Alipurduar, Town/City - Ghagra, Dist. - Jalpaiguri, West Bengal (B.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Private) (The West Bengal University of Teachers Training, Education Planning and Administration) (Application No.- ERCAPP ) (ID No ) After considering and examining the application along with the documents submitted by the institution, the agenda note, the NCTE Act., the NCTE Regulations 2014 including Norms and Standards, guidelines received from the NCTE Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply in response to SCN issued after LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Formal permission order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation 2014 for B.Ed. programme with an intake 100 (two basic units) from the academic session be issued to the institution Coochbehar Advancement and Prosperity College of Education, Plot No.- LR 6948, 6949, 6950, 6952(P), Street No , Vill.- Khagrabari, PO.- Khagrabari, Tehsil/Taluka- Kotowali, Town/City- Cooch Behar, Dist- Cooch Behar, West Bengal (B.Ed.) (Private) (The West Bengal University of Teachers Training, Education Planing and Administration) (ERCAPP3646) After considering and examining the application along with the documents submitted by the institution, the agenda note, the NCTE Act., the NCTE Regulations 2014 including Norms and Standards, guidelines received from the NCTE Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply of LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Formal recognition order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation 2014 for B.Ed. programme with an intake 100 (two basic units) from the academic session be issued to the institution. 6

7 Coochbehar Advancement and Prosperity College of Education, Plot No.- LR 6948, 6949, 6950, 6952(P), Street No , Vill.- Khagrabari, PO.- Khagrabari, Tehsil/Taluka- Kotowali, Town/City- Cooch Behar, Dist- Cooch Behar, West Bengal (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (ERCAPP3657) After considering and examining the application along with the documents submitted by the institution, the agenda note, the NCTE Act., the NCTE Regulations 2014 including Norms and Standards, guidelines received from the NCTE Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply of LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Formal recognition order under clause 7(16) of the NCTE Regulation 2014 for D.El.Ed. programme with an intake 100 (two basic units) from the academic session be issued to the institution Anjali Memorial College of Education and Training, Plot No. - 15, 16, Vill - Damodarpur, PO - Karanjali, Tehsil/Taluka - Kusumpukuria, Town/City - Karanjali, Dist. - South 24 Parganas, West Bengal (B.Ed.) (Private) (The West Bengal University of Teachers Training, Education Planing and Administration) (ERCAPP2701) After considering and examining the application along with the documents submitted by the institution, the agenda note, the NCTE Act., the NCTE Regulations 2014 including Norms and Standards, guidelines received from the NCTE Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply of LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: a. A representation dated Nil received on from Mr. Dipak Roy, President of Anjali Memorial College of Education and Training requesting for permission to stop processing for recognition, followed by a copy of resolution dated passed by the Management not to run the college due to financial crisis. b. Meanwhile, another letter dated received from Mr. Ashim Roy, Secretary of Karanjali Foundation for Human Resource Development, Karanjali, Kulpi, South 24 Pgs. along with documents in compliance of Letter of Intent u/c 7(13) for processing the same for grant of recognition, which is contradictory. c. The institution be asked to submit the following: Copy of resolution of the Committee along with ID proof i.e. Aadhar Card of the members. (ii) An affidavit on Rs.100/- stamp paper duly signed (with address) by Judicial Magistrate. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for recognition be not refused on the above point. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision. A copy of SCN be endorsed to Mr. Ashim Roy, Secretary of Karanjali Foundation for Human Resource Development, Karanjali, Kulpi, South 24 Pgs., West Bengal And Mr. Dipak Roy, President of Anjali Memorial College of Education and Training, West Bengal Anjali Memorial College of Education and Training, Plot No. - 15, 16, Vill - Damodarpur, PO - Karanjali, Tehsil/Taluka - Kusumpukuria, Town/City - Karanjali, Dist. - South 24 Parganas, West Bengal (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (ERCAPP2595) After considering and examining the application along with the documents submitted by the institution, the agenda note, the NCTE Act., the NCTE Regulations 2014 including Norms and Standards, guidelines received from the NCTE Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply of LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: a. A representation dated Nil received on from Mr. Dipak Roy, President of Anjali Memorial College of Education and Training requesting for permission to stop processing for 7

8 recognition, followed by a copy of resolution dated passed by the Management not to run the college due to financial crisis. b. Meanwhile, another letter dated received from Mr. Ashim Roy, Secretary of Karanjali Foundation for Human Resource Development, Karanjali, Kulpi, South 24 Pgs. along with documents in compliance of Letter of Intent u/c 7(13) for processing the same for grant of recognition, which is contradictory. c. The institution be asked to submit the following: Copy of resolution of the Committee along with ID proof i.e. Aadhar Card of the members. (ii) An affidavit on Rs.100/- stamp paper duly signed (with address) by Judicial Magistrate. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for recognition be not refused on the above point. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision. A copy of SCN be endorsed to Mr. Ashim Roy, Secretary of Karanjali Foundation for Human Resource Development, Karanjali, Kulpi, South 24 Pgs., West Bengal And Mr. Dipak Roy, President of Anjali Memorial College of Education and Training, West Bengal. ER VTR U/S 14/ District Institute of Education & Training (DIET), Dima, Hasao, Street/Road - K. K. Road, Vill. - Kalachand, Taluka/Mandal - Maibang, Town/City - Kalachand, Dist. - N. Cachar Hills, Assam (B.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Government) (SCERT, Assam) (Application No.-ERCAPP ) (ID No ) Hqrs. from time to time and VTR, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Letter of Intent under clause 7(13) of NCTE Regulation 2014 be issued to the institution for one basic unit. The institution is required to submit the faculty list as per Gazette Notification No.237 of NCTE published on which stipulates that for the post of Principal/HOD, Ph.D. qualification is essential and for the post of lecturer either Ph.D. (as per UGC Regulations, 2009) or NET qualifications. ER [SCN Reply after VT] District Institute of Education & Training, Nagaon, Vill - Bheleuguri, Street/Road - NH-37, Taluka/Mandal - Niz-Bheleuguri, Town/City - Bheleuguri, Dist - Nagaon, Assam (B.Ed. and D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Government) (Bodoland University and SCERT, Assam) (ERCAPP ) (ID No.10504) Hqrs. from time to time, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Letter of Intent under clause 7(13) of NCTE Regulation 2014 be issued to the institution for one basic unit for each applied course. ER VTR U/S 14/ HAM-AK Rural College of Education, Vill - Kawaimari Chalchali, Street/Road - Dhing Road, Taluka/Mandal - Kachomari, Town/City - Kawaimari Chalchali, Dist. - Nagaon, Assam (B.Ed. & D.El.Ed.) (Private) (Gauhati University and SCERT, Assam) (ERCAPP ) (ID No.10928) Hqrs. from time to time and VTR, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: Total built up area mentioned in the VT Report as 3600 Sq. Mts. which is less than required 4000 Sq. 8

9 Mts. for 2 units each applied course as per NCTE Regulations, The institution be asked to submit an affidavit giving willingness for B.Ed. and D.El.Ed. limit only. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for recognition be not refused on the above point. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision Panagarh Primary Teachers Training Institute, Plot No /4417, Street No.-PTTI Street, Vill.-Panagarh, PO.-Panagarh Bazar, Tehsil/Taluka-Trilokchandrapur Gram Pamchayat, Town/City - Panagarh, Dist. - Bardhaman, West Bengal (B.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Private) (University of Burdwan) (ERCAPP4165) Hqrs. from time to time and VTR, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Letter of Intent under clause 7(13) of NCTE Regulation 2014 be issued to the institution for one basic unit. The institution is required to submit the faculty list as per Gazette Notification No.237 of NCTE published on which stipulates that for the post of Principal/HOD, Ph.D. qualification is essential and for the post of lecturer either Ph.D. (as per UGC Regulations, 2009) or NET qualifications. The institution be asked to submit the FDRs of Rs.5.00 and Rs lakh towards endowment fund and reserve fund in the joint name of RD, ERC, NCTE and institution with the reply of letter of intent Dr. C.C. Mahato Teachers Training College, Plot No , Vill.-Sardaha, PO.- Sardaha, Tehsil/Taluka-Chas, Town/City-Bokaro, Dist.-Bokaro, Jharkhand (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (Jharkhand Academic Council) (ERCAPP3120) Hqrs. from time to time and VTR, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Letter of Intent under clause 7(13) of NCTE Regulation 2014 be issued to the institution. The institution be asked to submit the FDRs of Rs.5.00 and Rs lakh towards endowment fund and reserve fund in the joint name of RD, ERC, NCTE and institution with the reply of letter of intent Dr. C.C. Mahato Teachers Training College, Plot No , Vill.-Sardaha, PO.- Sardaha, Tehsil/Taluka-Chas, Town/City-Bokaro, Dist.-Bokaro, Jharkhand (B.Ed.) (Private) (Vinoba Bhave University) (ERCAPP3083) Hqrs. from time to time and VTR, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Letter of Intent under clause 7(13) of NCTE Regulation 2014 be issued to the institution. The institution is required to submit the faculty list as per Gazette Notification No.237 of NCTE published on which stipulates that for the post of Principal/HOD, Ph.D. qualification is essential and for the post of lecturer either Ph.D. (as per UGC Regulations, 2009) or NET qualifications. The institution be asked to submit the FDRs of Rs.5.00 and Rs lakh towards endowment fund and reserve fund in the joint name of RD, ERC, NCTE and institution with the reply of letter of intent. 9

10 Abhiruchi Institute of Physical Education, Plot No.- Dag-225, 226 & 229 Patta 1&3, Street No.- PWD. Road, Vill.- Gobhali, PO.- Chandrapur, Tehsil/Taluka- Mayang, Town/City- Chandrapur, Dist.- Kamrup, Assam (B.P.Ed.) (Private) (Gauhati University) (ERCAPP2255) Hqrs. from time to time and VTR, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Letter of Intent under clause 7(13) of NCTE Regulation 2014 be issued to the institution. The institution be asked to submit the FDRs of Rs.5.00 and Rs lakh towards endowment fund and reserve fund in the joint name of RD, ERC, NCTE and institution with the reply of letter of intent Sova Rani College of Education, Plot No.- 143, 145, Vill.- Gobindapur, PO.- Birampur, Tehsil/Taluka- Birahimpur, Town/City- Malda, Dist- Malda, West Bengal (B.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Private) (The West Bengal University of Teachers Training, Education Planing and Administration) (ERCAPP3155) Hqrs. from time to time and VTR, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Letter of Intent under clause 7(13) of NCTE Regulation 2014 be issued to the institution. The institution is required to submit the faculty list as per Gazette Notification No.237 of NCTE published on which stipulates that for the post of Principal/HOD, Ph.D. qualification is essential and for the post of lecturer either Ph.D. (as per UGC Regulations, 2009) or NET qualifications. The institution be asked to submit the FDRs of Rs.5.00 and Rs lakh towards endowment fund and reserve fund in the joint name of RD, ERC, NCTE and institution with the reply of letter of intent. ER [Appeal Case] J.P. College of Education, Vill.- Biyabani, Street / Road- NH-31, Taluka/ Mandal:- Biharsharif, Town/City- Biyabani, Dist.- Nalanda, Bihar (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (Bihar School Examination Board) (ERCAPP ) (ID No.10912) As decided in 249 th ERC meeting, recognition to D.El.Ed. course was refused vide order dated The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE HQs. against the refusal order of ERC and the Appellate Authority vide order No /E-72184/2018 Appeal/20 th Mtg.-2018/17 th, 19 th & 20 th November, 2018/72889 dated remanded back the case to ERC with a direction to take further action according to the NCTE Regulations, The ERC re-viewed the matter in accordance with the appeal order as well as documents relating to Letter of Intent submitted by the institution earlier and decided as under:- Show Cause Notice has been decided for B.Ed. application (ERCAPP ) of the said institution, hence the application for D.El.Ed. course be kept in abeyance. Therefore, a letter be issued to the institution stating the above position. ER [Reply of LOI / SCN Reply after LOI/No reply in response to LOI] J.P. College of Education, Vill.- Biyabani, Street/Road- NH-31, Taluka/Mandal- Biharsharif, Town/City- Biyabani, Dist:- Nalanda, Bihar (B.Ed.) (Private) (Patliputra University) (ERCAPP ) (ID No.10915) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply in response to SCN issued after LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: LOI u/c 7(13) was issued on (ii) 1 st Show Cause Notice was issued on for compliance of LOI. 10

11 (iii) Reply vide letter dated received from the institution requesting for extension of time. (iv) The Committee has allowed 21 days time. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for recognition be not refused on the above points. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision. ER [Appeal Case] Gorakh Singh College B.Ed. Course, Vill-Maharajganj, Street/Road-Maharajganj, Taluka/Mandal- Maharajganj, Town/City-Maharajganj, Dist.- Siwan, Bihar (D.El.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Private) (Bihar School Examination Board) (ERCAPP ) (ID No.10146) As decided in 252 nd ERC meeting, permission to D.El.Ed. course was refused vide order dated The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE HQs. against the refusal order of ERC and the Appellate Authority vide order No /E-75551/2018 Appeal/14 th Mtg.-2018/30 th & 31 st July, 2018 dated remanded back the case to ERC with a direction to consider these documents to be submitted to them by the appellant and take further action as per the NCTE Regulations, The appellant is directed to forward to the ERC the documents submitted in the appeal within 15 days of receipt of the orders on the appeal. The ERC re-viewed the matter in accordance with the appeal order as well as document submitted by the institution vide letter dated and observed as under:- (ii) (iii) The institution is required to submit blue print of building plan duly signed & approved by Govt. Engineer. In the submitted building plan, signature of Jr. Engineer mentioned as Niraj Kumar Singh, whereas in the building completion certificate mentioned as NKS. Both are mismatching. The institution applied for D.El.Ed. in 2015 under code No. ERCAPP2370 and granted recognition for one basic unit of additional D.El.Ed. course. In 2016, the institution applied online for D.El.Ed.- Basic mentioning one unit under ID No and submitted representation dated for one unit of D.El.Ed.-additional intake and another representation dated ref. letter No.21/2018 mentioning D.El.Ed. additional course, which is contradictory. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for permission be not refused on the above points. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision Ananda Chandra Training College, Plot No.-966, Street No.- Nayabasti, Vill.- Nayabasti, P.O.-Jalpaiguri, Town/City - Jalpaiguri, Tehsil/Taluka - Kharia, Dist. - Jalpaiguri, West Bengal (M.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Private) (The West Bengal University of Teachers Training, Education Planing and Administration) (ERCAPP4131) As decided in 252 nd ERC meeting, permission to M.Ed. course was refused vide order dated The institution preferred an appeal to NCTE HQs. against the refusal order of ERC and the Appellate Authority vide order No /E-74430/2018 Appeal/19 th Mtg.-2018/4 th & 5 th October, 2018/72492 dated remanded back the case to ERC with a direction, after perusing the approved composite list submitted by the appellant, to obtain clarification from the appellant about the details of approved faculty independently for B.Ed. and M.Ed. courses and take further action as per the NCTE Regulations, The appellant is directed to forward to the ERC the approved composite list submitted in appeal, duly clarifying the details of faculty for both the courses independently, within 15 days of receipt of the orders on the appeal. The ERC re-viewed the matter in accordance with the appeal order as well as document submitted by the institution vide letter dated and observed as under:- Refusal order was issued on for non-compliance of documents related to LOI u/c 7(13). (ii) Appeal Committee directed to submit clarification related to approved faculty independently for B.Ed. and M.Ed. courses. 11

12 (iii) Supporting documents related to LOI as per Regulations for M.Ed. course such as copy of advertisement, letter from the affiliating body relating to its nominated Representative, fire safety certificate, list of schools for practice teaching, individual affidavit on Rs.10/- stamp paper of the faculty, affidavit on Rs.100/- stamp paper from the management, minutes of selection committee, educational qualification certificates of faculty, FDRs in joint mode, updation of relevant information on institution website are not submitted. (iv) As per M.Ed. faculty list, one guest Professor at sl. No.9 appointed, which is not accepted as per NCTE norms. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for permission be not refused on the above points. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 14(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision. ER [Reply of SCN before VT] Sarif Rajjak Education Trust, Street/Road - NH 31, Vill.-Shaltali, Purba Dehar, Taluka/Mandal - Jalpaiguri, Town/City - Shaltali, Purba Dehar, Dist. - Jalpaiguri, West Bengal (B.Ed. & D.El.Ed.) (Private) (The West Bengal University of Teachers Training, Education Planning and Administration and West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (ERCAPP ) (ID No.10294) Hqrs. from time to time and reply in response to SCN issued before VT, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: VT be constituted Science College (Auto), Hinjilicut, Street/Road-Main Road, Vill.-Hinjilicut, Taluka/Mandal - Hinjilicut, Town/City - Hinjilicut, Dist - Ganjam, Odisha (4 year Intgerated B.A. B.Ed./B.Sc. B.Ed. course) (Government-Aided) (Berhampur University) (Application No.-Not Generated) (ID No ) Hqrs. from time to time and no reply in response to SCN issued before VT, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: a. Show Cause Notice u/s 14(3)(b) was issued on on the following grounds: Processing fee not submitted. No documentary proof submitted regarding submission of processing fee. (ii) As per the print out copy of the online application it is observed that Application Number is not available. (iii) The printout copy of the online application received on i.e. after 15 th July As per the NCTE Hqrs letter dated the competent authority has approved for acceptance of the hard copy of the application received on or before 15 th July 2016 irrespective of the date of online submission of application on online portal. (iv) The application is not appeared on the dashboard of the online NCTE portal due to which online process cannot be carried out. b. Reply from the institution has not been received so far and stipulated period has already been over. The Committee is of the opinion that application bearing ID No of the institution regarding recognition to 4 year Intgerated B.A. B.Ed./B.Sc. B.Ed. programme is refused under section 14(3)(b) of NCTE Act

13 Rama Chandra Mardaraj Science College, Khallikote, Street/Road-Khallikote, Vill. - Khallikote, Taluka/Mandal - Khallikote, Town/City - Khallikote, Dist-Ganjam, Odisha (4 year Intgerated B.A. B.Ed./B.Sc. B.Ed. course) (Government- Aided) (Berhampur University) (Application No.-Not Generated) (ID-11005) Hqrs. from time to time and no reply in response to SCN issued before VT, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: a. Show Cause Notice u/s 14(3)(b) was issued on on the following grounds: Processing fee not submitted. No documentary proof submitted regarding submission of processing fee. (ii) As per the print out copy of the online application it is observed that Application Number is not available. (iii) The printout copy of the online application received on i.e. after 15 th July As per the NCTE Hqrs. letter dated the competent authority has approved for the acceptance of the hard copy of the application received on or before 15 th July 2016 irrespective of the date of online submission of application on online portal. (iv) The application is not appeared on the dashboard of the online NCTE portal due to which online process cannot be carried out. b. Reply from the institution has not been received so far and stipulated period has already been over. The Committee is of the opinion that application bearing ID No of the institution regarding recognition to 4 year Intgerated B.A. B.Ed./B.Sc. B.Ed. programme is refused under section 14(3)(b) of NCTE Act ER [Reply of LOI / SCN Reply after LOI / No reply in response to LOI] DIET Cum PTE College Sasaram, Plot No.-129, 130, Street No.- G. T. Road, Vill.- Fazaiganj, PO.- Sasaram, Tehsil/Taluka- Sasaram, Town/City - Sasaram, Dist. - Rohtas, Bihar (D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Government) (Bihar School Examination Board) (ERCAPP2013) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and no reply in response to SCN issued after LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: LOI u/c 7(13) was issued on , followed by Show Cause Notice dated and for compliance of LOI, reply awaited. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for permission be not refused on the above point. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 15(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision. 13

14 ER [No reply of SCN after VT] District Institute of Education and Training (DIET), Dumraon Buxar, Plot No.-691, 692, 694, 695, 696, 697, 700, Vill.-Dumraon, PO.-Dumraon, Tehsil/Taluka-Dumraon, Town/City-Dumraon, Dist-Buxar, Bihar (D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Government) (Bihar School Examination Board) (ERCAPP2528) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and no reply in response to SCN issued after VT, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: a. Show Cause Notice u/s 15(3)(b) was issued on on the following ground: There is no justification to accord permission for additional intake of D.El.Ed. course as the building plan and building completion certificate of the existing building and proposed institution is under construction and not available in the submitted VT Report. b. Reply from the institution has not been received so far and stipulated period has already been over. The Committee is of the opinion that application bearing Code No.ERCAPP2528 of the institution regarding permission to additional intake of D.El.Ed. programme is refused under section 15(3)(b) of NCTE Act Primary Teacher Education College (upgraded BITE), Dariyapur, Purvi Champaran, Plot No.-2261, Street No.- Dariyapur, Vill.-Dariyapur, PO.-Dariyapur, Tehsil/Taluka- Areraj, Town/City-Areraj, Dist.-Purba Champaran, Bihar (D.El.Ed.-Addl. Intake) (Government) (Bihar School Examination Board) (ERCAPP2408) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and no reply in response to SCN issued after VT, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: a. Show Cause Notice u/s 15(3)(b) was issued on to the institution as well as Government of Bihar on the following ground: No water facility, electric connection, reading rooms, instructional materials, equipments of Music, Art & Craft and internet connectivy is there in the institution. b. Reply from the institution as well as Government of Bihar has not been received so far and stipulated period has already been over. The Committee is of the opinion that application bearing Code No.ERCAPP2408 of the institution regarding permission to additional intake of D.El.Ed. programme is refused under section 15(3)(b) of NCTE Act ER [Misc Case] Jot Kanuramgarh Mahatma Primary Teachers Training Institute, Vill./PO.- Jotkanuramgarh, P.S.- Daspur, Dist.-Paschim Medinipur, West Bengal (D.El.Ed.) (Private) (West Bengal Board of Primary Education) (APE00706) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply in response to SCN issued after VT, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and decided as under: Letter of Intent under clause 7(13) of NCTE Regulation 2014 be issued to the institution for one basic unit. The institution be asked to submit the FDRs of Rs.5.00 and Rs lakh towards endowment fund and reserve fund in the joint name of RD, ERC, NCTE and institution with the reply of letter of intent. 14

15 Ashu Kisku Memorial and Rabi Kisku Teachers Training Institute, Plot No , Vill.-Lupungdih, PO.- Tankacha, Tehsil/Taluka- Chandil, Town/City- Chandil, Dist.-Pashchim Singhbhum, Jharkhand (B.Ed.) (Private) (Kolhan University) (ERCAPP656) Recognition granted to B.Ed. course with an intake of 100 from the academic session vide order No dated , followed by revised order dated with an intake of 100 (two basic units) from the academic session The Committee considered the documents of the institution submitted time to time regarding change of Internal Management Committee and its members and some dispute between two parties pertaining to old and new Management of the institution and observed as under: The institution is required to submit a copy of resolution copy of the Management signed & mentioning complete address of all committee members with their Aadhar card. The change of committee members be submitted in an affidavit Rs.100/- Non-judicial stamp paper duly notarized by Judicial Magistrate. A letter be issued to the institution to submit reply within 21 days from the date of issue of the letter for taking appropriate decision by ERC thereon. A copy of the same be endorsed to both parties of the Management viz. Mr. Jagadish Mahato and Mr. Jay Ram Prasad, who claimed as Secretary of the institution. ER [Reply of LOI / SCN Reply after LOI / No reply in response to LOI] Kamla Bhubaneswar B.Ed. College, Vill.- Chandour, Street/Road- Main Road, Taluka/ Mandal- Bagwanpur, Town/City- Chandour, Dist.- Begusarai, Bihar (D.El.Ed.-Addl. Course) (Private) (Bihar School Examination Board) (ERCAPP ) (ID No.9286) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and reply in respose to SCN issued after LOI, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: As per building completion certificate, total built up area mentioned as 3032 Sq. Mts. which is less for running existing B.Ed. (100 intake) + proposed D.El.Ed. (100 intake) as per NCTE Regulations, (ii) Original FDRs of Rs.5 lakh & Rs.7 lakh towards endowment and reserve fund in joint operation mode as per NCTE Regulations, 2014 are not submitted. Show Cause Notice be issued to the institution as to why the application for permission be not refused on the above points. The Committee therefore, provides last opportunity under section 15(3)(b) of the NCTE Act 1993 to the institution to submit its reply within 21 days from the issue of this letter before the Committee takes final decision Vina Karuna Teacher Training College, Street/Road - Mortanga Road, Vill. - Purana Dumka, Taluka/Mandal - Kewat Para, Town/City - Purana Dumka, Dist. - Dumka, Jharkhand (B.Ed.) (Private) (Sido Kanhu Murmu University) (Application No.-ERCAPP ) (ID No ) Hqrs. from time to time, VTR and letter dated from Registrar, Sido-Kanhu Murmu University, the Committee discussed the matter in detail and observed as under: Letter of Intent u/c 7(13) was issued in favour of the institution on basing upon the required documents including No Objection Certificate dated from the affiliating body submitted by the institution along with application, but in the meantime a letter bearing No.SKMU/IC/112/2018 dated issued by Registrar of Sido-Kanhu Murmu University received through NCTE Hqrs. stating that NOC had not been issued by the University to the institution. 15